|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Division of Pulmonology, Department of Internal Medicine, Seoul Municipal Boramae Hospital Affiliated to Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, Korea. Supported in part by the Seoul Municipal Boramae Hospital.
Correspondence to: Hee Soon Chung, MD, FCCP, Department of Internal Medicine, Seoul Municipal Boramae Hospital, #395 Shindaebang-2-Dong, Dongjak-Gu, Seoul, 156707, Korea; e-mail: hschung{at}brm.co.kr
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study objective: To evaluate the value of this classification in predicting the therapeutic outcome of EBTB.
Design: A prospective study with serial bronchoscopy performed from the diagnosis of EBTB to the completion of antituberculosis chemotherapy.
Participants: Eighty-one patients with biopsy-proven EBTB.
Interventions: Fiberoptic bronchoscopy was done every month until there was no subsequent change in the endobronchial lesions, every 3 months thereafter, and at the end of treatment.
Results: Twenty-two of the 34 cases of actively caseating EBTB changed into the fibrostenotic type, and the other 12 healed without sequelae. Seven of the 11 cases of edematous-hyperemic EBTB changed into the fibrostenotic type, and the other 4 healed. Nine of the 11 cases of granular EBTB, 6 cases of nonspecific bronchitic EBTB, and 2 cases of ulcerative EBTB resolved completely. However, the other two cases of granular EBTB changed into the fibrostenotic type. Seven cases of fibrostenotic EBTB did not improve despite antituberculosis chemotherapy. These various changes in bronchoscopic findings occurred within 3 months of treatment. In 10 cases of tumorous EBTB, 7 progressed to the fibrostenotic type. In addition, new lesions appeared in two cases, and the size of the initial lesions increased in another two cases, even at 6 months after treatment.
Conclusions: The therapeutic outcome of each subtype of EBTB can be predicted by follow-up bronchoscopy during the initial 3 months of treatment, with the exception of the tumorous type. In tumorous EBTB, close and long-term follow-up is advisable because the evolution of the lesions during treatment is very complicated and bronchial stenosis may develop at a later time.
Key Words: bronchoscopic finding bronchoscopy endobronchial tuberculosis evolution subtype
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The pathogenesis of EBTB is not yet fully established. However, sources of EBTB may include direct implantation of tubercle bacilli into the bronchus from an adjacent pulmonary parenchymal lesion, direct airway infiltration from an adjacent tuberculous mediastinal lymph node, erosion and protrusion of an intrathoracic tuberculous lymph node into the bronchus, hematogenous spread, and extension to the peribronchial region by lymphatic drainage.9 10 16 17 18
The clinical course of EBTB is variable because not only are there several possible pathogenetic mechanisms, but the interaction between the effect of mycobacteria, host immunity, and antituberculous drugs is complex, and any variation in these three factors may result in an altered course.19 Therefore, the forms of EBTB need to be classified into subtypes.
We previously classified forms of EBTB into seven subtypes by bronchoscopic finding: actively caseating, edematous-hyperemic, fibrostenotic, tumorous, granular, ulcerative, and nonspecific bronchitic.2 However, it was not known whether the proposed classification had predictive value after treatment. Here, we show the value of this classification in predicting the outcome of EBTB after the treatment in a prospective clinical study.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Comparisons of the presence of bronchial stenosis before and after
treatment were done using
2 analysis and
Fishers Exact Test. A p value of < 0.05 was considered
statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
To assess the changes in bronchoscopic findings during treatment in each subtype of EBTB, we analyzed 81 cases, because 33 participants dropped out of the study and follow-up bronchoscopy could not be performed as scheduled in these cases.
Actively Caseating EBTB
Actively caseating lesions were diagnosed when the bronchial
mucosa was swollen, hyperemic, and diffusely covered with whitish
cheese-like material. This form was usually accompanied by luminal
narrowing at diagnosis whether granulation tissue was present or not
(Fig 1 , top, A).
Changes in the bronchoscopic findings of the 34 cases of actively caseating EBTB during treatment are summarized in Table 1 . Seven cases transformed into the fibrostenotic type via the edematous-hyper-emic type, and another 15 cases directly transformed into the fibrostenotic type, within 3 months of treatment. Therefore, 22 cases became fibrostenotic. Distinctively, 12 of these 22 cases, which showed granulation tissue on follow-up bronchoscopy, changed into the fibrostenotic type. The other 12 cases healed through the edematous-hyperemic, granular, or nonspecific bronchitic types without complication. Significant improvement of bronchial stenosis was shown after treatment in this type of EBTB only.
|
The prognosis of our cases of edematous-hyper-emic EBTB was not good because 7 of the 11 cases became fibrostenotic in type within 2 to 3 months after treatment, and 2 of these 7 cases showed complete obstruction of the bronchial lumen. The other four cases changed into the nonspecific bronchitic type at 1 or 2 months after treatment and healed within 3 months of treatment (Table 2 ).
|
All seven cases remained in a fibrostenotic state in spite of drug therapy. In addition, three endobronchial lesions showed progressive fibrostenosis and resulted in complete obstruction of the bronchial lumen at 2 or 3 months after treatment.
