(Chest. 1999;116:500S-503S.)
© 1999
American College of Chest Physicians
Non-small Cell Lung Cancer*
Role of Surgery for Stages I-III
F. Griffith Pearson, MD
*
From Toronto General Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Correspondence to: F. Griffith Pearson, MD, Toronto General Hospital, Eaton North 10233, 200 Elizabeth St, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5G-2C4; e-mail: pearson{at}user.rose.com
 |
Abstract
|
|---|
Survival following surgical resection of non-small cell lung
cancer (NSCLC) has improved since the 1960s, although the 5-year
survival rate remains low. This article provides an overview of the
role of surgery for NSCLC stages I-III, with a focus on optimizing
long-term survival in those patients with resectable disease. Topics
explored include diagnosis and staging, indications for resection,
types of resection, and indications for adjuvant therapy. A review of
the literature indicates a clear survival advantage for complete
resection, and is suggestive of an advantage for mediastinal lymph node
dissection (vs lymph node sampling) and neoadjuvant therapy (vs
adjuvant therapy).
 |
Introduction
|
|---|
In
the past 40 years, there have been no major advances that significantly
modified overall survival for resectable, non-small cell lung cancer
(NSCLC). The reported cumulative 5-year survival for patients with
primary lung cancer managed by resection has increased from 23% in
19601
to about 54% by 1990.2
However, this
increase is not due to improved surgical technique, but to more
accurate preoperative evaluation and selection of patients with
completely resectable tumors. A considerable reduction in operative
mortality has also been observed since the 1960s, when mortality varied
from 10 to 25% for pulmonary resection.1
These rates
decreased to approximately 4% in the early 1980s3
and
slightly over 1% in 1994.4
Despite these improvements,
lung cancer continues to be an extremely lethal disease, responsible
for more cancer deaths than any other solid tumor.5
Resection remains the best treatment option for patients with localized
NSCLC. Unfortunately, up to 70% of patients have disease that is too
advanced for resection,6
highlighting the need for early
diagnosis. The purpose of this article is to provide an overview of the
role of surgery for NSCLC stages I-III, with a focus on optimizing
long-term survival in those patients with completely resectable
disease.
 |
Diagnosis and Staging
|
|---|
Accurate diagnosis and histologic classification are made with the
assistance of imaging techniques (including CT, MRI, positron emission
tomography [PET], and bone scans), sputum cytology, needle biopsy,
bronchoscopy, thoracoscopy, mediastinoscopy, bone marrow biopsy, and
blood tests. Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery is also becoming
popular due to demonstrated diagnostic accuracy and the ability of the
surgeon to visualize the entire lung, pleura, and mediastinum.
In 1997, the International Staging System for Lung Cancer was revised
(Table 1)
7
to address the heterogeneity of end results within stage
groups and the lack of specificity in stage classification. Changes
from the previous system include the division of stage I into two
categories (IA and IB) based on tumor size, and the division of stage
II into two categories (IIA and IIB) based on tumor size and nodal
status. The category T3N0 has been moved from stage IIIA to stage IIB.
Satellite tumor nodules in the same lobe as the primary tumor are now
classified as T4, and separate metastatic tumor nodules in the
ipsilateral, nonprimary tumor lobe are classified as M1.
Until recently, the accurate evaluation of nodal status has warranted
wide application of invasive staging with mediastinoscopy, or a variant
of this procedure. In the 1980s, CT came into use as a noninvasive
method for mediastinal staging. However, the disappointing
false-positive and false-negative rates associated with CT
(approximately 50%8
and 20%,9
respectively)
have resulted in the continued search for a more accurate noninvasive
procedure. Investigators conducting nodal staging studies using PET
scanning with 2-[fluorine-18]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG) have
reported encouraging results, with FDG PET proving significantly more
accurate than CT in the demonstration and staging of nodal
involvement.10
11
These investigators reported correct
diagnosis and staging with PET in 94% and 96% of cases, respectively,
compared to 61% and 79% of cases evaluated by CT. Vansteenkiste et
al12
evaluated the accuracy of FDG PET, visually
correlated with CT in nodal staging, and concluded that a "negative
mediastinum" on PET scan reduces the need for mediastinoscopy. The
role of single-photon emission CT in the assessment of mediastinal
involvement has also been evaluated, with results suggesting that
single-photon emission CT is more accurate than CT13
14
but somewhat less accurate than PET15
in the detection of
lymph node metastases.
Intraoperative Staging
Accurate and deliberate intraoperative staging with evaluation of
lymph nodes is essential. The need for the precise assessment of lymph
nodes cannot be overestimated, because the presence or absence of N2
disease profoundly affects both survival and the selection of patients
for resection. The role of mediastinal lymph node dissection at the
time of primary tumor resection is controversial. Although no survival
advantage for dissection has been conclusively
demonstrated,16
17
dissection is recommended over
sampling, because it should increase the chance for a complete
resection with minimal associated morbidity and add little operative
time (approximately 20 to 30 min) to surgery.18
19
20
 |
Indications for Resection
|
|---|
The goal of surgery in NSCLC is to provide complete resection of
the primary tumor with no macroscopic tumor remaining and
microscopically free margins. Only patients in whom a complete
resection is anticipated are selected for surgery. These include
patients with T1 to T4, N0 and N1 tumors and selected N2 cases.
Multiple primary lung cancers can be resected with a reasonable
prospect of survival if the tumors appear completely resectable.
Survival following metachronous cancer resection has been found to be
higher than that following synchronous resection, with two studies
reporting 5-year survivals of 20% and 37% in the former group and 0%
in the latter group.21
22
In patients with hematogenous metastases, resection of metastases to
the brain and adrenal gland can, in selected cases, result in
significant survival benefit.23
24
25
26
The median survival of
untreated brain metastasis is only one to two months.27
A
review of > 230 patients who underwent surgical treatment for brain
metastases from lung cancer reported survival rates of 46.3% and
14.7% at 1 year and 3 years, respectively, with a predicted 5-year
survival rate of 12.5%.24
In a randomized study of 48
patients with solitary brain metastasis, surgery plus radiotherapy
resulted in significantly better local control and longer survival than
radiotherapy alone.23
In patients with clinically isolated
adrenal metastasis, surgical treatment was associated with a 5-year
survival rate of 24%.26
A significant advantage has been
observed with the combination of surgery and chemotherapy compared to
chemotherapy alone in patients with adrenal metastases.25
 |
Types of Resection
|
|---|
Limited Resection
Standard resections for primary lung cancer are pneumonectomy,
lobectomy, and sleeve lobectomy in selected cases. Lesser or limited
operations include wedge resection, segmental resection, nonanatomic
limited resection, and sleeve lobectomy. Advantages for these lesser
resections include preservation of pulmonary function, decreased
perioperative mortality and morbidity, and the potential for future
further pulmonary resection, if necessary. In patients with equivocal
levels of pulmonary reserve, these advantages must be weighed against
the potential for increased local recurrence and decreased survival.
It is generally accepted that sleeve lobectomy is an appropriate
alternative to pneumonectomy in well-selected cases; survival data
appear similar, although well-conducted randomized trials have yet to
be reported.28
29
In 1982, the Lung Cancer Study Group initiated a randomized trial
comparing limited resection (segmental or wedge) with standard
lobectomy or pneumonectomy in patients with T1, N0 primary lung cancer.
The results showed an unacceptably high local recurrence rate in
patients managed by lesser resection.30
In addition,
slightly less-favorable survival data were reported for the
limited-resection group. These observations were recently confirmed by
Landreneau et al,31
who reported a trend toward increased
local recurrence and decreased survival in patients managed by wedge
resection compared to lobectomy, using limited-access, video-assisted
techniques for resection.
Extended Resection
Locally advanced lung cancer (stage IIIA) has a considerably
less-favorable prognosis than earlier stages. If a complete resection
is judged possible, two groups of patients with stage IIIA disease are
potential surgical candidates: those with T3 tumors (primary tumors
with direct extension beyond the lung into adjacent structures), and
carefully selected cases with primary tumors with ipsilateral N2
involvement (ipsilateral mediastinal lymph node
metastases).6
In patients whose tumors are completely
resected, worthwhile survival may be obtained. Importantly, there is no
alternative form of treatment that provides comparable results at this
time.
T3 Tumors: If the primary tumor is locally
advanced, radical surgery is recommended if the lesion is judged
amenable to complete resection. Such resections include the main
carina, chest wall, diaphragm, pericardium, lower roots of the brachial
plexus in superior sulcus tumors, and the superior vena cava (in
selected instances). Dartevelle et al32
described a
technique for segmental resection of the superior vena cava with graft
replacement in a small number of patients with primary lung cancer.
Unfortunately, most cases of vena cava obstruction are due to
metastatic disease in mediastinal nodes and are almost certainly
incurable by such radical surgery. Graft replacement should only be
considered when involvement is due to extension from the primary tumor
itself. Favorable survival is reported following extended resection of
the chest wall in cases without lymph node involvement. An actuarial
5-year survival rate of up to 54% has been found in patients
undergoing chest wall resection for N0 disease.33
34
N1,
and particularly N2, status in such patients confers a much less
favorable outcome. The role of adjuvant radiotherapy in patients
undergoing chest wall resection remains uncertain.35
36
Superior sulcus tumors are rare, accounting for 5% of all lung
cancers.37
Treatment commonly includes preoperative
radiation followed by surgery, but may also involve intraoperative
brachytherapy and postoperative radiation. Most surgeons consider
superior sulcus tumors with N2 disease to be inoperable. Dartevelle et
al38
reported the innovation of an anterior approach for
the resection of some superior sulcus tumors in 1993. Overall 5-year
survival of patients who underwent resection and radiation was 33% in
one recent study.39
Optimal 5-year survival (60%) has
been reported following combined lobectomy and en bloc chest wall
resection.40
N2 Disease: Surgery in patients with N2 disease
remains controversial, and the importance of selection in this setting
cannot be overemphasized. The most carefully staged patients reported
to date were those entered into the Lung Cancer Study Group trials
between 1977 and 1989. In 1987, Mountain et al41
reported
survival in this group of patients with N2 disease.41
All
of these patients were completely resected using the criteria
established by the Lung Cancer Study Group. In 37 patients with
completely resected N2 squamous cell cancer and in 38 patients with
completely resected N2 adenocarcinoma or large cell tumors, cumulative
5-year survival rates of 46% and 24% were reported, respectively.
The current criteria for operability in N2 disease includes
non-small cell histology, ipsilateral metastases, and complete
resectability anticipated by the surgeon. The involved nodes should be
discrete, and not adherent to the trachea, subcarinal airway, or great
vessels. If the most proximal nodal stations in the superior
mediastinum (usually level 2) are involved, most surgeons consider the
patient to be inoperable.1
En bloc lymphadenectomy is
recommended, and the majority of practitioners add some form of
adjuvant therapy in these locally advanced cases.
Although N3 tumors preclude a complete and potentially curative
resection using standard techniques, Hata et al42
reported
long-term survival in some patients with primary tumors of the left
lung and nodal metastases on both sides of the superior mediastinum who
underwent a mediansternotomy, left pneumonectomy, and bilateral radical
lymphadenectomy. All patients received some form of adjuvant therapy.
Since this report, other Japanese centers have adopted this approach,
although most surgeons still consider this method of uncertain value.
 |
Indications for Adjuvant Therapy
|
|---|
The current status of adjuvant and neoadjuvant trials in NSCLC
were recently reviewed by Einhorn,43
who concluded that no
survival benefit is observed following postoperative adjuvant
radiotherapy, chemotherapy, or chemoradiation. At present, there is no
clear indication for adjuvant therapy in surgically resected cases
other than in the context of a clinical trial. In contrast, three
studies have demonstrated improved survival following neoadjuvant
therapy,44
45
46
although the case numbers are quite small
(ie, a maximum of 30 patients per treatment arm). Newer,
more effective agents may provide hope for the future of chemotherapy
in this setting.
 |
Summary
|
|---|
For patients with lung cancer, surgical resection provides the
best possibility of cure in selected patients. It is again emphasized
that surgical resection is only applicable for patients in whom a
complete resection is deemed possible. Accurate diagnosis and staging
maximizes this potential. Comprehensive evaluation of nodal status is
imperative. Extended resection can be effective in locally advanced
disease, with worthwhile survival possible in patients whose tumors are
completely resected. To date, adjuvant therapy confers no significant
survival benefit. At present, neoadjuvant therapy holds some promise in
the quest for improved survival following surgical resection in
patients with NSCLC.
 |
Footnotes
|
|---|
Abbreviations:
FDG = 2-[fluorine-18]fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose; NSCLC = non-small
cell lung cancer; PET = positron emission tomography
 |
References
|
|---|
-
Pearson, FG (1986) Lung cancer: the past twenty-five years. Chest 89(4 suppl),200S-205S[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Wada, H, Tanaka, F, Yanagihara, K (1996) Time trends and survival after operations for primary lung cancer from 1976 through 1990. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 112,349-355[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Ginsberg, RJ, Hill, LD, Eagan, RT, et al (1983) Modern thirty-day operative mortality for surgical resections in lung cancer. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 86,654-658[Abstract]
-
Wada, H, Nakamura, T, Nakamoto, K, et al (1998) Thirty-day operative mortality for thoracotomy in lung cancer. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 115,70-73[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Lung cancer resource center. American Cancer Society [on-line]. Available at: http://www.cancer.org. Accessed July 21, 1999
-
McCaughan, B (1997) Recent advances in managing non-small-cell lung cancer: 2. Surgery. Med J Aust 166(suppl),S7-S10
-
Mountain, CF (1997) Revision in the international system for staging lung cancer. Chest 111,1710-1717[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Dillemans, B, Deneffe, G, Verschakelen, J, et al (1994) Value of computed tomography and mediastinoscopy in preoperative evaluation of mediastinal nodes in non-small cell lung cancer: a study of 569 patients. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 8,37-42[Abstract]
-
De Leyn, P, Vansteenkiste, J, Cuypers, P, et al (1997) Role of cervical mediastinoscopy in staging of non-small cell lung cancer without enlarged mediastinal lymph nodes on CT scan. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 12,706-712[Abstract]
-
Steinert, HC, Hauser, M, Allemann, F, et al (1997) Non-small cell lung cancer: nodal staging with FDG PET versus CT with correlative lymph node mapping and sampling. Radiology 202,441-446[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Gupta, NC, Graeber, GM, Rogers, JS, et al (1999) Comparative efficacy of positron emission tomography with FDG and computed tomographic scanning in preoperative staging of non-small cell lung cancer. Ann Surg 229,286-291[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Vansteenkiste, JF, Stroobants, SG, De Leyn, PR, et al (1998) Lymph node staging in non-small-cell lung cancer with FDG-PET scan: a prospective study on 690 lymph node stations from 68 patients. J Clin Oncol 16,2142-2149[Abstract]
-
Chiti, A, Maffioli, LS, Infante, M, et al (1996) Assessment of mediastinal involvement in lung cancer with technetium-99m-sestamibi SPECT. J Nucl Med 37,938-942[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Yokoi, K, Okuyama, A, Mori, K, et al (1994) Mediastinal lymph node metastasis from lung cancer: evaluation with T1201 SPECT; comparison with CT. Radiology 192,813-817[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Higashi, K, Nishikawa, T, Seki, H, et al (1998) Comparison of fluorine-18-FDG PET and thallium-201 SPECT in evaluation of lung cancer. J Nucl Med 39,9-15[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Sugi, K, Nawata, K, Fujita, N, et al (1998) Systematic lymph node dissection for clinically diagnosed peripheral non-small-cell lung cancer less than 2 cm in diameter. World J Surg 22,290-295[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Izbicki, JR, Passlick, B, Pantel, K, et al (1998) Effectiveness of radical systematic mediastinal lymphadenectomy in patients with resectable non-small cell lung cancer: results of a prospective randomized trial. Ann Surg 227,138-144[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Martini, N (1995) Mediastinal lymph node dissection for lung cancer: the Memorial experience. Chest Surg Clin North Am 5,189-203[Medline]
-
Riquet, M, Manach, D, Saab, M, et al (1995) Factors determining survival in resected N2 lung cancer. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 9,300-304[Abstract]
-
Asamura, H, Nakayama, H, Kondo, H, et al (1996) Lymph node involvement, recurrence, and prognosis in resected small, peripheral, non-small-cell lung carcinomas: are these carcinomas candidates for video-assessed lobectomy? J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 111,1125-1134[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Ribet, M, Dambron, P (1995) Multiple primary lung cancers. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 9,231-236[Abstract]
-
Adebonojo, SA, Moritz, DM, Danby, CA (1997) The results of modern surgical therapy for multiple primary lung cancers. Chest 112,693-701[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Patchell, RA, Tibbs, PA, Walsh, JW, et al (1990) A randomized trial of surgery in the treatment of single metastases to the brain. N Engl J Med 322,494-500[Abstract]
-
Wronski, M, Arbit, E, Burt, M, et al (1995) Survival after surgical treatment of brain metastases from lung cancer: a follow-up study of 231 patients treated between 1976 and 1991. J Neurosurg 83,605-616[ISI][Medline]
-
Luketich, JD, Burt, ME (1996) Does resection of adrenal metastases from non-small cell lung cancer improve survival? Ann Thorac Surg 62,1614-1616[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Kim, SH, Brennan, MF, Russo, P, et al (1998) The role of surgery in the treatment of clinically isolated adrenal metastasis. Cancer 82,389-394[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Soo, EW, Galindo, EG, Levin, VA (1995) Brain tumors. Pazdur, R eds. Medical oncology: a comprehensive review 2nd ed. ,469-481 PRR Huntington, NY.
-
Tedder, M, Anstadt, MP, Tedder, SD, et al (1992) Current morbidity, mortality, and survival after bronchoplastic procedures for malignancy. Ann Thorac Surg 54,387-391[Abstract]
-
Deslauriers, J, Mehran, RJ, Guimont, C, et al (1993) Staging and management of lung cancer: sleeve resection. World J Surg 17,712-718[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Ginsberg, RJ, Rubinstein, LV (1995) Randomized trial of lobectomy versus limited resection for T1 N0 non-small cell lung cancer. Ann Thorac Surg 60,615-623[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Landreneau, RJ, Sugarbaker, DJ, Mack, MJ, et al (1997) Wedge resection versus lobectomy for stage I (T1 N0 M0) non-small-cell lung cancer. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 113,691-700[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Dartevelle, PG, Chapelier, AR, Pastorino, U, et al (1991) Long-term follow-up after prosthetic replacement of the superior vena cava combined with resection of mediastinal-pulmonary malignant tumors. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 102,259-265[Abstract]
-
Piehler, JM, Pairolero, PC, Weiland, LH, et al (1982) Bronchogenic carcinoma with chest wall invasion: factors affecting survival following en bloc resection. Ann Thorac Surg 34,684-691[Abstract]
-
McCaughan, BC, Martini, N, Bains, MS, et al (1985) Chest wall invasion in carcinoma of the lung: therapeutic and prognostic implication. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 89,836-841[Abstract]
-
Patterson, GA, Ilves, R, Ginsberg, RJ, et al (1982) The value of adjuvant radiotherapy in pulmonary and chest wall resection for bronchogenic carcinoma. Ann Thorac Surg 34,692-697[Abstract]
-
Shaw, EG, Brindle, JS, Creagan, ET, et al (1992) Locally recurrent non-small-cell lung cancer after complete surgical resection. Mayo Clin Proc 67,1129-1133[ISI][Medline]
-
Johnson, DE, Goldberg, M (1997) Management of carcinoma of the superior pulmonary sulcus. Oncology 11,781-785[Medline]
-
Dartevelle, PG, Chapelier, AR, Macchiarini, P, et al (1993) Anterior transcervical-thoracic approach for radical resection of lung tumors invading the thoracic inlet. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 105,1025-1034[Abstract]
-
Hagan, MP, Choi, NC, Mathisen, DJ (1999) Superior sulcus lung tumors: impact of local control on survival. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 117,1086-1094[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Ginsberg, RJ, Martini, N, Zaman, M, et al (1994) Influence of surgical resection and brachytherapy in the management of superior sulcus tumor. Ann Thorac Surg 57,1440-1445[Abstract]
-
Mountain, CF, Lukeman, JM, Hammar, SP, et al (1987) Lung cancer classification: the relationship of disease extent and cell type to survival in a clinical trials population. J Surg Oncol 35,147-156[ISI][Medline]
-
Hata, E, Hayakawa, K, Miyamoto, H, et al (1988) The incidence and prognosis of the contralateral mediastinal node involvement of the left lung cancer patients who underwent bilateral mediastinal dissection and pulmonary resection through a median sternotomy [abstract]. Lung Cancer 4,A87[CrossRef]
-
Einhorn, LH (1998) Neoadjuvant and adjuvant trials in non-small cell lung cancer. Ann Thorac Surg 65,208-211[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Pass, HI, Pogrebniak, HW, Steinberg, SM, et al (1992) Randomized trial of neoadjuvant therapy for lung cancer: interim analysis. Ann Thorac Surg 53,992-998[Abstract]
-
Rosell, R, Gómez-Codina, J, Camps, C, et al (1994) A randomized trial comparing preoperative chemotherapy plus surgery with surgery alone in patients with non-small-cell lung cancer. N Engl J Med 330,153-158[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Roth, JA, Fossella, F, Komaki, R, et al (1994) A randomized trial comparing perioperative chemotherapy and surgery with surgery with surgery alone in resectable stage IIIa non-small-cell lung cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst 86,673-680[Abstract/Free Full Text]
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. Licker, A. Spiliopoulos, J.-G. Frey, J. Robert, L. Hohn, M. de Perrot, and J.-M. Tschopp
Risk Factors for Early Mortality and Major Complications Following Pneumonectomy for Non-small Cell Carcinoma of the Lung*
Chest,
June 1, 2002;
121(6):
1890 - 1897.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
S. Elia, S. Griffo, M. Gentile, R. Costabile, and G. Ferrante
Surgical treatment of lung cancer invading chest wall: a retrospective analysis of 110 patients
Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg.,
August 1, 2001;
20(2):
356 - 360.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|