(Chest. 2001;120:1998-2003.)
© 2001
American College of Chest Physicians
Severe Accidental Hypothermia Treated in an ICU*
Prognosis and Outcome
Thierry Vassal, MD;
Brigitte Benoit-Gonin, MD;
Fabrice Carrat, MD, PhD;
Bertrand Guidet, MD;
Eric Maury, MD and
Georges Offenstadt, MD
*
From Service des Urgences (Dr. Vassal and Ms. Benoit-Gonin), Unité de Biostatistiques (Dr. Carrat), and Service de Réanimation Médicale (Drs. Guidet, Maury, and Offenstadt), Hopital Saint-Antoine, Assistance Publique - Hopitaux de Paris (AP-HP), Paris, France.
Correspondence to: Georges Offenstadt, MD, Service de Réanimation Médicale, Hopital Saint-Antoine, Assistance Publique - Hopitaux de Paris, 184, rue du Faubourg Saint-Antoine, 75571 Paris Cedex 12, France; e-mail: georges.offenstadt{at}sat.ap-hop-paris.fr
 |
Abstract
|
|---|
Study objectives: To assess the characteristics and
outcomes of patients admitted to an ICU for severe accidental
hypothermia, and to identify risk factors for mortality.
Methods: All consecutive patients admitted to an ICU
between January 1, 1979, and July 31, 1998, with a temperature of
32°C were retrospectively analyzed. Rewarming was always
conducted passively with survival blankets and conventional covers.
Prognostic factors were studied by means of univariate analysis
(Mann-Whitney U and
2 tests) and
multivariate analysis (logistic regression).
Results:Forty-seven patients were enrolled (mean ± SD age,
61.7 ± 16 years). Five patients had a cardiac arrest before ICU
admission. Patient characteristics at ICU admission were as follows:
temperature, 28.8 ± 2.5°C; systolic BP, 85 ± 23 mm Hg; heart
rate, 60 ± 24 beats/min; Glasgow Coma Scale, 10.4 ± 3.7; and
simplified acute physiology score (SAPS) II, 50.9 ± 27. Mechanical
ventilation was necessary in 23 cases, and 22 patients in shock
received vasoactive drugs. The mean length of stay in the ICU was
6.7 ± 9 days. Eighteen patients (38%) died, but ventricular
arrhythmia was never the cause. Univariate analysis identified several
prognostic factors (p < 0.05): age (57 ± 16 years vs 69 ± 14
years), systolic arterial BP (93 ± 20 mm Hg vs 71 ± 21 mm Hg),
blood bicarbonate level (23.5 ± 5.2 mmol/L vs 16.6 ± 6.2 mmol/L),
SAPS II score (35.3 ± 19.5 vs 72 ± 21), mechanical ventilation
(34% vs 81%), vasopressor agents (42% vs 82%), rewarming time
(11.5 ± 7.2 h vs 17.2 ± 7 h), and discovery of the patient at
home (2.3% vs 54.5%). The initial temperature did not influence vital
outcome (28.9 ± 2.6°C vs 28.6 ± 2.2°C). Only the use of
vasoactive drugs (odds ratio, 9; 95% confidence interval, 1.6 to 50.1)
was identified as a prognostic factor in the multivariate
analysis.
Conclusion: Severe accidental hypothermia is
a rare cause of ICU admission in an urban area. Its mortality remains
high, but there is no overmortality according to the SAPS II-derived
prediction of death. Shock, requiring treatment with vasoactive drugs,
is an independent risk factor for mortality, while initial core
temperature is not. It remains to be determined whether aggressive
rather than passive rewarming procedures are better.
Key Words: rewarming severe hypothermia shock
 |
Introduction
|
|---|
Hypothermia
is defined by a central temperature of < 35°C. Moderate hypothermia
(32°C to 35°C) is classically1
distinguished from
severe hypothermia (28°C to 32°C) and major hypothermia
(< 28°C). The most severe cases necessitate rapid admission to an
ICU because the prognosis is grim, with a mortality rate between
12%2
and 80%.3
Between 50 and 100 people
die each year from hypothermia in France (incidence, 0.13 deaths per
100,000 inhabitants),4
and 700 to 800 people die each year
from hypothermia in the United States (0.3 deaths per 100,000
inhabitants).5
6
Hypothermia in otherwise healthy subjects
(following mountain accidents or cold-water immersion) can be profound
(< 20°C), while "urban" hypothermia usually occurs in fragile
subjects (eg, the elderly, alcoholics, drug addicts), and
the temperature is rarely < 25°C.
Management of hypothermia combines symptomatic treatment and rewarming.
Rewarming can be passive external, active external, or active
internal.7
8
Passive external rewarming (covers, warm
room) leads to a body temperature increment of 0.5 to 1°C/h, while
active external rewarming9
10
11
(lamp, hot bath,
fluidized bed) can achieve increments of 1 to 2°C/h. Active internal
rewarming can be achieved with several methods, including circulation
of warmed, humidified air12
13
through the airways via a
facial mask or tube (1 to 1.5°C/h); infusion of warmed
fluid14
(40 to 42°C) in the gastric, colonic,
pleural,15
peritoneal, or pericardial
cavities16
(2 to 2.5°C/h); hemodialysis17
with a dialysis bath warmed to 40°C (2 to 3°C/h); and
extracorporeal circulation18
using a heat exchanger (up to
15°C/h). Aggressive rewarming by means of cardiopulmonary bypass
improves the functional and vital prognosis of healthy subjects with
very profound hypothermia,19
but the use of this method
for other patients is controversial, depending above all on local
practices. A better knowledge of prognostic factors could help to guide
this therapeutic choice. We therefore analyzed, in a retrospective
study, the mortality rate and prognostic factors in patients with
severe hypothermia admitted to our ICU.
 |
Materials and Methods
|
|---|
This retrospective study was conducted from January 1, 1979, to
July 31, 1998. Only patients with severe hypothermia (central
temperature < 32°C) were included. The rewarming methods were only
passive because there is no documented superiority of active techniques
to treat urban hypothermia. This management did not change in our unit
over the course of the study.
Data Acquisition and Analysis
On ICU admission, the following data were obtained: age, sex,
cause of hypothermia, place of discovery (indoors or outdoors),
patients status, cardiac arrest before ICU admission, core central
temperature, neurologic status (Glasgow Coma Score), systolic arterial
BP, heart rate, blood gases, blood chemistry (sodium, potassium,
glucose, urea, creatinine, bicarbonate, calcium, hepatic enzymes, and
amylase), CBC count, and chest radiography. ECG deserved specific
attention, with analysis of rhythm, variations of the isolectric line,
Osborn J wave, and its amplitude, QT interval.20
The
following were subsequently analyzed: simplified acute physiology score
(SAPS) at 24 h,21
rewarming time (temperature
> 35°C), complications, need for mechanical ventilation and
vasoactive drugs, and death (date, place, and cause).
Temperature monitoring was performed with a hypothermic rectal catheter
(Hewlett Packard; Evry, France), and rewarming was always based on
external passive means, with survival blankets, synthetic covers, and a
heater in the room. Considering the retrospective nature and type of
the study, institutional review board approval was not required. Our
ICU database is registered to the French authority (Commission
Nationale Informatique et Liberte). Results are expressed as
mean ± 1 SD. Prognostic factors were studied by univariate analysis
using the Mann-Whitney U and the
2
tests, assuming significance at a p < 0.05, and using multivariate
analysis with the logistic regression method (calculated odds ratio and
95% confidence interval). The SAPS II score was not included in the
multivariate analysis because it integrates several variables already
studied in the univariate analysis.
 |
Results
|
|---|
During the study period, 12,100 patients were admitted in the ICU.
Of these patients, 65 patients were coded as having hypothermia
(temperature < 35°C), 4 patient charts were not found, and 14
patients were excluded because their temperatures were > 32°C.
Forty-seven patients (0.4%) were thus studied (26 men and 21 women).
Their characteristics are given in Table 1
.
Five patients had a cardiac arrest before hospital admission.
Twenty-four patients were found at home: drug intoxication (n = 4),
falls in elderly subjects (n = 11), cardiogenic shock (n = 1),
infectious shock (n = 1), major alteration of general status
(n = 1), status epilepticus (n = 1), and undetermined causes
(n = 5). Twenty-three patients were found outdoors: acute alcohol
intoxication (n = 9), drug intoxication (n = 2), falls (n = 2),
severely altered mental status (n = 1), and undetermined causes
(n = 9). Most of the patients had one or multiple underlying
diseases: chronic alcohol intoxication (n = 22), psychiatric
disorders (n = 7), hypertension (n = 4), diabetes mellitus
(n = 3), epilepsy (n = 3), liver cirrhosis (n = 1), AIDS
(n = 1), and cancer (n = 2). Eight patients were homeless.
The mean temperature at ICU admission was 28.8 ± 2.5°C. Seventeen
patients had major hypothermia (< 28°C; Fig 1 ), including 7 patients with a body temperature of
26°. Univariate
analysis identified three factors correlated with the degree of
hypothermia: systolic arterial BP (p < 0.03), presence of the J wave
(27.6 ± 2.4°C vs 30.2 ± 1.5°C, p < 0.01), and amplitude of
the J wave (1 to 15 mm; p < 0.001)
Biological abnormalities were nonspecific, reflecting only the gravity
of shock. Chest radiographic findings were normal in 36 patients and
showed unilateral lung opacity in 5 patients and bilateral lung
opacities in 6 patients. Twenty-seven patients were in sinus rhythm, 10
patients had atrial fibrillation, and the remainder could not be
analyzed because of tremor. Heart rate was < 60 beats/min in 27
patients and < 40 beats/min in 10 patients. Osborns J wave was
present in 18 patients, and 28 patients had a significant prolongation
of the QT interval. Only one patient had ventricular tachycardia, which
was successfully treated by external electric shock. The ECG evolution
of the patient with an initial temperature of 22°C is shown in Figure 2
.

View larger version (81K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
[Download PPT slide]
|
Figure 2.. Characteristic ECG modifications observed in
patients with profound hypothermia. The first tracing shows a
bradycardic rhythm with a baseline artifact due to muscle tremors
hiding the P wave, and Osborn wave (arrows). The following tracing
shows the ECG evolution of the patient with an initial temperature of
22°C.
|
|
Eighteen patients died (38%). Sixteen deaths occurred in the ICU (11
deaths occurred in the first 48 h), but no patients died of
ventricular arrhythmia. Four of five patients who received
cardiopulmonary resuscitation initiated in the prehospital setting
died. There were no deaths among the 15 patients hospitalized for acute
intoxication (drug or alcohol). Interestingly enough, there was only
one death among the seven patients with core body temperature of
26°C. Nine patients died in the period from 1979 to 1988, and
nine patients died in the period from 1989 to 1998.
The results of univariate analysis of prognostic factors are shown in
Table 2
. The initial temperature did not influence vital outcome. Most
parameters reflecting the initial gravity correlated strongly with the
mortality rate. Patients found at home, patients whose hypothermia was
not linked to acute intoxication, and patients who underwent warming
slowly had a higher mortality rate. In multivariate analysis, only the
use of vasopressor agents was associated with mortality (odds ratio, 9;
95% confidence interval, 1.6 to 0.1; p < 0.01).
 |
Discussion
|
|---|
Hypothermia is a rare cause of admission to the ICU, with only 65
cases during the 19-year period of this study (approximately 3 cases
per year, representing 0.4% of ICU admissions). Other
teams9
22
have reported a similar incidence of three to
four patients per year. In Paris, the emergency medical ambulance
service23
recorded 30 cases of hypothermia in the 14-month
period from October 1986 to December 1987 (approximately 1 case per
1,000 calls). This frequency is probably underestimated, because the
Paris fire service also manages some hypothermic patients.
Mortality among hypothermic patients is highly variable according to
this study (12 to 80%). It depends on the cause of hypothermia, the
patients age and background, the delay before treatment, and,
probably, in some cases, the rewarming modality. In our study, the
mortality rate was 38%. Other studies22
24
of patients
with a similar degree of hypothermia (< 32°C) managed with passive
external rewarming have reported higher mortality rates (52% and 63%,
respectively). The Swiss multicenter study25
published in
1991, which grouped together mountain accidents and urban hypothermia
treated with active internal rewarming, reported a mortality rate
similar to ours (38.5%). In a prospective Scottish study9
including 44 patients rewarmed by means of an active external method,
the mortality rate was only 27% but 50% of the patients had acute
intoxication. In the 2-year North American prospective multicenter
study26
published in 1987, involving 428 patients from 11
US states and British Colombia in Canada, the overall mortality rates
were 17% and 23%, respectively, among patients with a temperature of
< 32.2°C, but the patients were younger than patients in our study.
A mortality rate of 17% was also found in the 1995 Dutch multicenter
study27
of 427 patients with hypothermia not due to
immersion, but no information was given on severity.
Contrary to most reports in the
literature,20
24
28
29
but similar to the
Scottish9
and American26
studies, none of our
patients died of ventricular arrhythmia. In a French retrospective
report24
of 24 patients similar to our population in terms
of degree of hypothermia and rewarming method, 2 of the 13 deaths were
attributed to ventricular fibrillation (1 death at hospital admission
at 24.5°C, and the other death during rewarming at 34°C). It seems,
however, that ventricular arrhythmia is more frequent in young patients
with very severe hypothermia. In a Swiss study20
of 15
asystolic patients who were successfully rewarmed by means of
cardiopulmonary bypass (mean initial temperature,
21.8 ± 2.5°C), 10 patients had ventricular fibrillation initially.
Our univariate analysis identified severity factors: old age, low BP,
low blood bicarbonate level, high SAPS II, need for mechanical
ventilation or vasoactive drugs, discovery of the patient at home,
hypothermia not due to acute intoxication, and long delay before
rewarming. Age was also highly significantly associated with prognosis
in other studies,9
22
27
except for the American
series,26
in which the mean age was 53 years (compared
with 62 years in our study). The high mortality rate among patients
found at home (77%) relative to those found outdoors (23%) may be
explained by the older age of the former (69.7 years vs 49.7 years)
and, probably, by later discovery. In the American
study,26
the difference in mortality between these two
patient categories was smaller (55% vs 45%), but the percentage of
patients discovered at home was lower. The prognosis of hypothermia due
to acute intoxication (drug or alcohol) is clearly better than that of
hypothermia due to other causes (0% vs 56% mortality rates in our
series), mainly because of the younger age of the former patients (49.5
years vs 72.3 years). This confirms the results of the Scottish
study9
(two deaths in 25 cases of acute intoxication, vs
53%), a 10-year French retrospective study22
of 35
hypothermic patients (no deaths among five patients with drug
intoxication), the Paris SAMU study23
(70% cases of acute
intoxication, overall mortality rate of 27%), and the Bellevue
hospital experience.29
As in other
studies,9
24
29
the baseline temperature was not a factor
of poor prognosis in our study (Fig 2)
. The American
study26
showed a significant difference by univariate
analysis, which disappeared in multivariate analysis. In our seven
patients with body temperatures
26°, there was only one death.
This low mortality is in contrast with the study by
White29
in New York City, documenting a 50% mortality
when the body temperature was < 26°C. In the event of mountain
accidents and cold-water immersion when temperatures are < 20°C,
baseline temperature is a major prognostic factor and to our knowledge,
survival has never been reported at < 15.2°C in
children30
31
and < 13.7°C in adults.32
The rewarming rate and the delay after the accident seem to be most
important prognostic factors. The rewarming delay was significantly
longer in the patients who subsequently died in our study (17.2 ± 7
h vs 11.5 ± 7.5 h, p < 0.03). In 1974, a French
team24
noted that the mortality rate in patients whose
temperature was increased regularly by 0.5 to 1°C/h during passive
external rewarming was 31%, compared to 100% in patients who were not
rewarmed or who were rewarmed too slowly (< 0.5°C/h). The North
American study26
also showed significantly slower
rewarming in the first hour in patients who died. In the study by
White,29
if in-hospital rewarming required > 12 h,
this was a grave prognostic sign. The slower rewarming rates may also
reflect underlying host problems such as poor circulating volume.
Major hyperkalemia (> 10 mmol/L) is a factor of poor prognosis only
in asphyxiated avalanche victims.33
34
35
In our
multivariate analysis, the use of vasopressor agents (reflecting the
severity of shock) was the only factor associated with mortality. Shock
was also associated with a poor prognosis in the study by
White.29
Danzl et al36
found five risk
factors also reflecting initial severity: cardiac arrest before
hospital admission, low BP, elevated blood urea, need for mechanical
ventilation, and gastric intubation. A prognostic score for hypothermia
(ranging from 0 to 40) was proposed on the basis of these five
parameters.36
Based on a logistic regression model, the
Swiss multicenter study25
identified four parameters (age,
asystole, hyperkalemia, and acute poisoning) that together were
predictive of vital outcome in 87% of cases.
To our knowledge no randomized prospective studies have yet compared
the different rewarming methods. Published series, using different
rewarming methods, are not comparable because of major differences in
patient populations. Danzl et al,36
using their prognostic
score, analyzed patients outcomes according to the rewarming method.
No significant difference was found between the different methods, but
there was a trend favoring active internal rewarming by gastric or
colonic lavage and another trend against active external rewarming with
hot baths or electric blankets. Recently, Walpoth et al19
reported a survival rate of 47% in 32 young patients with asystole
treated with extracorporeal circulation. The global long-term
neurologic outcome of the 15 survivors was excellent, with nine full
recoveries, three cases of minor CNS sequel, and two minor and one
major sequel of the peripheral nervous system. These results confirm
the value of this rewarming method for young patients with very severe
hypothermia.
Severe hypothermia is rare but potentially lethal, justifying immediate
admission to the ICU. In our multivariate analysis, shock was
identified as the only risk factor for mortality while initial core
temperature was not. Hypothermia without shock can be treated by
passive external rewarming. The best therapeutic approach for
hypothermia associated with shock necessitating the use of vasoactive
drugs (mortality rate > 60%) is more controversial. If passive
external rewarming is ineffective within the first few hours, a more
aggressive method may be warranted.
 |
Footnotes
|
|---|
Abbreviation: SAPS = simplified acute physiology
score
Received for publication February 2, 2001.
Accepted for publication June 19, 2001.
 |
References
|
|---|
-
Jolly, BT, Ghezzi, KT (1992) Accidental hypothermia. Emerg Med Clin North Am 10,311-327[Medline]
-
Miller, JW, Danzl, DF, Thomas, DM (1980) Urban accidental hypothermia: 135 cases. Ann Emerg Med 9,456-461[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Mills, GL (1973) Accidental hypothermia in the elderly. Br J Hosp Med 10,691-699
-
Bouachour, G, Alquier, P (1993) Épidémiologie des hypothermies accidentelles. Arnette, SRLF eds. Actualités en Réanimation et Urgences ,245-256 Arnette Paris, France.
-
Larach, MG (1995) Accidental hypothermia. Lancet 345,493-498[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Hanania, NA, Zimmerman, JL (1999) Accidental hypothermia. Crit Care Clin 15,235-249[ISI][Medline]
-
Daanen, HAM, Van de Linde, FJG (1992) Comparison of four noninvasive rewarming methods for mild hypothermia. Aviat Space Environ Med 63,1070-1076[Medline]
-
Gregory, JS, Bergstein, JM, Aprahamian, C, et al (1991) Comparison of three methods of rewarming from hypothermia: advantages of extracorporeal blood warming. J Trauma 31,1247-1252[ISI][Medline]
-
Ledingham, IMcA, Mone, JG (1980) Treatment of accidental hypothermia: a prospective clinical study BMJ 280,1102-1105
-
Zachary, L, Kucan, JO, Robson, MC, et al (1982) Accidental hypothermia treated with rapid rewarming by immersion. Ann Plast Surg 9,238-241[ISI][Medline]
-
Miles, JM, Thompson, GR (1987) Treatment of severe accidental hypothermia using the Clinitron bed. Anaesthesia 42,415-418[ISI][Medline]
-
Goheen, MS, Ducharme, MB, Kenny, GP, et al (1997) Efficacy of forced-air and inhalation rewarming by using a human model for severe hypothermia. J Appl Physiol 83,1635-1642[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Lloyd, ELI (1973) Accidental hypothermia treated by central rewarming through the airway. Br J Anaesth 45,41-48[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Handrigan, MT, Wright, RO, Becker, BM, et al (1997) Factors and methodology in achieving ideal delivery temperatures for intravenous and lavage fluid in hypothermia. Am J Emerg Med 15,350-358[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Iversen, RJ, Atkin, SH, Jaker, MA, et al (1990) Successful CPR in a severely hypothermic patient using continuous thoracostomy lavage. Ann Emerg Med 19,1335-1337[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Althaus, U, Aeberhard, P, Schüpbach, P, et al (1982) Management of profound accidental hypothermia with cardiorespiratory arrest. Ann Surg 195,492-495[ISI][Medline]
-
Hernandez, E, Praga, M, Alcazar, JM, et al (1993) Hemodialysis for treatment of accidental hypothermia. Nephron 63,214-216[ISI][Medline]
-
Gentilello, LM, Cobean, RA, Offner, PJ, et al (1992) Continuous arteriovenous rewarming: rapid reversal of hypothermia in critically ill patients. J Trauma 32,316-325[ISI][Medline]
-
Walpoth, BH, Walpoth-Aslan, BN, Mattle, HP, et al (1997) Outcome of survivors of accidental deep hypothermia and circulatory arrest treated with extracorporeal blood warming. N Engl J Med 337,1500-1505[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Okada, M (1984) The cardiac rhythm in accidental hypothermia. J Electrocardiol 17,123-128[ISI][Medline]
-
Le Gall, JR, Lemeshow, S, Saulnier, F (1993) A new simplified acute physiology score (SAPS2) based on a European/North American multicenter study. JAMA 270,2957-2963[Abstract]
-
Rimailho, A, Teboul, JL (1983) Les hypothermies accidentelles de ladulte. Rev Prat 33,2797-2802[ISI][Medline]
-
Deny, N, Bresard, D, Bertrand, J, et al (1990) Hypothermies accidentelles chez ladulte: prise en charge par le SAMU de Paris. Agressologie 31,117-119[Medline]
-
Nicolas, F, Nicolas, G, Heurtel, A, et al (1974) Vingt-quatre observations dhypothermies accidentelles. Anesth Anal Réan 31,485-538
-
Locher, Th, Walpoth, B, Pfluger, D, et al (1991) Akzidentelle hypothermie in der Schweiz (19801987): kasuistik und prognostische faktoren Schweiz Med Wochenschr 121,1020-1028[ISI][Medline]
-
Danzl, DF, Pozos, RS, Auerbach, PS, et al (1987) Multicenter hypothermia survey. Ann Emerg Med 16,1042-1055[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Bierens, JJLM, Uitslager, R, Swenne-Van Ingen, MME, et al (1995) Accidental hypothermia: incidence, risk factors and clinical course of patients admitted to hospital Eur J Emerg Med 2,38-46[CrossRef][Medline]
-
Lloyd, EL, Mitchell, B (1974) Factors affecting the onset of ventricular fibrillation in hypothermia: an hypothesis. Lancet 2,1294-1296[ISI][Medline]
-
White, JD (1982) Hypothermia: the Bellevue experience. Ann Emerg Med 11,417-424[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Nozaki, R, Ishibashi, K, Adachi, N, et al (1986) Accidental profound hypothermia. N Engl J Med 25,1680
-
Antretter, H, Dapunt, OE, Mueller, LC (1994) Survival after prolonged hypothermia [letter]. N Engl J Med 329,1965-1966
-
Gilbert, M, Busund, R, Skagseth, A, et al (2000) Resuscitation from accidental hypothermia of 13.7°C with circulatory arrest Lancet 355,375-376[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Hauty, MG, Esrig, BC, Hill, JG, et al (1987) Prognostic factors in severe accidental hypothermia: experience from the Mt Hood tragedy. J Trauma 27,1107-1112[ISI][Medline]
-
Schaller, MD, Fischer, AP, Perret, CH (1990) Hyperkalemia: a prognostic factor during acute severe hypothermia. JAMA 264,1842-1845[Abstract]
-
Mair, P, Kornberger, E, Furtwaengler, W, et al (1994) Prognostic markers in patients with severe accidental hypothermia and cardiocirculatory arrest. Resuscitation 27,47-54[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
-
Danzl, DF, Hedges, JR, Pozos, RS (1989) Hypothermia outcome score: development and implications. Crit Care Med 17,227-231[ISI][Medline]