Tumorous EBTB
Tumorous EBTB was characterized by an endobronchial mass whose
surface was often covered with caseous material and nearly totally
occluded the bronchial lumen (Fig 1
, top, D). This form of
EBTB was frequently mistaken for lung cancer because of its
bronchoscopic appearance and the fact that CT findings mimicked lung
cancer (Fig 2
).
|
|
Two cases transformed into the edematous-hyperemic type at 1 month after treatment and showed fibrostenosis of the bronchial lumen at 2 months after treatment. Another three cases transformed into the edematous-hyperemic type at 1 month after treatment but healed without endobronchial sequelae at 3 or 4 months after treatment. The other six cases healed within 3 months of treatment (Table 4 ).
|
Nonspecific Bronchitic EBTB
In nonspecific bronchitic EBTB, only mild mucosal swelling and/or
hyperemia were seen on bronchoscopy (Fig 1
, bottom, G).
However, tuberculosis was proven by bronchoscopic biopsy of these
lesions.
The prognosis was so excellent that all the six cases were healed within 2 months of treatment.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this study, EBTB showed a marked preponderance in female patients, consistent with other reports from Korea2 17 and Japan.21 22 However, the reason why EBTB is common in female patients is not clear. One of the possible reasons may be because the implantation of organisms from infected sputum occurs easily in female subjects, especially those in their teens and twenties, since they do not expectorate sputum well because of their sociocultural and cosmetic backgrounds. The incidence of EBTB in pulmonary tuberculosis was 5.88% (114 cases of EBTB/1,938 patients with pulmonary TB). However, it should be considered that the actual incidence is higher than this frequency because bronchoscopy was not routinely performed in all of the patients with tuberculosis.
We think that our classification of EBTB is closely related to the extent of disease progression. Pathologically, the initial lesion, which presents as simple erythema and edema of the mucosa with lymphocytic infiltration of the submucosa,1 23 corresponds to nonspecific bronchitic EBTB. This lesion is followed by submucosal tubercle formation that produces the erythema and granularity seen at bronchoscopy,16 and partial bronchial stenosis caused by considerable congestion and edema of the mucosa.23 These are granular and edematous-hyperemic type, respectively, according to our classification. At this point, development of caseous necrosis with formation of tuberculous granuloma can be found at the mucosal surface.23 This constitutes actively caseating EBTB. When the inflammation erupts through mucosa, an ulcer is seen that may be covered by caseous material.16 At this point, the disease is considered to be of the ulcerative type. Finally, the bronchial mucosal ulcer evolves into hyperplastic inflammatory polyps, and the endobronchial tuberculous lesion heals by fibrostenosis.10 24 In this process, the lesion has moved through either the tumorous or fibrostenotic type. In addition, tumorous EBTB can also develop through another pathway in which an intrathoracic tuberculous lymph node erodes and protrudes into the bronchus.1 11 In our experience, this mechanism is the principal one in tumorous EBTB, because CT usually reveals an endobronchial mass and enlarged lymph nodes adjacent to the bronchus, as illustrated in Figure 2 , and anthracotic pigment is frequently seen on biopsy specimens.10 25 Interestingly, EBTB in patients with HIV infection shows bronchoscopic and CT findings similar to ours.11 15 26 27
In the present study, 62 cases with actively caseating, edematous-hyperemic, fibrostenotic, and tumorous EBTB showed luminal narrowing of the bronchus at diagnosis. This number significantly decreased to 43 cases by the end of treatment. This result was consistent with other reports.15 18 19 However, it is noteworthy that drug therapy had no impact on the prevention of bronchostenosis22 in 43 of these cases. Among 19 cases with granular, ulcertive, and nonspecific bronchitic EBTB that did not show luminal narrowing of the bronchus at diagnosis, 17 cases healed without bronchostenosis, although the other 2 cases of granular type did show bronchial stenosis after treatment. Thus, the evolution of EBTB seems to be crudely determined by initial bronchoscopic findings that reflect the extent of the progress of the disease.
To assess the evolution of EBTB in detail, the changes in the bronchoscopic findings during the treatment of each subtype of EBTB needed to be analyzed. In 34 cases of actively caseating EBTB, 22 moved on to become fibrostenotic despite the treatment. The 12 of these cases that showed granulation tissue on follow-up bronchoscopy changed into dense fibrosis. However, the other 12 cases healed with the same treatment. Seven of the 11 cases of edematous-hyperemic EBTB converted into the fibrostenotic type, but the other 4 healed. Four of the seven cases of fibrostenotic EBTB showed no change, and the other three showed complete obstruction of the bronchial lumen with dense fibrosis. Nine of the 11 cases of granular EBTB healed, but 2 changed into the fibrostenotic type. All of the ulcerative (two cases) and nonspecific bronchitic EBTB (six cases) healed. These various changes in bronchoscopic findings occurred within 3 months of treatment, even if they followed different courses to their final subtypes. Therefore, the therapeutic outcomes of these six subtypes of EBTB can be predicted when follow-up bronchoscopy is performed every month for the first 2 to 3 months of treatment. In addition, marked stenosis is inevitable despite efficacious chemotherapy once fibrostenotic EBTB develops, or if extensive granulation tissue appears.10 However, it can be alleviated by aggressive intervention therapy.4 20 28 29 30
It was very difficult to analyze the evolution of tumorous EBTB because it showed diverse progress and unexpected changes. However, the opinions of Shulutko and coworkers1 were extremely valuable to our understanding of the evolution of tumorous EBTB. In bronchoglandular tuberculosis, which is equivalent to our tumorous EBTB, bronchoglandular fistulas occur when the necrotic foci of the tuberculous lymph node rupture into the bronchial lumen, and the lymph node contents are extruded. During this stage, bronchial stenosis is often temporary. The bronchoglandular fistula usually heals, leaving a thin tender scar that neither deforms the wall nor narrows the lumen of the bronchus, if endobronchial treatment (removal of caseous masses and granulations, cauterization of the fistulous opening, and peribronchial blockades) is performed. But, if scarring of the bronchoglandular fistula continues, the bronchial lumen may be left narrowed by persistent cicatricial stenosis or can even be completely obliterated. Most cicatricial stenoses of EBTB appear to be sequelae of tumorous bronchadenitis, and sometimes more lymphoglandular fistulas arise near the first one. When we applied their opinions to our results, we realize that the unexpected changes in the present study were actually unexpected, but probable. In addition, in order to maintain bronchial patency, the early diagnosis and efficacious treatment including interventional modalities6 10 31 is very important in tumorous EBTB. Also, our results fit in with their assertion that tumorous EBTB has a unique pathogenetic mechanism and shows a grave prognosis regarding bronchostenosis32 if it is not treated aggressively.
In summation, we suggest a scheme for the presumptive natural course of endobronchial tuberculous lesions (Fig 3 , dashed arrow), which we deduced by observing the healing process (Fig 3 , solid arrow). The desired end result of EBTB is healing without significant sequelae, and the other conflicting end is fibrostenosis. All subtypes of EBTB are situated between these two ends and can transform into another subtypes during treatment. But, there is a critical point between these two ends, which is mainly determined by the extent of disease progression18 and closely related to formation of granulation tissue.1 10 Bronchial stenosis is inevitable3 33 if the disease progresses beyond this critical point. Therefore, prompt diagnosis and efficacious treatment are of paramount importance in EBTB in order to minimize the resultant bronchial stenosis.5 To alleviate bronchostenosis that has already developed, aggressive therapeutic modalities such as electrocautery,31 stent insertion,29 or laser therapy28 should be considered before dense fibrosis continues or complete obstruction of the bronchus occurs.
|
| Conclusion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received for publication February 22, 1999. Accepted for publication September 9, 1999.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
Y. J. Ryu, H. Kim, C. M. Yu, J. C. Choi, Y. S. Kwon, and O. J. Kwon Use of silicone stents for the management of post-tuberculosis tracheobronchial stenosis Eur. Respir. J., November 1, 2006; 28(5): 1029 - 1035. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Long, E. Wong, and J. Barrie Bronchial Anthracofibrosis and Tuberculosis: CT Features Before and After Treatment Am. J. Roentgenol., March 1, 2005; 184(3_supp): S33 - S36. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Jaiswal, D. Whitaker, L. Lang-Lazdunski, and A. Coonar Stenting for tracheobronchial stenosis in tuberculosis J R Soc Med, January 1, 2005; 98(1): 26 - 28. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S-Y. Low, A. Hsu, and P. Eng Interventional bronchoscopy for tuberculous tracheobronchial stenosis Eur. Respir. J., September 1, 2004; 24(3): 345 - 347. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Lee, D. A. Culver, C. Farver, and A. C. Mehta Syndrome of Iron Pill Aspiration* Chest, April 1, 2002; 121(4): 1355 - 1357. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |