|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Department of Medical Sciences, Respiratory Medicine, and Allergology, Akademiska sjukhuset, Uppsala University, Sweden.
Correspondence to: Inger Dahlén, MD, Department of Medical Sciences, Respiratory Medicine, and Allergology, Akademiska sjukhuset, SE-751 85 Uppsala, Sweden; e-mail: inger.dahlen{at}lungmed.uu.se
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study objectives: To compare DTH and LAR tests in COPD patients and healthy controls, to investigate whether skin tests have any value in estimating nutritional status and outcome in COPD patients, and to see whether there is any relationship between DTH and LAR.
Methods: Twenty-five patients with stable COPD and 20 healthy controls were tested for DTH and LAR. The patients were investigated with spirometry and anthropometric measurements and were followed for 1 year.
Results: Both the LAR and DTH reactions were diminished in the patient group (p < 0.001) compared with controls. The skin tests did not correlate with anthropometric parameters. DTH correlated to lung function, which was expressed as FEV1 (percent predicted) (r = 0.56; p < 0.01), and LAR correlated to the number of exacerbations (at 3 months, r = - 0.61; p < 0.01). No correlation was found between LAR and DTH reactions.
Conclusions: We conclude that patients with COPD in stable condition have diminished DTHs and LARs. Our results indicate that the magnitude of the LAR may be a prognostic marker in patients with COPD.
Key Words: anthropometry COPD delayed hypersensitivity immunocompetence late allergic reaction nutritional status
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In a number of diseases with immunologic components, the patients capacity to develop the delayed type of hypersensitivity (DTH) is diminished ("anergy"). This is probably an effect of impaired T-lymphocyte function and CD4+ cell function in particular.12 DTH tests have been widely used to evaluate the nutritional status of patients13 and also to predict outcome.14 However, critical opinions about the utility of skin testing in nutritional assessment have also been expressed.15 16 The discovery of good instruments to assess nutritional status and prognosis in COPD patients would be of great value.
The immediate allergic skin reaction is caused by crosslinking with an antigen of immunoglobulin E (IgE) molecules on mast cells. The pathogenesis of the late phase of the allergic skin reaction is not completely understood, but it has been suggested that the T lymphocytes play an important role in inducing the inflammation that is necessary for the late allergic reaction (LAR) to develop.12 17 This reaction can also be induced by injecting antibodies to IgE intracutaneously in nonallergic persons.18 In this case, the antibodies crosslink IgE on the cell surface. We have previously shown that patients with lung cancer have an abnormally low capacity to elicit this reaction.19
The aim of this study was to compare LAR and DTH reactions in a group of COPD patients in the stable phase in comparison with healthy controls. Another aim was to investigate whether skin tests are useful for estimating nutritional status and whether DTH reactivity and LAR have any prognostic value in COPD patients. Finally, the aim was to compare DTH and LAR in order to see whether they are dependent on the same parts of the immune system.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
75% of the predicted
value. Patients were also excluded if they had taken oral
steroids during the 2 weeks prior to visit 1 or if they had a daily
dose of inhaled steroids of > 400 µg. Patients with a history of
allergy or other immunologic disorders were excluded. Treatment with
any immunomodulating agents was not permitted during the 2 weeks
immediately prior to skin testing. The control group consisted of 20 healthy, nonpregnant, nonallergic persons.
Each patient and control person gave his/her informed consent. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee at the Uppsala University Medical Faculty.
Study Design
The study design is presented in Figure 1
. The controls participated at visit 1 with skin and blood testing and
at visit 2 (48 h). The skin tests procedures were started at 9:00
AM on every patient and healthy control. The study ran
throughout the year. At visits 3 and 4 (6 and 12 months) and during
telephone contact (3 and 9 months), patients were asked how many
exacerbations they had had in the past 3 months. An exacerbation was
defined as an increase in dyspnea, increased or discolored sputum, or
any hospital contact in which bronchodilators or antibiotics were
given.
