|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Mayo Medical School, Mayo Clinic, and Mayo Medical Center, Rochester, MN.
Correspondence to: Udaya B. S. Prakash, MD, Pulmonary, Critical Care, and Internal Medicine, East-18, Mayo Building, Mayo Medical Center, Rochester, MN 55905-0001; e-mail: prakash.udaya{at}mayo.edu
Abstract
Bronchoscopy is currently the most commonly employed invasive procedure in the practice of pulmonary medicine. Both the rigid and flexible bronchoscopes are used to diagnose and treat various pulmonary disorders. The main diagnostic indications include pulmonary involvement by neoplasms, infections, diffuse lung diseases, and airway problems. Bronchoscopic needle aspiration remains an underutilized technique in the staging of lung cancer. Newer techniques such as bronchoscopic ultrasound appear promising and may lead to improved diagnostic yield from bronchoscopic procedures. The bronchoscope is used in application of laser therapy, brachytherapy, electrocautery, cryotherapy, placement of airway stents, and balloon dilatation to relieve airway obstruction caused by malignant and benign airway lesions.
Key Words: brachytherapy, bronchoscopy, cryotherapy, electrocautery, fluorescence bronchoscopy, laser therapy, phototherapy, stents, ultrasound
The technique and clinical application of bronchoscopy had their origins in 1897, when Gustav Killian of Freiburg, Germany, used a rigid endoscope to examine the airways. Chevalier Jackson of Philadelphia refined the rigid bronchoscope, which was the only type of instrument available for the evaluation of airways until the early 1970s, when Shigeto Ikeda developed the flexible fiberoptic bronchoscope and introduced it into clinical use. Subsequent refinements in both rigid and flexible bronchoscopes and ancillary equipment have significantly improved the diagnostic and therapeutic potential of bronchoscopy. Development of newer concepts in the diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary diseases has led to increased clinical applications for bronchoscopic procedures. As a result, bronchoscopy is perhaps the most commonly used invasive diagnostic and therapeutic procedure in pulmonology. This paper provides a brief overview of several types of bronchoscopic procedures, sometimes described as "interventional bronchoscopic procedures," and their advantages and disadvantages.
Basic Instrument
Both the rigid and flexible bronchoscopes have undergone many modifications. The newer modifications in the rigid bronchoscope have established it as the ideal instrument for debulking of large tumors in the major airways, dilatation of tracheobronchial strictures, laser bronchoscopy, insertion of airway prostheses (stents), and extraction of tracheobronchial foreign bodies.1 2 3 The flexible bronchoscope is used in > 95% of all bronchoscopic procedures. Indeed, there are very few bronchoscopic procedures that cannot be accomplished with the flexible bronchoscope. Presently, many ancillary instruments are available to accomplish various diagnostic and therapeutic procedures via the flexible bronchoscope. Ultrathin flexible bronchoscopes permit inspection of airways in infants and neonates. Flexible bronchoscopes with a larger working channel enable the bronchoscopist to insert larger biopsy forceps, balloon catheters, laser fibers, and other instruments into the airways to obtain larger and better-quality biopsy specimens.
The traditional fiberoptic bronchoscope is gradually giving way to videobronchoscope. The latter is a flexible bronchoscope equipped with a charge-coupled device at its distal tip. The bronchoscopic images are digitally captured and transmitted to a video processor for display on a television monitor. The advantage is that the excellent images can be simultaneously visualized by many, making it an excellent tool for teaching purposes. The images can also be stored in several digital formats. The disadvantages include the added expense of purchasing video equipment and a computer terminal, and the larger working and storage space required. The major drawback is the loss of ability to view the image through the headpiece of the flexible bronchoscope; the bronchoscopist has to depend on the video monitor to visualize bronchoscopic findings. The image on the monitor is only as good as the monitor. The traditional fiberoptic instrument remains very valuable for direct visualization of airways.
Diagnostic Bronchoscopy
Routine bronchoscopic visualization to detect endobronchial abnormalities, BAL for the identification of many infectious and certain noninfectious lung diseases, and the use of bronchoscopy in brushing and biopsy of both visible airway lesions and bronchoscopically invisible parenchymal lung lesions are standard practice. The following discussion pertains to certain diagnostic procedures not routinely performed by all bronchoscopists.
Bronchoscopic Needle Aspiration
Bronchoscopic needle aspiration (BNA) of lymph nodes located in
the paratracheal, subcarinal, and perihilar areas is useful in the
diagnosis and staging of thoracic malignancies. The technique can also
be used in the diagnosis of endobronchial lesions that are
submucosal,4
and peripheral nodules and masses. The
bronchoscopic needle has been used to drain bronchogenic and
mediastinal cysts located adjacent to major airways. Although BNA is
easy to learn and perform, it remains underused by
bronchoscopists.5
6
The aspiration needle is available in
19-gauge, 20-gauge, and 21-gauge sizes and can be inserted through the
working channel of the flexible bronchoscope. The diagnostic rate for
non-small cell carcinoma has ranged from 43 to 83%.5
7
Complications are rare and include pneumothorax and hemomediastinum.
Serious bleeding is seldom encountered. More commonly, inadvertent
passage of the needle through the wall of the working channel of
the flexible bronchoscope leads to expensive damage to the inner lining
of the bronchoscope.8
Fluorescence Bronchoscopy
Fluorescence bronchoscopy is a technique that detects early
mucosal cancer by differentiating autofluorescence in normal and
abnormal mucosa. When the normal bronchial mucosa is illuminated via
the bronchoscope, a higher fluorescence is observed. Mucosa containing
abnormal or malignant cells produces decreased autofluorescence. This
phenomenon is used to detect mucosal changes suggestive of either
premalignant or malignant lesions in the airway mucosa. Mucosal changes
observed by routine (white-light) bronchoscopy can be compared with
those observed via green-light bronchoscopy. Early reports show that
that this technique, when used as an adjunct to standard bronchoscopy,
may enhance the ability to localize small neoplastic lesions,
especially intraepithelial lesions.9
10
Bronchoscopic Ultrasound
Clinical application of bronchoscopic ultrasound examination of
the tracheobronchial tree is still in the investigational stage. The
major advantage of this technique is the ability to visualize, via
ultrasound, the extra-airway structures that cannot be seen through the
bronchoscope.11
12
The major technical problem is the
inability to consistently provide the coupling of the ultrasound probe
to the bronchial wall to generate meaningful images of the
extrabronchial structures. To overcome this, flexible bronchoscopes are
being fitted with water-inflatable balloons. This will permit constant
360-degree contact between the wall of the airway and the ultrasound
probe. Preliminary studies have shown the ability to identify
mediastinal structures including lymph nodes, great vessels, and
esophagus (Fig 1
). The identification of lymph nodes and their relation to airways may
help improve diagnostic techniques such as BNA for the diagnosis and
staging of thoracic tumors.13
14
The simultaneous
use of ultrasound-guided BNA is desirable, but currently the technology
is not available for clinical application.
|
Therapeutic Bronchoscopy
Therapeutic bronchoscopy accounts for more than half of all bronchoscopies. Therapeutic bronchoscopy to remove retained respiratory secretions, mucous plugs, and blood clots from the airways is common. In patients admitted to critical care units, up to 75% of bronchoscopies are for therapeutic purposes.19 20 Frequently, diagnostic and therapeutic bronchoscopies are performed simultaneously. The following discussion pertains to certain therapeutic procedures not routinely performed by all bronchoscopists.
Laser Bronchoscopy
Bronchoscopic treatment of airway malignancies is usually
considered in patients with surgically unresectable lesions. The
treatment is aimed at relieving obstructive symptoms rather than curing
the neoplasm. Bronchoscopic techniques used to treat obstructing airway
lesions, both benign and malignant, are listed in Table 1 .
|
|
Dilatation of Airway Stenosis
The rigid bronchoscope itself can be used as a bougie to dilate
malignant or benign airway stenosis. Repeated passage of rigid
bronchoscopes of gradually increasing diameters can be used to dilate
the trachea and mainstem bronchi. Balloon dilatation through either the
flexible or rigid bronchoscope is best suited for stenoses that are
short in length.29
Dilatation procedures are more
effective if the airway stenosis is intrinsic rather than extrinsic.
Most patients with chronic benign strictures require repeated
dilatations. All types of dilatation procedures are effective if
membranous or web-like lesions involving a very short length of the
airways cause strictures and stenoses. Transmural strictures and
strictures involving long segments of the airway require either
surgical or stent therapy.
Airway Prostheses (Stents)
Airway stents made of metal, silicone, or other materials
are available in various shapes and sizes (Fig 3
-5).30
31
Stents can be placed in the obstructed airways to
provide relief of symptoms caused by malignant or benign airway
disorders. Stent therapy is more effective in patients with tracheal or
main bronchial diseases than in those with airway diseases that involve
lobar and distal bronchi. Silicone stents seem better suited for both
benign and malignant airway lesions, whereas covered metal stents may
be useful in malignant airway stenosis. Use of the rigid bronchoscope
is essential for the insertion, manipulation, and removal of silicone
stents32
33
34
; metal stents can be inserted with the aid of
flexible bronchoscopy and/or fluoroscopic guidance. Complications seen
with silicone stents include migration of stent and inspissation of
thick mucous within the stent lumen. Metallic stents seem to promote
growth of granulation tissue, which makes it difficult to remove and
replace the stent. Uncovered metallic stents should not be inserted in
patients with malignant airway lesions because the growth of cancer
through the wire mesh negates the benefits of stent placement.
|
Electrocautery
Bronchoscopic electrocautery employs alternating electrical
current to produce coagulation and vaporization of endobronchial
lesions.37
Argon plasma coagulator is also used to
accomplish electrocautery therapy. Electrocautery probes are available
for use with either flexible or rigid bronchoscopes. The indications
for electrocautery are similar to those for cryotherapy. Immediate
relief of symptoms caused by airway obstruction can be achieved with
electrocautery in 55 to 75% of patients.38
39
40
41
42
The
advantages of electrocautery include less expensive equipment (compared
with lasers) and the ease of use through flexible or rigid
bronchoscopes.43
Complications include endobronchial fire,
hemorrhage, and inadvertent electrical shock to the operator or
patient. Overall, electrocautery seems to be a good alternative to the
more expensive laser therapy.
Cryotherapy
Bronchoscopic cryotherapy consists of cold-induced death of
malignant cells by repeated cycles of cold application followed by
thawing. Nitrous oxide or liquid nitrogen is most commonly used to
produce temperatures of -80°C. Cryoprobes are available for use
through rigid or flexible bronchoscopes.44
45
46
The
indications for cryotherapy are same as those for other types of
bronchoscopic therapies to treat airway neoplasms. Most importantly,
the lesion must be accessible to the cryoprobe through the
bronchoscope.37
Smaller polypoid lesions visible in the
distal airway are better suited for this type of therapy. Benign
lesions have been treated with cryotherapy.46
The
equipment is less expensive and easier to use than lasers. Subjective
improvements have been observed in > 75% of patients with malignant
airway lesions.47
48
Complications are few and minor. One
disadvantage is the longer duration of therapy required because of the
need for frequent freeze-thaw cycles. Repeat bronchoscopy is needed for
continued therapy in many patients.
Bronchoscopic Resection of Airway Lesions
Large obstructing airway tumors are suitable for
bronchoscopic resection. This is best accomplished with the rigid
bronchoscope rather than the flexible instrument. This type of purely
palliative therapy provides immediate relief of airway obstruction
secondary to large neoplasms in the trachea or mainstem bronchi.
Serious hemorrhage that may follow removal of tumor mass can be
controlled by tamponading the bleeding point with the rigid
bronchoscope itself. The flexible bronchoscope is ill-suited for this
purpose because of the small working channel and its inability to
remove large pieces of tumor and large volumes of blood.
Tracheobronchial Foreign Body
Rigid bronchoscopy is ideal for the extraction of aspirated
tracheobronchial foreign bodies, especially in pediatric
patients.49
In adults with airway foreign bodies, flexible
bronchoscopy is effective in 61% of cases, whereas rigid bronchoscopy
is successful in 98%.50
The flexible bronchoscope may be
used to extract a foreign body that is impacted in airways too distal
for access with the rigid bronchoscope. Newer ancillary equipment
enable the flexible bronchoscope to extract large foreign bodies in the
proximal airways.
|
|
Abbreviation: BNA = bronchoscopic needle aspiration
References
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
T.J. Shaw, S.L. Wakely, C.R. Peebles, R.L. Mehta, J.M. Turner, S.J. Wilson, and P.H. Howarth Endobronchial ultrasound to assess airway wall thickening: validation in vitro and in vivo Eur. Respir. J., June 1, 2004; 23(6): 813 - 817. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Ost, R. D. Shah, D. Fein, and A. M. Fein To Screen or Not To Screen: A Volatile Issue in Lung Cancer Chest, June 1, 2003; 123(6): 1788 - 1792. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Phillips, R. N. Cataneo, A. R.C. Cummin, A. J. Gagliardi, K. Gleeson, J. Greenberg, R. A. Maxfield, and W. N. Rom Detection of Lung Cancer With Volatile Markers in the Breath Chest, June 1, 2003; 123(6): 2115 - 2123. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. A. Keller, R. Hinerman, A. Singh, and F. Alvarez The Use of Endoscopic Argon Plasma Coagulation in Airway Complications After Solid Organ Transplantation Chest, June 1, 2001; 119(6): 1968 - 1975. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. M. Boiselle, A. Ernst, and D. D. Karp Lung Cancer Detection in the 21st Century: Potential Contributions and Challenges of Emerging Technologies Am. J. Roentgenol., November 1, 2000; 175(5): 1215 - 1221. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |