|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Department of Anaesthetics, Intensive Care Unit and Scottish Liver Transplant Unit, Royal Infirmary, Edinburgh, Scotland.
Correspondence to: Dr Timothy S Walsh, Department of Anaesthetics, Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, Lauriston Place, Edinburgh, Scotland EH3 9YW
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: Prospective observational study.
Setting: The ICU of a major teaching hospital.
Patients: Twelve patients with fulminant hepatic failure; 30 other critically ill patients in whom a pulmonary artery catheter was in place.
Interventions: None.
Measurement and results: The precision of whole-blood lactate measurements was assessed in 30 patients with critical illnesses of variable etiology who had a wide range of arterial lactate concentrations. The reliability of lactate measurements decreased with increasing lactate concentration. In each patient with liver failure, pulmonary lactate flux was calculated on three occasions using the Fick principle. Arterial blood lactate concentration was consistently higher than venous concentrations, indicating lactate release by the lungs (mean difference, 0.15 mmol/L; 95% confidence interval, 0.09 to 0.21; p < 0.001). Mean pulmonary lactate production for the 12 patients was 83 mmol/h (range, 22 to 210 mmol/h). No patient had significant acute lung injury. Correlations were found among the arterial lactate concentration and both the arteriovenous (AV) lactate difference (p < 0.025) and pulmonary lactate production (p < 0.05), but not with acid-base status or cardiac output. The reliability of individual AV lactate difference calculations and pulmonary lactate flux calculations was poor.
Conclusion: The lungs release lactate in patients with fulminant hepatic failure at a rate proportional to the degree of systemic hyperlactatemia. However, the measurement errors associated with pulmonary lactate flux calculations using the Fick principle are large, so individual measurements should be interpreted with caution.
Key Words: acidosis acute liver failure critical illness lactate lung measurement error reproducibility of results
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We observed incidentally that in patients with fulminant hepatic failure, in whom hepatic lactate metabolism is significantly impaired, the systemic arterial lactate concentration was consistently slightly higher than lactate concentration in pulmonary arterial blood, despite the absence of clinically significant ALI. Based on this finding, the present study was carried out with the following objectives: (1) to investigate prospectively whether a lactate flux exists across the lungs of patients with fulminant hepatic failure; (2) to determine whether a relationship exists between pulmonary lactate flux and systemic hyperlactatemia or acidosis; and (3) to estimate the repeatability of pulmonary lactate flux calculations in critically ill patients.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Repeatability of Blood Lactate Measurements in Critically Ill Patients: The repeatability of whole-blood lactate measurements over the range of concentrations commonly observed in the intensive care setting was investigated using arterial blood samples taken from a mixed group of 30 critically ill patients admitted to the general ICU. In each case, a 2-mL sample of blood was drawn from the arterial catheter into a heparinized syringe. The sample was immediately placed in iced water and analyzed within 5 min of collection. Following thorough mixing, whole-blood lactate was measured five times on each sample. The means (SDs) of the five measurements were calculated and plotted against one another for each of the 30 patients in order to determine the relationship between the whole-blood lactate concentration and the precision of measurement.
Pulmonary Lactate Production in Patients With Fulminant Hepatic
Failure: Twelve patients with fulminant hepatic failure were
studied. Nine were female, 11 had acetaminophen toxicity, and 1 had
non-A, non-B, non-C hepatitis. All patients had grade III or IV hepatic
encephalopathy and were tracheally intubated, sedated (with alfentanil
and propofol infusions), paralyzed (with atracurium), and ventilated.
Patients were all studied within 24 h of admission to the
intensive therapy unit. In all cases, a 7.5F pulmonary artery
catheter was in situ, and cardiac output was monitored
semi-continuously using a cardiac output computer (Vigilance; Baxter
Edwards Critical-Care; Irvine, CA). Arterial BP was monitored via an
indwelling radial or femoral artery catheter. Patients were studied
after fluid resuscitation to a pulmonary artery wedge pressure of
10 mm Hg. No patients received enteral or parenteral nutrition
during or prior to the study period, except those in whom blood glucose
concentration was < 4 mmol/L. In these cases, dextrose was
administered IV to maintain blood glucose concentrations at 46
mmol/L.
Whole-blood lactate concentration was measured using an analyzer (YSI
2300 Stat Plus; Yellow Springs Instrument Co; Yellow Springs, OH),
which employs a technique based on membrane-bound enzyme electrode
methodology. L-lactate oxidase is immobilized in a thin
membrane placed over an electrochemical probe and catalyzes the
conversion of L-lactate to pyruvate and hydrogen peroxide,
the latter then being oxidized at the platinum anode. A stainless-steel
electrode completes the circuits, and a silver chloride electrode is
used as the reference electrode. The validity and precision of this
rapid method of lactate measurement in comparison with slower
traditional methods has been previously demonstrated.12
13
Instrument performance was checked daily against standards according to
the manufacturer's recommendations. The machine also self-calibrates
after every five samples or every 15 min. With this method, normal
whole-blood lactate concentration is
1 mmol/L.
To calculate pulmonary lactate flux, 2-mL samples of arterial and mixed venous blood were drawn simultaneously into heparinized syringes, and the cardiac output was recorded (this represented a running average over approximately 3 min). Mixed venous blood was drawn over at least 30 s from the distal port of the pulmonary artery catheter. Care was taken to ensure that samples were not contaminated with saline from flush systems or diluted with excess heparin, and all were analyzed within 5 min of collection. Pulmonary lactate flux was calculated from the Fick principle as the product of cardiac output and the AV whole-blood lactate concentration difference. In each patient, three pulmonary lactate fluxes were calculated over a 90-min period, during which time gas exchange did not alter significantly and no other therapeutic interventions or changes were made. PaO2, PaCO2, H+ concentration, and standard bicarbonate concentration (SBC) were determined with an analyzer (IL BGE, 1400 series; Instrumentation Laboratories; Lexington, MA), using the arterial samples. At the beginning of the study period, an ALI score was calculated for each patient using the method described by Murray et al,14 and the alveolar-to-arterial oxygen tension gradient and the ratio of PaO2 to the fraction of inspired oxygen were determined. For these calculations, alveolar oxygen pressure was calculated using the simplified alveolar gas equation with the respiratory quotient measured using a metabolic monitor (Deltatrac; Datex; Helsinki, Finland).
Statistical Analysis
AV Lactate Gradient: The overall significance of the
AV lactate concentration difference in the 12 patients was determined
using a paired Student's t Test. The difference between the
arterial and mixed venous lactate concentrations was further
illustrated using the Bland and Altman method.15
The
relationship between the mean lactate concentration and the AV lactate
concentration difference was investigated by calculating the
product-moment correlation coefficient between these variables.
Pulmonary Lactate Flux: For each patient, the mean of the
three pulmonary lactate flux calculations was determined. The
relationship between this and the other measured physiologic variables
was investigated by calculating the Spearman rank correlation
coefficient (
). The repeatability of AV lactate difference and
pulmonary lactate flux calculations was calculated, with the assumption
that the amount of lactate released by the lungs did not change over
the 90-min study period, so that variability in pulmonary lactate flux
within each patient was attributable to measurement error alone.
Overall repeatability of pulmonary lactate flux measurements in the 12
patients was then estimated by calculating the within-patient SD, using
analysis of variance. Repeatability was calculated as 2.77 SD, which
represents the amount by which two measurements might differ because of
measurement errors at a confidence level of 95%. Thus, the larger the
repeatability the less accurate the measurement of interest. This
method of estimating and expressing repeatability has been described in
full elsewhere.16
The relationship between the
repeatability of pulmonary lactate flux calculations in individual
patients and the arterial lactate concentration was investigated by
calculating the correlation (
) between the precision (SD) of the
three calculations of pulmonary lactate flux for each patient and the
mean lactate concentration. A p value < 0.05 was considered
statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
= 0.63; p < 0.025), and with the
mean pulmonary lactate production (
= 0.57; p < 0.05). There
were no correlations between mean pulmonary lactate flux and cardiac
output, systemic acidemia (H+ concentration), or
systemic acidosis (SBC). Mean arterial lactate concentration did not
correlate with either the H+ concentration, the
SBC, or the cardiac output.
|
= 0.60; p < 0.05), as shown in Figure 3 . | Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
As predicted by the positive correlation between precision and size of lactate measurement in the mixed group of critically ill patients, the reliability of pulmonary lactate flux calculations decreased as the mean arterial lactate concentration increased. It is possible that some of the variability in the pulmonary lactate flux observed within patients occurred because of true physiologic variability over the study period rather than measurement error alone. However, the direction of variability was random in all patients and they were otherwise stable, so we consider it unlikely that true physiologic variability was significant. Values for blood lactate measurements can be falsely elevated by contamination with lactate-containing crystalloid solutions and falsely decreased by dilution with lactate-free crystalloid solutions in flush systems,18 but care was taken to avoid these factors in the present study. The use of citrate as an anticoagulant can also falsely lower blood lactate values, but heparin does not adversely affect accuracy.19 Previous studies of pulmonary lactate production have used plasma samples, and some made corrections for changes in hematocrit between pulmonary and systemic arterial blood,7 8 9 but this approach requires further laboratory measurements, which may introduce further measurement error rather than improve accuracy. The use of whole blood for analysis, as in the present study, is considered most accurate.11 19
Despite concerns regarding the reliability of individual measurements, our data indicate that the lungs of patients with fulminant hepatic failure release lactate. The mechanism of lactate production by the lungs in this, and in other conditions, is unclear. Previous studies have demonstrated lung lactate production, but only in patients with ALI in whom lactate production correlated with lung injury scores.7 8 9 The present study is the first to demonstrate lung lactate production in patients without significant lung injury. Lactic acidosis might occur in hypoperfused or hypoxic lung regions, but while these may exist in the lungs of patients with ALI, lung hypoxia was unlikely in the patients in the present study in whom pulmonary blood flow was high, pulmonary shunt was low, and clinically significant lung injury was not present. An alternative mechanism of lactate production, without acidosis, occurs as a result of enhanced cellular glucose uptake and accelerated glycolysis, which may occur as part of the stress response in the absence of hypoxia.5 Under these circumstances, the ratio of lactate to pyruvate remains normal (approximately 10:1). The mechanism of lung lactate release could be investigated further by examining lactate-pyruvate ratios across the lungs, although such measurements would be subject to considerable measurement error.
Pulmonary lactate flux correlated with the mean arterial lactate concentration. This association could indicate that the lungs contribute significantly to systemic hyperlactatemia in fulminant hepatic failure, as has been proposed in patients with ALI.7 8 Alternatively, lung lactate release may represent part of a generalized increase in lactate production by tissues, resulting in hyperlactatemia. The majority of patients were not acidotic, and recent studies indicate that inadequate global oxygen delivery is unusual in resuscitated patients with fulminant hepatic failure, so mechanisms of lactate production other than tissue hypoxia may be implicated.20 21 This conjecture is supported by the lack of relation between blood lactate concentrations and the degree of acidemia or acidosis. The presence of metabolic alkalosis in many patients, which is common in fulminant hepatic failure, may have contributed to hyperlactatemia by accelerating glycolytic production of pyruvate at a rate which exceeds cellular capacity to metabolise it via the citric acid cycle.22 Exogenous glucose supply can also stimulate lactate production, which may have contributed to hyperlactatemia in those patients receiving dextrose infusions to maintain normoglycemia.23 Hyperlactatemia can also result from reduced lactate clearance, which is likely in patients with fulminant hepatic failure as a result of impaired hepatic lactate metabolism.6
In conclusion, we have shown that the lungs of patients with fulminant hepatic failure release lactate into the systemic circulation in the absence of clinically significant ALI. Lung lactate release was associated with the degree of systemic hyperlactatemia, but not with acid-base variables. The accuracy of blood lactate measurements using a rapid enzymatic method decreased as the blood lactate concentration increased, so the repeatability of pulmonary lactate flux calculations in individual patients was low. In future studies which investigate lactate flux across organs in the critically ill, the accuracy of measurements will require careful consideration.
| Footnotes |
|---|
= Spearman rank
correlation coefficient; SBC = standard bicarbonate concentration Received for publication July 24, 1998. Accepted for publication February 16, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |