|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Department of Pediatrics, Stanford University Medical Center, Palo Alto, CA.
Correspondence to: Richard Moss, MD, FCCP, Stanford University Medical Center, 701 Welch Rd, #3328, Palo Alto, CA 94304-5786; e-mail: rmoss{at}stanford.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: Two identical, randomized, placebo-controlled trials followed by three open-label follow-on trials.
Setting: Sixty-nine CF study centers in the United States.
Interventions: Active drug consisting of a 300-mg tobramycin solution for inhalation (TSI).
Patients: One hundred twenty-eight adolescent CF patients
(aged 13 to 17 years) with P aeruginosa and
mild-to-moderate lung disease (FEV1 percent predicted
25% and
75%).
Measurements: Pulmonary function, P aeruginosa colony forming unit density, incidence of hospitalization and IV antibiotic use, weight gain, and aminoglycoside toxicity were monitored.
Results: At the end of the first three 28-day cycles of TSI treatment, patients originally randomized to TSI and placebo treatments exhibited improvements in FEV1 percent predicted of 13.5% and 9.4%, respectively. FEV1 percent predicted was maintained above the value at initiation of TSI treatment in both groups. At the end of the last "on-drug" period (92 weeks), patients originally randomized to TSI and placebo treatments showed improvements of 14.3% and 1.8%, respectively. Improvement in pulmonary function was significantly correlated with reduction in P aeruginosa colony forming unit density (p = 0.0001). The average number of hospitalizations and IV antibiotic courses did not increase over time. TSI treatment was associated with increased weight gain and body mass index. P aeruginosa susceptibility to tobramycin decreased slightly over time, but this was not correlated with clinical response.
Conclusions: TSI treatment improved pulmonary function and weight gain in adolescent patients with CF over a 2-year period of long-term, intermittent use.
Key Words: aminoglycoside cystic fibrosis Pseudomonas aeruginosa pulmonary function tobramycin
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
P aeruginosa is the major infectious burden in the airway of CF patients,6 and this pathogen is present in the lower respiratory tract of nearly 70% of CF patients by the age of 17 years.7 Acquisition of P aeruginosa is a major event in the natural history of CF lung disease, as its presence is associated with increased rates of lung function decline8 and is a significant predictor of mortality.9
The relationship between chronic respiratory tract infection, decline in pulmonary function, and mortality has been described.9 Death rates for CF patients chronically infected with P aeruginosa increase slowly with age up to the teenage years, when rates increase more rapidly and then remain fairly constant from the late teens to beyond the age of 30 years.4 Similarly, mean FEV1 percent predicted declines rapidly until early adulthood, when the rate of decline levels off.4 Kerem et al5 demonstrated an inverse relationship between age and risk of death for any given level of relative lung function. In patients with the same percentage of predicted FEV1 but an age difference of 10 years, the relative risk of death is doubled for younger patients.5 These findings are consistent with those of Corey et al,10 who showed that patients who die earlier in life experience significantly higher rates of lung function decline than longer-living patients. In 1998, the median age of death in CF patients in the United States was 22.5 years.4
The central role of P aeruginosa in CF lung disease has led to testing of intensive therapy with antipseudomonal antibiotics to suppress infection.11 Ramsey et al12 reported significant increases in pulmonary function as well as decreases in hospitalization and IV antibiotic use following 6 months of long-term, intermittent therapy with tobramycin solution for inhalation (TSI) [TOBI; Chiron Corporation; Annandale, NJ] in a pair of double-blind, placebo-controlled, clinical trials. It is noteworthy that an age-stratified analysis of pulmonary function change showed a highly significant treatment effect in adolescents that was nearly three times greater than that observed in any other age subgroup.12 Here, the results reported by Ramsey et al12 are extended with an analysis of data obtained from adolescent patients (aged 13 to 17 years) who completed these controlled trials and received up to 24 months of treatment in a series of open-label, follow-on trials.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Assessments
There were a total of 27 scheduled visits during the series.
During the screening period and the first treatment cycle (study weeks
4 to 8), visits occurred every 2 weeks. During the second to ninth
treatment cycles (study weeks 8 to 72), visits occurred every 4 weeks
and coincided with the end of each on-drug and off-drug period. During
treatment cycles 10 and 11 (study weeks 72 to 88), visits occurred
every 8 weeks and coincided with the beginning of each on-drug period.
During treatment cycle 12 (study weeks 88 to 96) visits occurred every
4 weeks. Throughout the series, clinical evaluations and spirometry
testing were performed at each visit. The frequency of other
evaluations, including sputum cultures, safety laboratory assessments,
and audiology testing, was greater during the controlled trials than
during the open-label trials.
Evaluations
The primary evaluation in this series was change in lung
function (FEV1 percent predicted) from baseline.
Other evaluations included change in P aeruginosa
susceptibility, change in serum creatinine concentrations, change in
weight and body mass index (BMI), use of IV antipseudomonal
antibiotics, and hospitalization. Spirometry testing
(FEV1) was performed according to American
Thoracic Society standards. FEV1 was expressed as
a percentage of the value predicted based on age and height according
to the methods of Knudson et al.13
Relative change in
FEV1 percent predicted was calculated as follows:
![]() |
Statistical Methods
The initial 24 weeks of the study series (the controlled trials)
included a placebo control group, allowing for statistical comparisons
between 24 weeks of TSI treatment and 24 weeks of placebo treatment.
Results from the controlled trial have been published
previously.12
Results obtained following the beginning of
the open-label trials (week 24, visit 11) are pooled and presented in
one of the following three ways, depending on the requirements of the
particular analysis: (1) by the number of cycles of TSI exposure, (2)
by the number of weeks since the patients first dose of TSI (week 0
[visit 3] for patients originally randomized to TSI, and week 24
[visit 11] for patients originally randomized to placebo treatment),
and (3) with all data for all patients since their first dose of TSI
combined. In each case, data from the placebo experience during the
controlled trials are presented for comparison. When relevant, the
96-week results are presented in the context of published controlled
trial results.
Data from all patients whose age at entry into the controlled trial
(visit 3) was between 13 years and 17 years (inclusive) and who
received at least one dose of study drug were included in the analyses.
Analysis of the relationship between changes in
FEV1 percent predicted and P
aeruginosa colony forming unit density was performed using a
2 test. The effect of recombinant human
dornase
(rhDNAse) on change in FEV1 percent
predicted was evaluated by means of a two-tailed t test.
Changes in BMI and serum creatinine levels were performed using
two-tailed, paired t test procedures.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
18 years) according to their age
at the first visit of the controlled trials (visit 3, week 0). One
hundred twenty-eight adolescent patients were enrolled in the
controlled trials. Of these 128 patients, 120 patients completed 24
weeks of randomized treatment. Ninety-three adolescent patients entered
the open-label phase of the study and 65 adolescent patients completed
the 96-week series. Of the 63 adolescent patients who discontinued therapy at some point during the four consecutive 6-month trials, 39 patients (61.9%) completed at least one trial and chose not to enroll in the subsequent trial with no reason given for this decision. Of the remaining 24 adolescent patients (38.1%) who withdrew during trials, the primary reasons were nonmedical complaints (n = 11, 45.8%), medical complaints (n = 8, 33.3%), and protocol violations (n = 4, 16.7%). No adolescent patients withdrew due to adverse events associated with study drug.
The baseline characteristics of the adolescent patients showed no meaningful differences between treatment groups (Table 1 ). Examination of these characteristics by four three-cycle (24-week) blocks of TSI exposure demonstrates that despite attrition over the course of the series, there was no meaningful change in any of these characteristics over time.
|
|
In order to determine the relationship between change in pulmonary function and change in P aeruginosa colony forming unit density, a correlation analysis was performed using all available data points for adolescent patients from visit 3 to visit 11 (Fig 3 ). P aeruginosa sputum density was calculated as the log10 value for the sum of all morphotypes. This analysis revealed a highly significant inverse relationship between the change in pulmonary function and change in P aeruginosa colony forming unit density (r = - 0.34175; p = 0.0001).
|
|
|
|
|
16 µg/mL increased from 5 to
19%. Over 96 weeks of TSI therapy, the tobramycin MIC for 50% of
isolates for P aeruginosa increased from 1 to 2 µg/mL, and
the MIC for 90% of isolates (MIC90) increased
from 8 to 32 µg/mL (Table 5
). A similar shift toward higher tobramycin MICs was observed for the
most resistant morphotype isolated from each patient. At the end of 12
treatment cycles, the percentage of patients whose most resistant
isolate had an MIC of
16 g/mL increased from 10 to 41% (Fig 5
,
right panel).
|
|
8 µg/mL, 16 to 64 µg/mL, and
128 µg/mL) according to the MIC value of their most-resistant
P aeruginosa isolate obtained at any start-of-treatment
visit prior to the end of that TSI exposure period. As was observed for
the entire study population, neither the percentage of adolescent
patients with a positive clinical response, nor the magnitude of the
observed response appeared to be related to tobramycin MIC (Fig 6
).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A major concern with long-term use of inhaled antibiotics in CF patients is decreased antibiotic susceptibility of P aeruginosa. CF patients frequently receive IV aminoglycosides for the treatment of acute exacerbations, and the potential risk of reducing the effectiveness of these agents must be weighed carefully against the benefits of aerosol administration. When considered in these terms, the threefold increase in MIC90 and the nearly 40% increase in patients whose most-resistant isolate had an MIC exceeding the traditional parenteral break point warrant concern. However, withholding long-term inhaled tobramycin therapy to preserve the effectiveness of IV antibiotics may present risks even greater than those posed by decreased antibiotic susceptibility. Treatment of exacerbations with IV antibiotics is a symptom-driven strategy that by itself fails to address the progressive decline in lung function experienced by Pseudomonas-infected CF patients. Lung function decline occurs even in the absence of exacerbations, and for each 10% decline in relative lung function, a patients risk of death doubles.5 This is a particularly salient point for adolescent CF patients and their caregivers. As a group, adolescents can have high rates of pulmonary function decline and, consequently, high rates of death. This high death rate is a substantial contributor to the 22.5-year median age of death for Pseudomonas-infected patients. Management strategies that fail to reduce the inexorable decline in lung function in these patients serve only to maintain the status quo of disease progression and death by early adulthood.
The data presented here demonstrate that long-term, intermittent TSI
therapy can not only preserve but can actually improve lung function
for at least 2 years in adolescent patients with CF, and that clinical
response is not affected by tobramycin MIC. This finding is consistent
with that of Ramsey et al,12
who showed that improvement
in FEV1 percent predicted at the end of the last
on-drug period of the controlled trials was similar regardless of
whether the patients most-resistant isolates were above or below the
parenteral break point. Continued pulmonary response, even in patients
with tobramycin-resistant strains of P aeruginosa, suggests
that the traditional parenteral break point for tobramycin (MIC
16
µg/mL) does not apply to inhaled tobramycin. This is most likely
because sputum tobramycin concentrations (mean, 1,000 µg/g) far
exceed the MIC values of most strains considered resistant using the
parenteral break point.
Analysis of secondary study end points of hospitalization and IV antibiotic use also supports the long-term effectiveness of TSI. The primary cause of hospitalization in CF patients is for treatment of exacerbations with IV antibiotics. In 1998, nearly 50% of all CF patients in the United States were hospitalized at least once, with an average stay of 9.8 days.4 The finding that both hospitalization and IV antibiotic use were reduced in CF adolescents following initiation of TSI therapy is consistent with the substantial improvements observed in pulmonary function. The number of exacerbations leading to hospitalization and IV antibiotic treatment clearly did not increase over time, although this could be expected in a population of patients with rapidly declining lung function. Furthermore, the hospitalization and IV treatment data suggest that changes in the susceptibility of P aeruginosa did not affect the severity of the underlying exacerbations, or the efficacy of treating them. Finally, body weight is an important prognostic factor in CF patients and has been associated with survival.15 16 17 18 Results from this study series strongly suggest that long-term suppression of P aeruginosa with TSI therapy can significantly improve weight gain in growing adolescents.
In conclusion, the long-term results obtained from adolescent patients participating in the TSI study series confirm and extend those previously reported.12 The adolescent subgroup analyses illustrate that this vulnerable group of patients can gain substantial benefit from long-term TSI treatment, including improved lung function, reduced hospitalization and IV antibiotic use, and increased weight gain. They also strongly suggest that in order to be maximally effective, TSI treatment should begin earlier rather than later, since lung function decline in patients with CF appears to be in part irreversible.
| Footnotes |
|---|
; TSI = tobramycin
solution for inhalation The author has received speaking and consulting fees from Chiron Corporation.
Presented in part at the 1999 North American Cystic Fibrosis Conference, Seattle, WA, October 710, 1999.
Received for publication February 6, 2001. Accepted for publication June 28, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S P Conway Nebulized antibiotic therapy: the evidence Chronic Respiratory Disease, January 1, 2005; 2(1): 35 - 41. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. J. Wine and N. S. Joo Submucosal Glands and Airway Defense Proceedings of the ATS, January 1, 2004; 1(1): 47 - 53. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. E. Robinson, A. N. Leung, W. H. Northway, F. G. Blankenberg, F. P. Chan, D. A. Bloch, T. H. Holmes, and R. B. Moss Composite Spirometric-Computed Tomography Outcome Measure in Early Cystic Fibrosis Lung Disease Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., September 1, 2003; 168(5): 588 - 593. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. B. Vakulenko and S. Mobashery Versatility of Aminoglycosides and Prospects for Their Future Clin. Microbiol. Rev., July 1, 2003; 16(3): 430 - 450. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. B. Fiel Early Aggressive Intervention in Cystic Fibrosis: Is It Time To Redefine Our "Best Practice" Strategies? Chest, January 1, 2003; 123(1): 1 - 3. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |