|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Service de Pneumologie (Drs. Marchand, Delaunois, Brancaleone, and Vandenplas), Cliniques Universitaires de Mont-Godinne, Université Catholique de Louvain, Yvoir; Service de Pneumologie (Dr. Mairesse), Clinique Saint-Luc, Bouge; and Centre de Génétique Humaine et Unité de Génétique Médicale (Dr. Verellen-Dumoulin and Mr. Rahier), Université Catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium.
Correspondence to: Eric Marchand, MD, Service de Pneumologie, Cliniques Universitaires de Mont-Godinne, 5530-Yvoir, Belgium; e-mail: eric.marchand{at}pneu.ucl.ac.be
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: Case-control study. All subjects in the study were
screened for the presence of 13 mutations in the CFTR gene (R117H,
621 + 1G->T, R334 W,
F508,
I507, 17171G->A, G542X, R553X,
G551D, R1162X, 3849 + 10kbC->T, W1282X, and N1303K). Moreover, they
were also screened for the presence of the 5T variant in intron 8.
Setting: University hospital and community-based hospital.
Patients: Twenty-one white patients with ABPA participated in the study. The presence of CFTR mutations was also investigated in 43 white subjects with allergic asthma who did not show sensitization to Aspergillus fumigatus and in 142 subjects seeking genetic counseling for diseases other than cystic fibrosis (CF).
Results: Six patients with ABPA were
found to be heterozygous for one CFTR mutation, including
F508
(n = 2), G542X (n = 1), R1162X (n = 1), 17171G->A (n = 1),
and R117H (n = 1). The 5T allele was not detected in ABPA patients.
None of the ABPA patients showed sweat chloride concentrations > 60
mEq/L. The frequency of CFTR mutation carriers was significantly higher
in ABPA patients (6 of 21 patients; 28.5%) than in control asthmatic
subjects (2 of 43 subjects; 4.6%; p = 0.01) and in subjects seeking
genetic counseling (6 of 142 subjects; p < 0.001).
Conclusion: These findings indicate that in patients without a clinical diagnosis of CF, CFTR gene mutations could be involved in the development of ABPA, in association with other genetic or environmental factors.
Key Words: allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis cystic fibrosis cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator gene.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The pathophysiology of ABPA remains largely speculative. Familial
occurrence of ABPA has been reported, suggesting a possible genetic
contribution to the disease.3
4
This possibility is
further suggested by the development of ABPA-like features in a
substantial proportion of patients with cystic fibrosis
(CF).5
6
7
8
9
10
CF is an autosomal recessive hereditary
disorder caused by mutations of the CF transmembrane conductance
regulator (CFTR) gene, which encodes for a cyclic-adenosine
monophosphateregulated chloride channel in epithelial
cells.11
CF is characterized by chronic airway disease
with proximal bronchiectasis, pancreatic exocrine insufficiency, male
infertility, and elevated concentrations of electrolytes in sweat.
Clinical ABPA has been documented in 2 to 11% of patients with CF,
although immunologic sensitization to A fumigatus may
occur with a much higher frequency.5
6
7
8
9
10
The possibility
that CFTR could play a role in the pathogenesis of ABPA is also
supported by the finding12
of a high frequency
of the
F508 mutation in ABPA patients with bronchiectasis. The aim
of this study was to assess the frequency of CFTR mutations in a case
series of patients with ABPA, as compared with a control group of
subjects with allergic asthma whodid not show evidence of
immunologic sensitization toA fumigatus.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The frequency of CFTR mutations in ABPA patients was compared with the frequency found in 43 white individuals with allergic asthma. These were unrelated consecutive patients with allergic asthma seen by one of the authors (O.V.) at the Cliniques Universitaires de Mont-Godinne. Accordingly, they were not recruited from a registry. The absence of ABPA was based on normal chest radiographic findings and the lack of specific IgE and precipitins directed against A fumigatus. CFTR mutations were also analyzed in 142 unrelated subjects seeking genetic counseling at the Centre de Génétique Humaine (which is part of the Cliniques Universitaires St Luc in Brussels) for reasons other than CF in order to obtain an estimate of the frequency of CFTR mutations in the general Belgian population (control subjects). This center recruits in the all French-speaking Belgian population. It is located 50 kilometers from Namur.
Patients and control subjects were informed of the purpose and procedures of the study, and each signed a statement of informed consent. The study protocol and consent form were approved by the Ethics Committee of the Cliniques Universitaires de Mont-Godinne.