|
DTH Tests
Delayed skin reactivity was tested by injecting 0.1 mL of the
following antigens: Candida (Monilia albicans diluted in physiologic
saline solution, 1,000 protein nitrogen units/mL, using the
Dome-Hollister-Stier; Newbury, Berks, United Kingdom);
streptokinase-streptodornase, 50 U/mL
(Lederle/Cyanamid); mumps, 20 cfu/mL (Connaught Lab; Swiftwater,
PA); Trichophyton, 1/100 w/v (Connaught Lab); purified protein
derivative, 2 tuberculin units (SBL AB vaccine;
Stockholm, Sweden); and isotonic saline solution as the negative
control. One single batch of each allergen was used throughout the
study. These antigens were injected intracutaneously on the left
forearm. After 48 h, the maximum diameter of the indured part and
the diameter at the right angle were measured. A sum of the two
perpendicular diameters of at least 10 mm was assessed as positive and
the number of positive tests was summarized. In addition, the mean size
of all the DTH tests in each individual was calculated. Subjects
without any positive DTH tests were classified as anergic.
IgE-Mediated Skin Reactions
On the right forearm, 100 µL of rabbit antihuman IgE (1/50 v/v
[Sigma; St. Louis, MO]) was injected intracutaneously. A
single batch of antibody solution was kept frozen in an undiluted state
and was thawed and diluted shortly before use. The size of the indured
swelling of the skin (the weal) was measured. The sum of the largest
diameter and its perpendicular was registered. The reaction at 20 min
was defined as the immediate allergic skin reaction, and that observed
at 4 to 24h was defined as the LAR. The maximum diameter sum measured
at 4, 8, or 12 h was recorded as the size of the LAR.
Blood Samples
Serum albumin and retinol-binding protein were measured as
indicators of visceral protein stores, and total lymphocyte count was
measured as an indicator of immunocompetence. In addition, hemoglobin
was measured. The analyses were made using standard techniques at the
hospitals Department of Clinical Chemistry.
Anthropometric Measurements
The following anthropometric measurements were performed:
weight, height, triceps skinfold thickness (TSF), and arm
circumference (AC). In healthy controls, only weight and height
were measured. Body mass index (BMI) was calculated as (weight in
kilograms)/(height in meters)2. TSF, which is an
indicator of the subcutaneous fat store, was measured with a skinfold
caliper on the posterior aspect of the nondominant arm by pinching a
fold of skin from the underlying triceps muscle. AC was measured 15 cm
above the olecranon. The mid-arm muscle circumference (MAC) reflects
the skeletal muscle mass and was calculated from the following
equation:
![]() |
Statistical Methods
The statistical analyses were performed using software
(StatViewSE+graphics; Abacus Concepts; Berkeley, CA).
Comparisons between patients and controls were performed using the
Mann-Whitney U test for continuous variables, whereas the
2 test was used for comparisons of
proportions. To find a correlation between continuous variables and
variables on an ordinal scale, Spearmans rank correlation test was
performed. For the simultaneous evaluation of more than two
factors, multiple linear regression was performed. A p value
0.05
was regarded as statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
In the COPD group, neither the DTH reaction nor the LAR correlated with the BMI or the other anthropometric parameters (Table 3 ). However, the patient with the lowest BMI and MAC (16.0 kg/m2 and 72.5% of the reference value) was anergic in terms of both DTH and LAR. Another three patients had a BMI < 20 kg/m2, but their MAC was normal. The four patients with a BMI < 20 kg/mg2 had decreased skin reactivity in comparison with the others. The number of positive DTH reactions was 0.5 vs 1.5 (p = 0.052), whereas the mean size of all DTH reactions was 2.45 mm vs 8.53 mm (p = 0.058) and the mean size of LAR was 72 mm vs 112 mm (p = 0.36). There was no significant correlation between the blood parameters, albumin and retinol-binding protein, and the DTH or LAR.
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All of the healthy controls had at least two positive DTH reactions that correspond with previous studies in healthy subjects.24 The decrease in DTH reaction and LAR among the COPD patients indicates an impairment in their immune status. In addition, the total lymphocyte count, which also mirrors the immune status, decreased as compared to healthy controls.
DTH tests have been widely used in assessing nutritional status. Several studies have reported impaired DTH reactions among malnourished, hospitalized patients,25 26 as well as improved DTH reactivity after nutritional intervention.27 28 Hunter et al11 reported impaired DTH reactions and malnutrition in a group of COPD patients in stable condition. In the study by Laaban et al,29 DTH tests were performed in COPD patients with acute respiratory failure, and it was found that 85% of the patients who required mechanical ventilation were anergic. That result was influenced not only by malnutrition, but also by nonnutritional factors such as infection and old age. In the present study, five patients (20%) were anergic. Our patients were, however, obviously less sick than those of Laaban et al.29
DTH tests have also been claimed to be valuable prognostic indicators when it comes to mortality in heart-transplant14 and cancer patients.30 Patients with impaired DTH reactivity tended to have a poorer prognosis. In our study, we were not able to demonstrate any significant correlation between DTH reactivity and prognosis when looking at the number of exacerbations within 12 months. On the other hand, the DTH tests correlated to the severity of the disease in terms of lung function (FEV1 [percent predicted]). However, the LAR test was a better prognostic factor because it showed a negative correlation to exacerbations within 12 months.
The immediate allergic reaction was not affected in the COPD patients in this study. The same result was found previously19 when patients with uremia, sarcoidosis, or cancer also had normal immediate allergic reactions, although cancer patients had an impaired LAR. This difference may be due to the fact that the immediate reactions are mainly effects of histamine being released from mast cells, whereas the LARs are the results of complex inflammatory reactions.
The mean BMI (24 kg/m2) in our patient group appears to indicate that nutritional status in the group was normal. On the other hand, the range was very large (16 to 43 kg/m2), which means that both underweight and overweight patients participated in the study. When TSF was examined, the mean value was very low, which means that subcutaneous fat stores were affected in this group. In contrast, the MAC (reflecting the skeletal muscle mass) was normal. In our study, we found no correlation between DTH or LAR tests and the anthropometric variables. This might be explained by the limited number of patients enrolled and the fact that so few of them were severely malnourished. However, this may also be due to the difficulties involved in assessing the nutritional status of COPD patients. So, although body weight and BMI are both easy to measure, they could be misleading in the event of fluid retention, which is common among COPD patients.31 One indication of poorer protein stores was the lower levels of albumin and retinol-binding protein seen in the patient group compared with the control group. The anthropometric measurements, TSF and AC, are simple and inexpensive. Serial measurements in the same patient are more valuable and the method is better in patients with long-term nutritional problems.32 There is also a limitation in that the distribution of total body fat is not always uniform. Particularly in the elderly, adipose tissue may be concentrated in the trunk.33 In our view, the COPD patients in the study were undernourished as a group, in spite of anthropometric parameters, which were not always especially abnormal.
The control group in this study was not age- or sex-matched with the patients, which is a weakness. Whereas the differing proportions of men and women in the two groups probably had no influence on the results, the age difference could have influenced the results. In the elderly, the response to DTH tests is reduced in frequency and size, and antibody production could also be reduced in old age.34 It is not known whether the LAR is affected by age. In our study, the differences between the COPD and control group remained after adjustments for age and sex, thereby indicating that the difference in age or sex is not the cause of the difference in skin reactivity. One disadvantage of the study is the fact that the number of exacerbations was only based on the patients own reports and not on objective parameters.
The study ran throughout the year. Allergen-induced immediate skin reactions are known to vary with season,35 but seasonal variation in anti-IgE-induced or DTH reactions has not been reported in the literature.
Even if both the DTH reaction and the LAR decreased in this group of patients with a stable COPD condition, there was no statistically significant correlation between the two of them. The DTH reaction was related to the severity of the disease, and the LAR was related to the prognosis. T lymphocytes are important in the development of both types of reactions.12 17 36 The DTH reaction appears to be more dependent on the TH137 and the LAR appears to be more dependent on the TH212 type of T cells. The malnutrition or other components of the COPD disease may thus affect the two parts of the immune system in different ways.
We conclude that patients with COPD in stable condition have a diminished DTH and LAR, which can be caused in part by malnutrition, but other factors that affect immunocompetence in COPD may play a role. Our results indicate that the magnitude of the LAR may be a prognostic marker in patients with COPD.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
This study was supported by the Bror Hjerpstedt Foundation, Sweden; the Swedish Heart and Lung Foundation, Sweden; and Astra, Sweden.
Received for publication February 18, 1999. Accepted for publication June 10, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |