(Chest. 2000;117:226-232.)
© 2000
American College of Chest Physicians
Is Rest or Exercise Hypertension a Cause of a False-Positive Exercise Test?*
Todd D. Miller, MD, FCCP;
Timothy F. Christian, MD;
Thomas G. Allison, PhD;
Ray W. Squires, PhD;
David O. Hodge, MS and
Raymond J. Gibbons, MD
*
From the Division of Cardiovascular Diseases and Department of Internal Medicine (Drs. Miller, Christian, Allison, Squires, and Gibbons), and the Department of Biostatistics and Health Sciences Research (Mr. Hodge), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Correspondence to: Todd D. Miller, MD, FCCP, Mayo Clinic, East 16-A, 200 First Street SW, Rochester, MN 55905; e-mail: miller.todd{at}mayo.edu
 |
Abstract
|
|---|
Study objectives: To determine if a history of
hypertension or an exaggerated rise in exercise systolic BP is
associated with a false-positive exercise ECG.
Design,
setting, and patients: Retrospective analysis of the associations
between exercise-induced ST-segment depression and a history of
hypertension, exercise systolic BP, and several other clinical and
exercise test variables. Among 20,097 patients referred for exercise
tomographic thallium imaging in a nuclear cardiology laboratory at a
tertiary care center, 1,873 patients met inclusion criteria for this
study, which included no history of myocardial infarction or coronary
artery revascularization, a normal resting ECG, and normal exercise
thallium images.
Results: False-positive ST-segment
depression occurred in 20% of the population. A history of
hypertension was actually associated with a lower likelihood of
ST-segment depression (odds ratio, 0.70; 95% confidence interval
[CI], 0.55 to 0.89; p = 0.004). A higher peak exercise systolic BP
was associated with a higher likelihood of ST-segment depression (odds
ratio, 1.08 for each 10-mm Hg increase in systolic BP; 95% CI, 1.03 to
1.14; p < 0.001). However, the association between peak exercise
systolic BP and ST-segment depression was so weak that this measurement
could not be predictive in the individual patient
(R2 = 0.2%). For every 20-mm Hg increase in
peak exercise systolic BP, the percentage of patients with ST-segment
depression increased by only 3%.
Conclusions: In
patients with normal resting ECGs, we conclude the following: (1) a
history of hypertension is not a cause of a false-positive exercise
test, and (2) higher exercise systolic BP is a significant but weak
predictor of ST-segment depression.
Key Words: BP hypertension ST-segment depression
 |
Introduction
|
|---|
Hypertension
is often cited as a cause of false-positive ST-segment depression
during exercise testing.1
2
3
4
5
However, studies
demonstrating this relationship are few.6
7
8
9
10
ST-segment
depression occurs commonly in patients with left ventricular
hypertrophy, whether the etiology is hypertensive or valvular heart
disease.8
9
10
11
12
Because of the high prevalence of
false-positive stress tests in patients with left ventricular
hypertrophy and the limited sensitivity of the resting ECG for
detecting this condition,13
the value of exercise testing
for diagnostic purposes in hypertensive patients with chest pain has
been questioned.14
15
The American College of
Cardiology/American Heart Association exercise testing guidelines
indicate that there is an increase in false-positive stress studies in
patients with left ventricular hypertrophy, but the guidelines do not
describe such a limitation for patients with hypertension in the
absence of left ventricular hypertrophy.16
Another related
and unresolved issue is whether an excessive rise in exercise BP is
associated with a greater likelihood of false-positive ST-segment
depression. An exaggerated exercise BP response is a marker of
undetected left ventricular hypertrophy.17
18
Some authors
have postulated that a very high exercise rate-pressure product may
cause subendocardial ischemia.2
3
19
20
The small number
of studies examining exercise BP and ST-segment depression have
reported conflicting results.8
21
22
The purposes of this
study were to determine if false-positive ST-segment depression occurs
more frequently in patients with either hypertension at rest or an
exaggerated rise in systolic BP during exercise.
 |
Materials and Methods
|
|---|
Study Group
Between October 1986 and August 1992, 20,097 patients underwent
thallium exercise treadmill testing at the Mayo Clinic. The study group
was selected to have no evidence of coronary artery disease and to not
be predisposed to have a false-positive exercise test. Inclusion
criteria therefore included the following: (1) a normal thallium image
(see below); (2) no clinical history of myocardial infarction; (3) no
prior percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty or coronary artery
bypass surgery; (4) normal resting ECG; (5) no digoxin use; and (6) no
evidence of clinically significant valvular heart disease or
cardiomyopathy. A clinical history of hypertension was defined as
either a systolic BP > 140 mm Hg or a diastolic BP > 90 mm Hg on
repeated occasions, or a prior diagnosis of hypertension. A normal
thallium image was used to exclude significant coronary artery disease,
realizing that this criterion is not perfect. The reported sensitivity
of tomographic imaging is approximately 90%.23
Since most
patients with normal thallium images are not referred for coronary
angiography, requiring angiography on all patients would result in a
considerably smaller and more skewed study population. Patients with
resting ECGs showing abnormalities of rhythm (other than sinus
bradycardia), axis deviation, QRS-complex voltage, ventricular
conduction, pathological Q waves, and any ST-T-segment abnormalities
were excluded from the study. A normal resting ECG was required both to
eliminate patients with left ventricular hypertrophy and to reduce the
likelihood of exercise false-positive ST-segment depression. The
presence of even nonspecific ST-segment, T wave abnormalities is
associated with developing false-positive ST-segment
depression.24
Exercise Testing
These techniques have been described in detail
previously.25
Briefly, the patients underwent treadmill
exercise using either the Bruce or Naughton protocols. Exercise
duration from either protocol was converted to estimated metabolic
equivalents using published nomograms. End points consisted of severe
fatigue, moderate angina,
2.0-mm ST-segment depression, marked
hypotension, or severe arrhythmia. BP was measured by cuff
sphygmomanometry at rest in the standing position immediately before
exercise and during the last minute of each exercise stage, including
the last minute of exercise. A 12-lead ECG was performed at rest and
during each minute of exercise, and three leads were monitored
continuously during exercise. The exercise ECG was interpreted visually
by the cardiologist or nurse supervising the exercise test. ST-segment
depression was measured 0.08 s after the J point and was
categorized into three groups: (1) none, any degree of upsloping, or
< 1-mm horizontal or downsloping; (2) 1.0- to 1.9-mm horizontal or
downsloping; and (3)
2.0-mm horizontal or downsloping.
Tomographic Thallium-201 Imaging
During the last minute of exercise, 3.0 to 4.0 mCi of
thallium-201 were injected IV. Tomographic imaging was performed
shortly after exercise and repeated 4 h later. Patients studied
after January 1, 1990, underwent reinjection with 1.0-mCi thallium
before delayed imaging. The images were interpreted by two experienced
observers who graded thallium uptake in 14 short-axis segments on the
postexercise and rest images using a 5-point scale (0 = no uptake; 1,
2, and 3 = severely, moderately, and mildly reduced uptake,
respectively; and 4 = normal uptake). Only patients with completely
normal images or mild fixed defects (coded 3 on both the postexercise
and rest images) were included. Most mild fixed defects represent soft
tissue attenuation artifacts and are not due to coronary artery
disease.
Statistics
The associations between ST-segment depression and several
clinical and exercise variables were tested using logistic regression.
A multivariate model was then created using stepwise logistic
regression analysis to determine which variables were independently
associated with ST-segment depression. For all analyses, a p value
< 0.05 was considered significant. The generalized coefficient of
determination R2 value was used to
illustrate the predictive value of the models. The
R2 value is the square of the correlation
coefficient and represents the amount of variability associated with a
given Y variable that is explained by the potential predictor
X.26
 |
Results
|
|---|
Patient Characteristics
There were 1,873 patients in the study group. ST-segment
depression developed in 378 patients (20%). Table 1
lists the characteristics of patients subgrouped by the presence or
absence of ST-segment depression. A clinical history of hypertension
was present in 707 patients (38%), and 780 patients (42%) were taking
at least one antihypertensive medication (a small number were taking an
antihypertensive medication for an indication other than hypertension).
Because of the large number of patients, relatively small differences
between the two groups were statistically significant. Of note is that
patients with ST-segment depression were less likely to have a history
of hypertension. They were also less likely to have chest pain or to be
taking a ß-blocker or calcium channel blocker.
Exercise Test Results
These results are listed in Table 2
. Patients with ST-segment depression had slightly higher systolic BP
both at rest and at peak exercise. They also exercised longer and
attained a higher peak exercise heart rate and rate-pressure product.
Association Between ST-Segment Depression and Exercise Systolic BP
For the entire study population (Fig 1
), there was a statistically significant (p < 0.001) but very weak
association (R2 = 0.2%) between
ST-segment depression and exercise systolic BP. The percentage of
patients with ST-segment depression increased modestly but
progressively from 18% with exercise systolic BP < 180 mm Hg to 27%
for those with exercise systolic BP
220 mm Hg. Attributable risk
was calculated using exercise systolic BP cut-points
200 mm Hg and
220 mm Hg. For the cut-point
200 mm Hg, 28% of the excess
occurrence of ST-segment depression was attributable to the elevated
exercise systolic BP. The attributable risk increased to 39% using the
cut-point
220 mm Hg.

View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
[Download PPT slide]
|
Figure 1.. Percentages of patients with ST-segment depression
for categories of peak exercise systolic BP (SBP) for the entire study
population. The numbers within the bars indicate the percentages of
patients with 1.0- to 1.9-mm and 2-mm ST-segment depression. The
numbers at the bottom of the graph indicate the numbers of patients in
each subgroup.
|
|
The results were analyzed with patients being categorized as with or
without a history of hypertension (Fig 2
), and as taking or not taking either a ß-blocker or calcium channel
blocker (Fig 3
). The same effect of a modest increase in the percentage of patients
with ST-segment depression by increasing exercise systolic BP was
present for each of these subgroups. The increase in percentage of
patients with ST-segment depression was progressive with increasing BP
for all subgroups except those taking a ß-blocker or calcium channel
blocker, where a decrease in the percentage occurred between the third
and fourth categories of BP. The magnitude of the association between
ST-segment depression and exercise BP was greater in patients without a
history of hypertension and in those not taking a ß-blocker or
calcium channel blocker.
There was a small but significant gender difference: 22% of men and
18% of women had ST-segment depression. The increase in percentage of
men with ST-segment depression was progressive with increasing BP, but
women demonstrated a decrease between the third and fourth categories
(Fig 4
). Men were more likely than women to have ST-segment depression in
three of the four categories of systolic BP, but not for the category
from 200 to 219 mm Hg.
An inspection of Figures 1
2
3
4
reveals that the increase in the
percentage of patients with ST-segment depression associated with
increasing exercise systolic BP was due to more patients with severe
(
2 mm) ST-segment depression for all subgroups. This association
was greater for patients without hypertension, for patients not taking
a ß-blocker or calcium channel blocker, and for men. An additional
analysis revealed that 22% of men without hypertension and not taking
a ß-blocker or calcium channel blocker whose exercise systolic BP was
220 mm Hg had
2-mm ST-segment depression (Fig 5
). Note that there were only 23 men in this subgroup. There was no
consistent association between exercise systolic BP and modest (1.0 to
1.9 mm) ST-segment depression for the entire study population or any of
the subgroups analyzed.
The results of the multivariate analysis testing the association
between ST-segment depression and several clinical and exercise
variables are shown in Table 3
. These variables were all independent but weak predictors of ST-segment
depression. Peak ex-ercise systolic BP was of borderline
significance (p = 0.046). The R2 value
for the multivariate model was 5.3%.
 |
Discussion
|
|---|
This study demonstrates that an exaggerated exercise systolic BP
was associated with a slightly increased likelihood of false-positive
ST-segment depression in patients without evidence of coronary artery
disease by tomographic thallium scintigraphy. However, the association
was so weak that it could not be highly predictive in the individual
patient. For every 20-mm Hg increment in exercise systolic BP, the
increase in the percentage of patients with false-positive ST-segment
depression was only 3%. This association was most evident for men
without a history of hypertension who developed
2-mm ST-segment
depression. In contrast to exercise BP, a history of hypertension was
actually associated with a slightly lower likelihood of false-positive
ST-segment depression.
Exercise BP and ST-Segment Depression
Potential mechanisms by which an exaggerated rise in exercise BP
could cause exercise-induced ST-segment depression include the
following: (1) An excessive rate-pressure product could result in
global subendocardial ischemia due to a mismatch between myocardial
oxygen supply and demand.2
3
19
20
The potential for
abnormal loading conditions to cause false-positive ST-segment
depression is supported by the finding that healthy young adults can
develop ST-segment depression and abnormal left ventricular
contractility by performing sudden vigorous exercise.27
(2) As noted earlier, exercise-induced ST-segment depression occurs
commonly in patients with left ventricular
hypertrophy.8
9
10
11
12
The ECG has limited sensitivity for
detecting left ventricular hypertrophy.13
An exaggerated
systolic BP response has been proposed as a marker of left ventricular
hypertrophy.17
18
Coronary vasodilator reserve is reduced
in patients with left ventricular hypertrophy.28
The net
result could be global subendocardial ischemia causing ST-segment
depression but no focal thallium defect. (3) Even in the absence of
left ventricular hypertrophy, myocardial ischemia can occur in
hypertensive patients due to abnormally elevated resistance at the
coronary microvascular level.29
Conceivably, the same
mechanism could occur in patients who are normotensive at rest but
hypertensive during exercise. (4) PR-segment depression can result in
ST-segment depression during exercise.30
A greater rise in
exercise BP could have a greater impact on atrial
repolarization.31
Comparison to Other Studies
The data supporting hypertension as a cause of false-positive
ST-segment depression are scanty. Some studies have been limited by
small numbers of patients6
7
or lack of confirmatory
evidence that patients who did develop ST-segment depression did not in
fact have coronary disease since no additional evaluation was
pursued.6
7
8
9
Other studies have reported that the
hypertensive patients who developed ST-segment depression were those
with left ventricular hypertrophy on the resting ECG.9
10
Even fewer studies have investigated exercise BP. Both Chaing et
al8
and Ellestad et al21
reported that
exercise BP was significantly associated with ST-segment depression. In
a more recent study, however, Lauer and colleagues22
found
that there was no increase in false-positive ST-segment depression in
subjects with exercise hypertension.
Study Limitations
BP was measured indirectly by cuff sphygmomanometer rather than
directly. Indirect BP measurement during exercise is reasonably
accurate32
but can be difficult in occasional patients.
Given the large size of the study group, occasional inaccurate readings
are unlikely to have significantly impacted on the study results.
Indirect measurement is standard clinical practice. As already
discussed, a normal thallium image rather than coronary angiography was
used to exclude coronary artery disease. One would assume that the
small percentage of patients with coronary disease that thallium failed
to detect more likely had ST-segment depression. Excluding these
patients from the study population would only further weaken the
associations that were detected and would not change the message of
this article. Finally, although the study group was large, the number
of patients with an excessively elevated exercise BP was relatively
small (131 patients
220 mm Hg and 21 patients
240 mm Hg). It is
possible that patients with an excessively elevated exercise BP may
have a greater likelihood of developing ST-segment depression that we
failed to show, but from a practical standpoint, these patients are
uncommonly encountered in clinical practice.
Implications
Patients who have hypertension and a normal resting ECG are not
more likely than those without hypertension to develop false-positive
ST-segment depression. Standard exercise testing should remain a useful
diagnostic modality when evaluating these patients for myocardial
ischemia. Although a high systolic BP during exercise is associated
with a slightly greater likelihood of false-positive ST-segment
depression, the strength of this association is so weak that this
finding cannot be predictive in an individual patient. Patients with a
positive exercise ECG and a high exercise systolic BP should not be
assumed to have a false-positive study.
 |
Acknowledgements
|
|---|
We thank Lisa VanDeWalker for secretarial
preparation of the manuscript.
Received for publication March 30, 1999.
Accepted for publication August 20, 1999.
 |
References
|
|---|
-
The Committee on Exercise. Exercise testing and training of individuals with heart disease or at high risk for its development: a handbook for physicians. Dallas, TX: American Heart Association, 1975
-
Erickssen, J, Myhre, E (1984) False positive exercise ECG: a misnomer? Int J Cardiol 6,263-268[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Detrano, R, Froelicher, VF (1988) Exercise testing: uses and limitations considering recent studies. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 31,173-204[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Fletcher, GF, Balady, G, Froelicher, VF, et al (1995) Exercise standards: a statement for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association. Circulation 91,580-615[Free Full Text]
-
Ellestad, MH (1996) Stress testing principles and practice 4th ed. ,333-334 FA Davis Company Philadelphia, PA.
-
Lepeschkin, E, Surawicz, B (1958) Characteristics of true-positive and false-positive electrocardiographic Master two-step exercise tests. N Engl J Med 258,511-520
-
Bellet, S, Roman, L (1967) Exercise test in hypertensive subjects studies by radioelectrocardiography. Am J Med Sci 254,398-405[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Chaing, BN, Alexander, R, Bruce, RA, et al (1969) Factors related to ST-segment depression after exercise in middle-aged Chinese men. Circulation 40,315-325[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Wong, HO, Kasser, IS, Bruce, RA (1969) Impaired maximal exercise performance with hypertensive cardiovascular disease. Circulation 39,633-638[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Massie, BM, Szlachcic, Y, Tuban, JF, et al (1993) Scintographic and electrocardiographic evidence of silent coronary artery disease in asymptomatic hypertension: a case-control study. J Am Coll Cardiol 22,1598-1606[Abstract]
-
Harris, CN, Aronow, WS, Parker, DP, et al (1973) Treadmill stress test in left ventricular hypertrophy. Chest 63,353-357[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Wroblewski, EM, Pearl, FJ, Hammer, WJ, et al (1982) False positive stress tests due to undetected left ventricular hypertrophy. Am J Epidemiol 115,412-417[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Carr, AA, Prisant, LM, Watkins, LO (1985) Detection of hypertensive left ventricular hypertrophy. Hypertension 7,948-954[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Prisant, LM, Frank, MJ, Carr, AA, et al (1987) Can we diagnose coronary heart disease in hypertensive patients? Hypertension 10,467-472[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Frohlich, ED, Apstein, C, Chobanian, AV, et al (1992) The heart in hypertension. N Engl J Med 327,998-1008[ISI][Medline]
-
Gibbons, RJ, Balady, GJ, Beasley, JW, et al (1997) ACC/AHA guidelines for exercise testing: a report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines (Committee on Exercise Testing). J Am Coll Cardiol 30,260-315[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Ren, JF, Hakki, AH, Kotler, MN, et al (1985) Exercise systolic blood pressure: a powerful determinant of increased left ventricular mass in patients with hypertension. J Am Coll Cardiol 5,1224-1231[Abstract]
-
Gottdiener, JS, Brown, J, Zoltick, J, et al (1990) Left ventricular hypertrophy in men with normal blood pressure: relation to exaggerated blood pressure response to exercise. Ann Intern Med 112,161-166
-
Wolthuis, RA, Froelicher, VF, Jr, Fischer, J, et al (1977) The response of healthy men to treadmill exercise. Circulation 55,153-157[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Froelicher VF, Myers KJ, Follansbee WP, et al. Interpretation of ECG responses. In: Manning S. ed. Exercise and the heart. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Year Book, 1993; 119
-
Ellestad, MH, Savitz, S, Bergdall, D, et al (1977) The false positive stress test: multivariate analysis of 215 subjects with hemodynamic, angiographic and clinical data. Am J Cardiol 40,681-685[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Lauer, MS, Pashkow, FJ, Harvey, SA, et al (1995) Angiographic and prognostic implications of an exaggerated exercise systolic blood pressure response and rest systolic blood pressure in adults undergoing evaluation for suspected coronary artery disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 26,1630-1636[Abstract]
-
Kotler, TS, Diamond, GA (1990) Exercise thallium-201 scintigraphy in the diagnosis and prognosis of coronary artery disease. Ann Intern Med 113,684-702
-
Weiner, DL, Ryan, TJ, McCabe, CH, et al (1979) Exercise stress testing: correlations among history of angina, ST-segment response and prevalence of coronary artery disease in the Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS). N Engl J Med 301,230-235[Abstract]
-
Christian, TF, Miller, TD, Bailey, KR, et al (1992) Noninvasive identification of severe coronary artery disease using exercise tomographic thallium-201 imaging. Am J Cardiol 70,14-20[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Neter, J, Wasserman, W, Kutner, MH (1985) Applied linear statistical models 2nd ed. ,96 Irwin Homewood, IL.
-
Barnard, RJ, MacAlpin, R, Kattus, AA, et al (1973) Ischemic response to sudden strenuous exercise in healthy men. Circulation 48,936-942[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Houghton, JL, Frank, MJ, Carr, AA, et al (1990) Relations among impaired coronary flow reserve, left ventricular hypertrophy and thallium perfusion defects in hypertensive patients without obstructive coronary artery disease. J Am Coll Cardiol 15,43-51[Abstract]
-
Brush, JE, Cannon, RO, III, Schenke, WH, et al (1988) Angina due to microvascular disease in hypertensive patients without left ventricular hypertrophy. N Engl J Med 319,1302-1307[Abstract]
-
Riff, DP, Carleton, RA (1971) Effect of exercise on the atrial recovery wave. Am Heart J 82,759-763[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Naimark, BJ, Tate, RB, Manfreda, J, et al (1990) The association between exercise blood pressure and the prevalence of ECG abnormalities. Can J Cardiol 6,267-273[ISI][Medline]
-
Rasmussen, PH, Staats, BA, Driscoll, DJ, et al (1985) Direct and indirect blood pressure during exercise. Chest 87,743-748[Abstract/Free Full Text]
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
J.-W. Ha, E. M. Juracan, D. W. Mahoney, J. K. Oh, C. Shub, J. B. Seward, and P. A. Pellikka
Hypertensive response to exercise: a potential cause for new wall motion abnormality in the absence of coronary artery disease
J. Am. Coll. Cardiol.,
January 16, 2002;
39(2):
323 - 327.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|