Mutation Analysis
DNA was isolated from peripheral blood lymphocytes using the
NaCl extraction method and conventional techniques. Mutations and
polymorphism analysis were obtained from different polymerase chain
reaction amplifications. Genomic DNA samples were screened for
the following CFTR mutations: R117H/exon 4, 621 + 1G->T/intron 4,
R334 W/exon 7,
F508/exon 10,
I507/exon 10, 17171G->A/intron
10, G542X/exon 11, R553X/exon 11, G551D/exon 11, R1162X/exon 19,
3849 + 10kbC->T/intron 19, W1282X/exon 20, and N1303K/exon 21. The
studied mutations accounted for approximately 85% of alleles causing
CF in the Belgian population.17
18
The
I507 mutation
was detected by the formation of heteroduplex following electrophoresis
on acrylamide gel (8%). The 12 other mutations were identified using
the Elucigene CF 12 mutations kit (Astra Zeneca Diagnostics; London,
UK) based on the Amplification Refractory Mutation System (Astra Zeneca
Diagnostics) technology. The length of the intron 8
polythymidine tract was investigated with the nested-polymerase chain
reaction method followed by electrophoresis. The stretch was
characterized using the Gene Scan 672 software of a 373A Sequencer
Perkin-Elmer/Applied Biosystem (Perkin-Elmer; Norwalk, CT).
Statistics
Proportions were compared using two-tailed Fishers Exact Test
or
2 test. The former was calculated as the
sum of the probability of obtaining the observed contingency table plus
the probabilities of obtaining all other hypothetical tables
(constructed without changing the row or column totals) that were even
less likely.19
The 95% confidence intervals (CIs) of the
differences of proportions and odds ratios were calculated using usual
methods.20
A p < 0.05 was considered significant.
As others,21
22
23
we choose to analyze CFTR mutations and
variants of the intron 8 polythymidine tract separately. Indeed, a
linkage disequilibrium has been described between some CFTR mutations
(as
F508) and the intron 8 polythymidine tract
alleles.23
Moreover, in opposition to CFTR mutations, the
5T allele in intron 8 alone has never been shown to be associated with
various pathologic conditions, such as atypical sinopulmonary
disease,22
23
or congenital bilateral absence of vas
deferens.21
The presence of the 5T allele in intron 8
rather potentates the effects of CFTR mutations in these conditions.
Accordingly, we think that CFTR mutations and intron 8 polythymidine
tract alleles deserve a separate analysis, both from a statistical and
from a physiologic point of view.
Despite a small number of patients with ABPA, the power of the study was accurate (> 80%) to detect differences between the groups when hypothesizing a 30% prevalence of CFTR mutations in ABPA patients and a normal prevalence (4%) in allergic asthmatics. When hypothesizing (1) a fourfold increase in the prevalence of the 5T allele in ABPA as compared to control subjects (prevalence, 5%),21 and (2) a normal prevalence of 5T allele in allergic asthmatics, the power of the study to detect a difference between patients with ABPA and allergic asthmatics was 43%. The power was 53% when comparing the frequency of the 5T allele in ABPA patients and control subjects.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
F508 (n = 2), G542X (n = 1), R1162X
(n = 1), 17171G->A (n = 1), and R117H (n = 1). The 5T intron 8
variant was not detected in ABPA patients. One patient (patient 12)
declined sweat testing. None of the ABPA patients demonstrated a sweat
chloride level > 60 mEq/L, while two patients (patients 5 and 13)
showed a sweat chloride concentration in the intermediate range (54
mEq/L and 40 mEq/L, respectively; Table 2
). There was no significant difference between ABPA patients with CFTR
mutation and those without, regarding sex, atopy, smoking habits, age
at the time of ABPA diagnosis, and presence of A fumigatus
in sputum. The frequency of documented Pseudomonas
aeruginosa infection was not different in patients with a CFTR
mutation (1 of 6 patients) from that found in those who showed no CFTR
mutation (2 of 12 patients).
|
|
F508 and 17171G->A.
In the group of control subjects, 6 of 142 subjects (4.2%) were found
to be heterozygous for a CFTR mutation and 7 other subjects (4.9%)
were heterozygous for the 5T allele. The proportion of CFTR mutation
carriers in ABPA patients (6 of 21 patients; 28.5%) was significantly
higher than that found in control asthmatics (2 of 43 asthmatics;
4.6%; p = 0.01, Fishers Exact Test; 95% CI for difference in
proportions, 3.6 to 44.2%) and in the control subjects (6 of 142
subjects; 4.2%; p < 0.001,
2 test; 95% CI
for difference in proportions, 4.7 to 43.9%). This corresponds to odds
ratios of 8.2 (95% CI, 1.5 to 45.2) and 9.1 (95% CI, 2.6 to 31.7)
when comparing patients with ABPA with allergic asthmatics and control
subjects, respectively. Two allergic asthmatics (4.6%) and seven control subjects (4.9%) were found to be heterozygous for the 5T variant in intron 8. None of the 5T carriers were heterozygous for CFTR mutations. The differences in proportions of 5T carriers were not statistically significant between the three groups (Fishers Exact Test).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
F5085/R347H), and she was reclassified as having
atypical CF. Five patients were found to carry one CFTR mutation,
including
F508 in four patients and R117H in one patient. The
proportion of patients who were excluded because they did not fulfill
the proposed diagnostic criteria for ABPA was higher in our population
(21%) than in the study by Miller et al12
(4%). However,
participation in genetic testing was higher in our group of ABPA
patients (95% vs 24%). As our sample of patients with ABPA came
from both community-based and university hospitals, we think that
it was representative for the cases of ABPA that come to the attention
of lung specialists.
The higher-than-expected frequency of CFTR mutations among ABPA
patients raises two hypotheses. First, the patients found to be
heterozygous for the studied mutations could actually present an
atypical form of CF, as they could carry another rare CFTR mutation on
the second chromosome. Because we did not analyze the complete coding
sequence of the CFTR gene, we cannot formally exclude that our ABPA
patients were compound heterozygotes for unidentified CFTR mutations.
This possibility, however, would imply that a substantial proportion of
patients with ABPA have unrecognized CF. None of our patients with ABPA
showed elevated sweat chloride concentrations. Accordingly, they did
not meet the usual diagnostic criteria for CF.11
One
patient with a CFTR mutation was found to have a sweat chloride level
in the intermediate range. This patient did not show other evidence of
CF, such as P aeruginosa infection or pancreatic
insufficiency. However, previous genetic studies24
25
26
27
28
29
have provided accumulating evidence that some CFTR mutations are
associated with milder CF phenotypes and normal sweat electrolytes. In
the study by Miller et al,12
only one ABPA patient was
identified as carrying two CFTR mutations (
F508/R347H). This patient
presented with recurrent P aeruginosa pneumonia, normal
sweat electrolytes, and abnormal values of nasal transepithelial
voltage measurements. The presence ofP aeruginosa in
sputum was not more frequent in our ABPA patients with a CFTR mutation
than in those without mutation. Nasal potential differences were not
measured in our patients. This test deserves further investigation in
patients with ABPA, as it could represent a more reliable indicator of
CFTR function than the sweat test.
Besides mutations of the CFTR gene, genetic polymorphism of noncoding regions may have an impact on the level of functional CFTR and CF phenotype.30 In addition, mutations of the noncoding regions of CFTR have been associated with atypical CF phenotypes. For instance, the 5T allele sequence in intron 8 results in the deletion of exon 9 in CFTR messenger RNA, leading to reduced levels of the normal CFTR protein. The combination of one CFTR mutation with the 5T allele has been involved in the pathogenesis of congenital bilateral absence of vas deferens21 and atypical sinopulmonary disease.22 23 Among the ABPA patients studied by Miller et al,12 the 5T intron 8 variant was identified in two patients without other mutations in the CFTR gene.12 By contrast, we did not detect the 5T allele in our ABPA patients. This is probably explained by the small number of ABPA patients that is inherent to the rarity of the disorder and which precludes to draw definitive conclusions on the role of this variant in ABPA.
Alternatively, our findings, together with those of Miller et
al,12
could indicate that heterozygosity for CFTR
mutations has a specific effect on the development of ABPA, at least in
a subset of patients. Heterozygosity for CFTR mutations could either
predispose to the development of bronchiectasis with secondary
sensitization to A fumigatus or promote immune response to
A fumigatus, leading to airway inflammation and
bronchiectasis. Whether CF carrier status is associated with an
increased risk of pulmonary disease remains a matter of debate. A
higher prevalence of bronchial hyperresponsiveness to methacholine,
wheezing, and lung disease during childhood, as well as a decrease in
expiratory volumes and flows have been found in obligate heterozygotes
for CF.31
32
An increased prevalence of reported asthma in
adult heterozygotes for the
F508 mutation has been reported in
some33
but not all studies.34
35
Previous studies36
37
have convincingly documented
a high prevalence of CFTR mutations in adult patients with disseminated
bronchiectasis of unknown etiology. By altering the mucociliary
clearance process, bronchiectasis could lead to chronic airway
colonization with A fumigatus hyphae, which is thought to be
a prerequisite to the development of immunologic sensitization to
A fumigatus.1
2
In the study by Gervais et
al,36
the presence of ABPA was not mentioned, while 2 of
the 16 patients studied by Pignatti et al37
had ABPA, and
1 of these 2 patients was heterozygous for a rare mutation (3667 ins
4). Another possibility is that CFTR mutations contribute to enhanced
immunologic and inflammatory responses to A fumigatus. An
epidemiologic survey35
found a higher prevalence of
positive skin-prick tests to A fumigatus in
F508 carriers
than in noncarriers, although there was no difference in the prevalence
of asthma. In addition, there is emerging evidence that CF is
associated with altered production of cytokines in the airways,
including interferon-
, interleukin (IL)-8, and IL-10, which could
result in inappropriately regulated inflammatory and immunologic
processes.38
39
Peripheral CD4+ T cells derived from CF
patients have been found to produce reduced levels of IL-10 after
polyclonal activation.40
IL-10 has potent
anti-inflammatory effects by reducing the release of various
proinflammatory cytokines. Assessing the prevalence of CF carriers in
ABPA patients who lack demonstrable bronchiectasis41
would
help to elucidate the role of CFTR mutations in the development of
ABPA. None of the three ABPA patients without bronchiectasis included
in our study was found to carry CFTR mutations, although their number
was too low to draw any reliable conclusions.
A limitation of this study is the small number of subjects included, particularly in the group of patients with ABPA. This is inherent to the rarity of the disorder. However, the power of the study was accurate (see "Materials and Methods") to detect differences in CFTR-mutations frequency. In ABPA as in other conditions associated with CFTR mutations,21 22 23 the difference in prevalence of the 5T allele with a control population seems to be less dramatic. Regarding the 5T allele frequency, the power of our study was relatively weak. Still, we choose to analyze the 5T allele in the present study because of its potential role when associated with a CFTR mutation. Larger multicentric studies including a greater number of patients are needed to resolve the issue of the association of the 5T allele and ABPA as well as the prevalence of CFTR gene mutations in patients suffering from ABPA without bronchiectasis. The present study as well as that by Miller et al12 demonstrate a high odds ratio for carrying a CFTR mutation in patients with ABPA. However, the CIs for odds ratios were wide. Larger studies would also allow to confirm these impressive odds ratios.
In conclusion, this study indicates that CFTR gene mutations, in combination with environmental or other genetic factors, could be involved in the pathogenesis of ABPA in patients who do not meet the clinical criteria for CF. Further investigation is warranted to assess the impact of CFTR dysfunction on airway response to A fumigatus. The high frequency of heterozygotes for a CFTR mutation among ABPA patients suggests that CFTR genotyping should be proposed to patients with this disease in order to provide appropriate genetic counseling.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received for publication December 29, 1999. Accepted for publication November 1, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
F508 heterozygosity in cystic fibrosis and susceptibility to asthma. Lancet 351,1911-1913[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
F508 mutation: a heterozygote advantage in cystic fibrosis. Nat Med 1,703-705[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
F508 heterozygosity and asthma: EGEA-operative Group. Lancet 352,985-986[ISI][Medline]
F508 mutation in chronic bronchitis or bronchiectasis [letter]. Lancet 342,997[ISI][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. Kraemer, N. Delosea, P. Ballinari, S. Gallati, and R. Crameri Effect of Allergic Bronchopulmonary Aspergillosis on Lung Function in Children with Cystic Fibrosis Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., December 1, 2006; 174(11): 1211 - 1220. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Grossman and L. C. Grossman Pathophysiology of Cystic Fibrosis: Implications for Critical Care Nurses Crit. Care Nurse, August 1, 2005; 25(4): 46 - 51. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Kamory, B. Csokay, and Z. Hollo Rapid Detection of Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator Gene IVS8 5T Variant by Real-Time PCR Clin. Chem., October 1, 2004; 50(10): 1837 - 1839. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H Witt Chronic pancreatitis and cystic fibrosis Gut, May 1, 2003; 52(90002): ii31 - 41. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
J. D. Groman, M. E. Meyer, R. W. Wilmott, P. L. Zeitlin, and G. R. Cutting Variant Cystic Fibrosis Phenotypes in the Absence of CFTR Mutations N. Engl. J. Med., August 8, 2002; 347(6): 401 - 407. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. L. Venarske and R. D. deShazo Sinobronchial Allergic Mycosis* : The SAM Syndrome Chest, May 1, 2002; 121(5): 1670 - 1676. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |