|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Pulmonary and Critical Care Division (Dr. Epstein), Department of Medicine, Tupper Research Institute, New England Medical Center, Boston, MA; and Tufts University School of Medicine (Ms. Vuong), Boston, MA.
Correspondence: Scott K. Epstein, MD, FCCP, Pulmonary and Critical Care Division, Box 369, New England Medical Center, 750 Washington St, Boston, MA 02111; e-mail: scott.epstein{at}es.nemc.org
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design and setting: Prospective observational study in an MICU of a tertiary-care academic medical center.
Patients: Five hundred eighty consecutive patients admitted to the MICU service and mechanically ventilated for a minimum of 12 h.
Results: There was no difference in overall hospital mortality rate (woman, 36.3%; men, 40.4%; p > 0.2). No differences in mortality rates were noted after stratification based on age, underlying comorbid condition, APACHE (acute physiology and chronic health evaluation) II score, indication for mechanical ventilation, or acute hepatic or renal failure. Using a multiple logistic regression model, gender was not independently associated with hospital mortality. No differences were found between men and women for a number of secondary outcomes, including likelihood of undergoing weaning trials, success of weaning trials, time between onset of mechanical ventilation and extubation, total time on mechanical ventilation, rate of unplanned extubations, need for reintubation or tracheostomy, or duration of MICU and hospital stay, after the onset of mechanical ventilation. The number and timing of orders written to withhold care were comparable between men and women.
Conclusions: Using univariate and multivariate analyses, we found no differences in hospital mortality rates between mechanically ventilated men and women. Differences in the process of care or gender-based treatment bias may explain previously reported differences in outcomes.
Key Words: extubation gender ICU mechanical ventilation outcome weaning
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
12 h of
mechanical ventilation. | Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Data Collection
A member of the research team made daily rounds in the MICU and
obtained clinical data. Initial clinical data that were recorded
included age, gender, indication for mechanical ventilation, presence
of significant chronic comorbid conditions, severity of illness scoring
using the acute physiology and chronic health evaluation (APACHE) II,
ventilator data, and arterial blood gas evaluation results. The initial
postintubation chest radiograph was reviewed to note the positioning of
the endotracheal tube. Subsequently, chest radiographs (and, if
obtained, chest CT scans) were reviewed daily for the presence of
barotrauma unrelated to central line insertion. Severity of illness
scoring using APACHE II, arterial blood gas measurements, and
measurement of the spontaneous breathing pattern (frequency [f]/tidal
volume [VT] ratio) were recorded at the onset of weaning
trials. The f/VT ratio was measured, using a
spirometer (Wright respirometer; Ferraris, England), during the
first minute of disconnection from the ventilator. The development of
acute hepatic failure and acute renal failure was noted.
Outcomes
Patients were followed daily until hospital discharge. The
principal study outcome was hospital mortality rate. Additional
secondary outcome measures included the following: days in the ICU and
days in the hospital after the initiation of mechanical
ventilation; total duration of mechanical ventilation (including
additional time resulting from reintubation); likelihood of undergoing
weaning trials; time from onset of mechanical ventilation to initiation
of weaning trials; total duration of weaning trials; need for
reintubation within 72 h of extubation; occurrence of unplanned
extubation; need for tracheostomy; and need for transfer to
rehabilitation or chronic/subacute care unit. We also recorded the time
and date when an order to withhold care was written.
Definitions
Indications for mechanical ventilation were the following:
respiratory failure (from asthma, COPD, upper airway obstruction,
pneumonia, acute lung injury, lobar collapse, pleural disease,
interstitial lung disease, pulmonary hemorrhage, pulmonary vasculitis,
pulmonary embolism, hypoventilation syndrome, respiratory muscle
dysfunction, anaphylaxis, or aspiration); cardiac failure (from
myocardial infarction/unstable angina, congestive heart failure,
cardiogenic shock, cardiac arrest, pericardial disease, arrhythmia, or
cor pulmonale); and other (acute renal failure, acute hepatic failure,
sepsis, acidosis, hemorrhagic or hypovolemic shock, GI bleeding
requiring transfusion, drug overdose, and acute CNS dysfunction,
including seizure, cerebrovascular accident, hemorrhage, infection, or
encephalopathy).
Chronic comorbid conditions included the following: active malignancy
(untreated or currently undergoing therapy); cirrhosis (proven by
biopsy or with evidence of portal hypertension); congestive heart
failure (history of left ventricle ejection fraction
40%); COPD
(compatible clinical history or FEV1/FVC ratio
< 0.70); chronic renal failure (long-term dialysis); diabetes
mellitus (on either oral hypoglycemic agent or insulin); HIV (positive
blood test for HIV); and organ transplantation (liver, kidney, bone
marrow, or heart).
Organ failure included the following conditions: acute hepatic failure
(bilirubin level,
5 mg/dL; international normalized ratio,
1.5) and acute renal failure (condition requiring dialysis,
excluding long-term dialysis patients)
Malpositioning of the endotracheal tube was considered to be present if the tube was in the right mainstem bronchus, within 2 cm of the carina or above the thoracic inlet.
Barotrauma was defined as the presence of pneumothorax, pneumomediastinum, or subcutaneous air (unrelated to central line placement) noted either on chest radiograph or, if obtained, on chest CT scan.
Statistical Analysis
Continuous variables are reported as mean ± SD. Continuous
variables were compared using an independent Student's t
test for normally distributed variables and a nonparametric test
(Wilcoxon rank sum test) for nonnormally distributed variables. For
dichotomous variables, either a
2 test or a
two-tailed Fisher's Exact Test was used. The primary analysis compared
men and women. A secondary analysis compared hospital survivors and
nonsurvivors. We subsequently performed a multiple logistic regression
analysis with hospital survival as the dependent variable. Independent
variables included those found to have a p value < 0.20 during
univariate analysis, gender, and variables previously shown by
multivariate analysis to be associated with mortality (eg,
reintubation). A forward stepwise approach was used, with a
value of 0.05 used as the limit for determining entrance or
removal to or from the model. Assuming that approximately 60% of
mechanically ventilated patients in our MICU are men (estimated
mortality rate, 30%), a power analysis determined that 580 patients
were required to have an 80% chance of finding an absolute mortality
rate increase of 10% in mechanically ventilated women. All statistical
analyses was performed using computer software (SPSS, version 6.1; SPSS
Inc; Chicago, IL).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The issue of gender-based differences in outcomes for patients requiring mechanical ventilation has been indirectly explored in earlier reports. Studies examining mixed groups of surgical and medical patients with acute hypoxemic respiratory failure,10 all patients ventilated for > 24 h,11 or patients with acute respiratory failure12 found no differences in outcomes when men were compared to women in univariate analysis. More recently, Kollef5 studied referrals to a military hospital and found higher mortality rates for mechanically ventilated women. With multiple logistic regression analysis, controlling for severity of illness and organ dysfunction, this independent effect of gender disappeared. In a subsequent study of combined MICU and surgical ICU patients in two tertiary-care university hospitals, Kollef et al6 found higher mortality rates for women that persisted after controlling for age, ARDS, APACHE II scores, and the number of dysfunctional organs. The authors controlled for some (eg, COPD and diabetes) but not all (eg, chronic congestive heart failure, chronic renal failure, cirrhosis, active malignancy, HIV, and organ transplantation) of the chronic comorbid conditions that may impact survival.
In contrast, both prior to and after controlling for a wide array of chronic comorbid conditions, we found gender not to be an independent predictor of survival for mechanically ventilated MICU patients. In our multivariate model, we controlled for age, severity-of-illness scoring, chronic comorbid conditions, and indications for mechanical ventilation (eg, acute lung injury and sepsis). Although we did not use the organ system dysfunction score used by Kollef et al,6 we did control for important extrapulmonary organ failure, including acute hepatic failure and acute renal failure.
A number of explanations have been offered for possible differences in mortality rates between men and women, including the following: referral bias; gender-based differences in physiology; hormonal or immunologic distinctions; or treatment bias.3 4 5 6 13 14 15 16 17 18 Kollef et al6 found that the relative risk (RR) was higher for women in the surgical ICU (RR, 2.3) than for those in the MICU (RR, 1.3). In addition, these authors noted that male nonsurvivors were more likely to die while still on mechanical ventilation and were less likely to have mechanical ventilation actively withdrawn. Our finding of equivalent outcomes could relate to the fact that men were not treated as aggressively as women. The analysis of withholding-of-care rates, time to withholding of care, time from withholding of care to time of death, and severity-of-illness scoring clearly shows that this is not the case. That is, when the process of care is uniform in an MICU, the outcomes for men and women are the same. The implications are clearly very important. Critical care physicians who find disparities in outcomes for MICU patients need to look carefully at whether differences in the process of care or gender-based treatment biases are present. Furthermore, our findings should provide new impetus to address the surgical ICU experience to determine whether true physiologic variability or disparity in the process of care explain gender-based differences in outcomes.
Our findings confirm previous observations that women were more likely to experience malpositioning of the endotracheal tube at initial intubation.19 This finding had no effect on mortality, most likely because of rapid detection from routine postintubation radiographs and timely repositioning of the endotracheal tubes. Consistent with previous studies, women had a higher f/VT ratio than men, although differences in duration or success of weaning trials were not noted.20 21 We speculate that if weaning or extubation had been systematically delayed because of an elevated f/VT ratio, women would have been disproportionately subjected to needlessly prolonged mechanical ventilation and a worse outcome.
The gender-based differences in mortality rates for patients with long-term congestive heart failure and drug overdose deserve further comment. The difference in mortality rate for the former group is explained by the fact that men in that group were more likely to have underlying active malignancy (15/51 men vs 2/27 women; p < 0.05) and tended to be intubated with an acute myocardial infarction (13/51 men vs 3/27 women; p = 0.11). The difference in outcome for the drug overdose subgroup is attributable to the distribution of overdose type. Specifically, 68% of men, compared to just 30% of women, overdosed on alcohol, narcotics, or sedatives. Only 1 of 30 such patients died. In contrast, five of six acetaminophen overdoses (all complicated by hepatic failure) occurred in women, two of whom died. Among other sources of overdose (theophylline, cocaine, calcium channel blockers, anticonvulsants, and tricyclic antidepressants), the mortality rates for men and women were similar (1/11 men vs 2/11 women).
In conclusion, among MICU patients requiring mechanical ventilation, we found no difference in hospital mortality rate between men and women. Previously reported differences may have been related to the influence of data from surgical patients in the study cohort. Our findings suggest that differences in the process of care or gender-based treatment bias may explain previously reported differences in outcomes.
|
|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received for publication September 17, 1998. Accepted for publication March 25, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
N. R. MacIntyre, S. K. Epstein, S. Carson, D. Scheinhorn, K. Christopher, and S. Muldoon Management of Patients Requiring Prolonged Mechanical Ventilation: Report of a NAMDRC Consensus Conference Chest, December 1, 2005; 128(6): 3937 - 3954. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D V Pilcher, M J Bailey, D F Treacher, S Hamid, A J Williams, and A C Davidson Outcomes, cost and long term survival of patients referred to a regional weaning centre Thorax, March 1, 2005; 60(3): 187 - 192. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. N. Gong, Z. Wei, L.-L. Xu, D. P. Miller, B. T. Thompson, and D. C. Christiani Polymorphism in the Surfactant Protein-B Gene, Gender, and the Risk of Direct Pulmonary Injury and ARDS Chest, January 1, 2004; 125(1): 203 - 211. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Esteban, A. Anzueto, F. Frutos, I. Alia, L. Brochard, T. E. Stewart, S. Benito, S. K. Epstein, C. Apezteguia, P. Nightingale, et al. Characteristics and Outcomes in Adult Patients Receiving Mechanical Ventilation: A 28-Day International Study JAMA, January 16, 2002; 287(3): 345 - 355. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. E. Behrendt Acute Respiratory Failure in the United States : Incidence and 31-Day Survival Chest, October 1, 2000; 118(4): 1100 - 1105. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |