|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Respiratory Unit, Department of Medicine (Drs. Wong and Hopley), and Department of Radiology (Dr. Szkup), Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital, and the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Correspondence to: Michelle L. Wong, MD, FCCP, PO Box 2588, Northcliff, Johannesburg, South Africa 2115; e-mail: 014miche{at}chiron.wits.ac.za
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design, setting, patients, interventions: Sixteen consecutive patients who underwent percutaneous embolotherapy for life-threatening hemoptysis in a tertiary-care hospital were evaluated retrospectively. The bronchial arteries, as well as other intrathoracic arteries, were evaluated and selectively embolized if they were considered to supply the pathologic area from which the hemoptysis arose.
Results: The most common cause for hemoptysis was posttuberculous bronchiectasis (n = 12) with or without mycetomas. Ten patients required blood transfusions before embolotherapy. Pleural disease was noted on the chest radiograph in 13 patients and was generally associated with the presence of nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels. In three patients, arteries other than the bronchial arteries were the only source of hemoptysis. Percutaneous embolotherapy was successful in controlling the hemoptysis in all patients. The only complication documented was a transient paraparesis in one patient. Six patients did not return for follow-up. Of the remaining 10 patients, 3 patients had minor episodes of hemoptysis that were treated conservatively with success. One patient had significant recurrent hemoptysis that was managed with radiotherapy. One patient subsequently underwent a lobectomy.
Conclusion: Percutaneous embolotherapy is a useful therapeutic modality in the management of life-threatening hemoptysis. The contribution of nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels, particularly where there is evidence of coexistent pleural disease, should always be suspected. In experienced hands, this is a safe and potentially life-saving procedure.
Key Words: bronchial arteries bronchiectasis embolization embolotherapy hemoptysis therapeutic
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The term massive hemoptysis is loosely applied in the literature. Various authors1 2 3 4 5 use this phrase for the expectoration of an amount of blood varying from as little as 200 mL to as much as 1,000 mL over 24 to 48 h. The volume of blood loss is often underestimated because a significant amount may remain in the lung and may not be expectorated. Others2 have shown that the rate of blood loss is a better predictor of mortality.
We have used the term life-threatening hemoptysis to denote one of the following: (1) expectoration of at least 250 mL of blood in 24 h; (2) requirement for blood transfusion because of a significant decrease in hemoglobin level; or (3) failure or inadequacy of conservative management of the hemoptysis (supplemental oxygen, morphine, and antibiotics) either because of ongoing hemoptysis or because the hemoptysis posed a serious threat to life in patients with significant pulmonary functional impairment. All patients were assessed by one of the pulmonary physicians (M.L.W. or M.J.H.). The purpose of this analysis was to assess the value of bronchial artery embolization in this group of patients and to assess how frequently the bronchial arteries were the major source of the bleeding.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Embolotherapy
Angiography and embolization were performed using a
high-resolution digital subtraction angiography unit (Angiostar;
Siemens; Erlangen, Germany). Fourteen of the 16 patients were
treated by the same radiologist (P.S.); two other radiologists were
involved in the management of the remaining two patients. None of the
patients required mechanical ventilation before, during, or after the
embolization procedure.
Diagnostic thoracic aortography was performed via cannulation of the femoral artery in all patients. The number, location, and degree of pathologic enlargement of the bronchial arteries, as well as the presence of nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels (in particular, intercostal arteries from T4 to T7, subclavian arteries, and internal mammary arteries) were evaluated in all patients. After aortography, selective catheterization of all arteries responsible for hemoptysis, if technically feasible, was performed using 4F to 5F H1, C2, or Simmons catheters (Cordis; Miami, FL). Omnipaque (Nycomed Imaging; Oslo, Norway) was the contrast agent used.
Arteries were considered pathologic if they were hypertrophied, or demonstrated vascular blush or arteriovenous shunting. Extravasation of the contrast agent was not visualized in any patient. Embolization was performed using 250- to 750-µm polyvinyl alcohol particles (Trufill; Cordis). In one patient, standard steel coils (Cook; Bloomington, IN) were used to embolize the internal mammary artery. Diagnostic angiography was routinely performed during the embolotherapy procedure to exclude the presence of spinal arteries arising from the bronchial or intercostal arteries. Spinal arteries, if found before or after partial embolization, were not considered a contraindication to embolization. In these cases, the catheter was positioned so that the tip was distal to the origin of the spinal artery, and larger particles were then used. The rationale for this technique is that these larger particles will occlude the abnormal hypertrophied bronchial or intercostal arteries, but will be too large to pass into the smaller spinal arteries, thus avoiding occlusion of the latter.
A coaxial microcatheter system was not used in any patient. Pulmonary angiography was not performed in any patient.
Analysis
The following factors were examined in the study population: the
underlying etiology for the hemoptysis, the presence or absence of
pleural thickening (assessed on plain chest radiography) in the area of
lung from which the bleeding had arisen, the arteries that required
occlusion by embolotherapy, the lowest hemoglobin concentration
measured before embolotherapy, and the incidence of complications
consequent to the embolization procedure. Outcome at follow-up visits
was also assessed.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Underlying Cause of Hemoptysis
Twelve patients had underlying bronchiectasis, the etiology of
which was posttuberculous in all patients except one (Table 1) . Four of
these patients also had mycetomas. Three patients had active pulmonary
tuberculosis. One patient had inoperable primary bronchogenic
adenocarcinoma.
Severity of Anemia Before Embolotherapy
An estimate of the volume of blood expectorated before
embolization was documented in 11 of the 16 patients. In all patients
except for one, the volume of blood expectorated was > 500 mL in a
24-h period. The lowest hemoglobin concentration recorded for each
patient before embolotherapy varied from 4.4 to 12.3 g/dL
(mean ± SD, 8.6 ± 2.7 g/dL). Ten patients required blood
transfusions. One of these patients (patient 9) received > 10 U of
packed RBCs during his hospital admission.
Presence of Pleural Disease
Pleural disease (thickening) in the region from which the
hemoptysis originated was visible on the chest radiograph in all but
three patients (Table 2
).
|
|
|
|
In 13 patients, bronchial arteries supplied the radiographically abnormal area from which the hemoptysis had most likely arisen. However, in 11 of these patients, other arteries (intercostal arteries, the internal mammary artery, branches from the subclavian artery) also fed the abnormal network of vessels. We can only surmise that these nonbronchial collateral vessels played a role in the hemoptysis.
Of the 13 patients with pleural thickening adjacent to the radiologically abnormal area of lung parenchyma on the chest radiograph, all patients except three had vessels other than the bronchial arteries also involved in the abnormal vascular network. Of the three patients without obvious pleural thickening, two patients had vessels other than the bronchial arteries involved. It is possible that pleural disease may have been detected in these patients, had a more sensitive radiologic technique, such as CT, been used.
Three of the 13 patients with radiologic evidence of pleural disease did not undergo embolization of any nonbronchial systemic vessels. In patient 3, no systemic collateral supply was documented. Small collateral vessels were noted to originate from the left lateral thoracic artery in patient 4; these were too small to be selectively cannulated for embolization. Patient 6 was found to have a very tortuous right subclavian artery that prohibited cannulation and examination of the internal mammary artery and other branches.
Complications of Embolotherapy
One patient (patient 1) experienced transient paraparesis
(previously documented)6
but subsequently recovered fully.
Another patient who had active pulmonary tuberculosis and was HIV
seropositive with a CD4 cell count of 184/µL developed disseminated
herpes zoster 3 days after embolotherapy. A large right
hemopneumothorax developed that required tube thoracostomy. This was
considered an incidental adverse event unrelated to the embolization
procedure. All other patients had an uneventful course.
Follow-up
The duration of follow-up for the 16 patients ranged from 0 to 28
months (median, 1.5 months). Six patients did not return for any
follow-up visits. Patient 1 presented with hemoptysis (100 mL) 10
months after she underwent embolotherapy. This subsided with antibiotic
therapy. Patient 4 underwent a left upper lobectomy 6 weeks after
embolization for ongoing minor hemoptysis and a recurrent left
pneumothorax. He was well when last seen 2 years postoperatively.
Patient 6 was referred to the oncology service for palliative
radiotherapy for his lung tumor. Patient 10 had three further hospital
admissions for recurrent hemoptysis, all of which were resolved with
conservative therapy (supplemental oxygen, morphine, and
antibiotics). A CT scan performed after his last hospital
admission demonstrated a left upper lobe mycetoma that had not been
detected on his chest radiograph. Patient 12 was readmitted for
significant hemoptysis 27 months after bronchial artery embolization. A
repeat procedure was planned but was cancelled because of technical
reasons. She was discharged after the hemoptysis resolved with
conservative therapy. Patient 15 required two hospital admissions at 7
weeks and 12 weeks, respectively, after the embolization procedure. On
the first occasion, he presented again with significant hemoptysis and
was successfully treated with radiotherapy. On the second occasion,
minor hemoptysis responded to antibiotic therapy. Ten weeks later,
primary carcinoma of the esophagus was diagnosed and he was referred to
the surgical department, which determined that the tumor was
inoperable. An esophageal stent was inserted. After his third hospital
admission for hemoptysis 15 months after embolotherapy, he underwent a
second course of radiotherapy. He died as a result of the esophageal
malignancy 7 months later.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In situations in which pulmonary resection will eliminate the cause for the hemoptysis, this is the treatment of choice. Unlike other modalities, surgical resection is curative. In patients who are unsuitable surgical candidates, who refuse surgical treatment, or for whom appropriate medical therapy will ultimately lead to a cure, control of the hemorrhage may be achieved by various other options. These include cold saline solution lavage via bronchoscopy,7 8 endobronchial balloon tamponade with or without endobronchial instillation of epinephrine,9 10 instillation of thrombin or fibrinogen-thrombin infusions endobronchially via fiberoptic bronchoscopy,11 laser photocoagulation,12 radiotherapy,13 or bronchial artery embolization.14 15 Selection of the modality of treatment will be determined by the underlying etiology for the hemoptysis and the available expertise at the center to which the patient presents. All of these procedures should be regarded as temporizing measures before more definitive management. Unfortunately, these are the only options available for functionally compromised patients.
The etiology for massive hemoptysis in various parts of the world reflects the socioeconomic development of the geographic location.5 In South Africa, where the prevalence of tuberculosis is one of the highest in the world, most patients presenting with massive hemoptysis either have active tuberculosis or have the sequelae of this disease, such as bronchiectasis or colonization of old tuberculous cavities by Aspergillus. These patients frequently have bilateral disease and significantly compromised pulmonary function. Bronchial artery embolization has been demonstrated to be an effective means of managing these patients.4 16
Although deaths related to massive hemoptysis are most commonly caused by asphyxiation, acute loss of blood volume leading to shock may also occur. It has been shown that the bronchial circulation, rather than the pulmonary arterial circulation, is the usual source of bleeding from areas of acute and chronic lung inflammation and scarring. This vascular system can increase to more than one third of the systemic flow in chronic pulmonary disease.17
Bronchial artery anatomy varies greatly. In the majority of patients, the bronchial arteries arise directly from the aorta or from the intercostal arteries. Uflacker et al18 identified as many as 10 different patterns in a group of 72 patients who underwent bronchial artery embolization. However, bronchial arteries have also been described to arise from the subclavian, brachiocephalic, internal mammary, phrenic, and coronary arteries. The interventional radiologist performing embolotherapy needs to have a good working knowledge of these variants. Because catheterization of the bronchial and other arteries requires expertise and skill, the success of this procedure is dependent on the experience of the radiologist.
The parietal pleura is supplied by the intercostal, internal mammary, and musculophrenic arteries, whereas the visceral pleura derives its arterial supply from the bronchial arteries.19 Patients who have pleural disease in association with parenchymal abnormalities are more likely to have nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels supplying the bleeding area. For this reason, it is prudent to actively exclude such vessels as contributors to the origin of hemoptysis in cases where there is associated pleural disease. Indeed, in three of our patients, bleeding from systemic vessels other than the bronchial arteries was the only source of hemoptysis. In 9 of the remaining 13 patients, these vessels provided a significant contribution toward the hemoptysis.
Embolization of the bronchial arteries alone may achieve control of bleeding in a significant number of patients. Because it is not always routine to then exclude additional nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels, their presence is probably frequently missed and their importance difficult to estimate. Nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels may arise from the axillary, subclavian, thyrocervical, lateral thoracic, internal mammary, and phrenic arteries, as well as from the chest wall.20 21 22 Brinson et al23 reported 18 patients with cystic fibrosis and hemoptysis who underwent a total of 36 bronchial artery embolization procedures. The incidence of hemorrhage from nonbronchial systemic collateral vessels was 75% in patients with recurrent bleeding but only 8% in patients who underwent their first embolization procedure. In the series published by Keller et al,24 45% of 20 patients with massive or recurrent hemoptysis had a significant blood supply from nonbronchial collateral vessels. Vujic et al25 described three patients in whom hemoptysis was controlled by embolization of the intercostal arteries only. In another study,26 the internal mammary artery was demonstrated to be an important collateral supply in 11 of 23 patients with hemoptysis. It has been shown that both short-term and long-term outcomes are less successful in patients with pleural abnormalities,21 presumably because it may be impossible to occlude all significant collateral vessels supplying the diseased area.
Complications from embolotherapy in patients with hemoptysis are uncommon but have been described. These include spinal cord syndromes,6 25 27 28 bronchial stenosis,29 bronchoesophageal fistula,30 infarction of a bronchus,31 mediastinal hematoma after subintimal aortic dissection,28 and transient cortical blindness.32 Some of these complications may be attributable to the use of older ionic contrast agents33 or the use of alcohol as an embolic agent,31 rather than inadvertent embolization of important vessels. The most dreaded consequence of bronchial artery embolization is inadvertent occlusion of spinal arteries. In a study of 75 patients,18 in no patient was the anterior spinal artery demonstrated to arise from a bronchial artery or an intercostobronchial trunk. Cohen et al34 found a spinal artery branching from a vessel that also supplied the bronchial artery circulation in as many as 55% of 20 patients with cystic fibrosis. Interestingly, all were branches of right-sided bronchial arteries or right-sided head and neck vessels.
Although many authors feel that identification of the anterior spinal artery or spinal radicular arteries arising from the bronchial arteries is an absolute contraindication to proceed with embolization, others do not.4 14 18 23 It is noteworthy that in instances in which spinal cord injury followed embolotherapy, branches to the spinal cord were not identified at angiography.6 25 27 28 It is possible that arteries to the spinal cord may become angiographically visible only once embolization of larger hypertrophied bronchial vessels, into which flow will be preferentially directed, is achieved. In our series, a spinal artery was visualized in only one patient (patient 5). Cowling and Belli35 have also warned of potential complications related to the passage of particles from the bronchial circulation to the subclavian artery or its branches via collateral vessels.
Unless the underlying disease giving rise to hemoptysis can be cured by appropriate medical therapy, embolotherapy should be regarded as an interim measure to stabilize the patient before definitive management is instituted. However, many of these patients are not fit for lung resection surgery. In the study by Uflacker et al,18 bronchial artery embolization was successful in treating hemoptysis in 72.7% of 33 patients who underwent this procedure as the sole form of treatment.
Approximately 20% of patients who undergo embolotherapy will develop recurrent hemoptysis, usually within 6 months.36 37 In one study28 of 43 patients who underwent bronchial artery embolization, 7 of these patients experienced a recurrence of hemoptysis within 30 days of undergoing the procedure. Rebleeding may be caused by incomplete occlusion of vessels feeding the area (including bleeding from the pulmonary arterial circulation, which accounts for < 10% of patients with massive hemoptysis),20 recanalization of previously embolized vessels, the development of new collaterals, or inadequate treatment of the underlying disease. Repeat embolization may be successful in those patients who rebleed and in whom surgical intervention is not feasible.37 Where subsequent pulmonary resection is an alternative, the timing of surgery is a controversial issue. Factors to be taken into consideration include the likelihood of rebleeding given the underlying cause for hemoptysis, the proximity of appropriate medical facilities to the patients residence should a recurrent episode of life-threatening hemoptysis occur, and the accessibility of transport services.
Various materials have been used in embolization procedures, with polyvinyl alcohol (Ivalon; Cathmed Science; Paris, France) being the most popular because it is relatively nonbiodegradable and has low antigenicity. A histopathologic study in which Ivalon was used for embolotherapy38 confirmed prolonged vascular occlusion by fibrosis, although extravascular extravasation of polyvinyl alcohol particles was also documented.
| Conclusion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
To achieve good results with embolotherapy for massive hemoptysis, it may be insufficient to occlude the bronchial arteries only. Many patients, particularly those with evidence of pleural thickening, have a significant nonbronchial systemic collateral supply as well.21 24 37 39
In good hands, embolotherapy is an effective therapeutic tool with a low incidence of complications. The procedure may be repeated in those patients who develop a recurrence of hemoptysis. The recent use of microcatheters for superselective arterial embolization of target vessels is a promising method for minimizing complications in the future.40
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received for publication June 19, 2000. Accepted for publication July 23, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. F. Bruzzi, M. Remy-Jardin, D. Delhaye, A. Teisseire, C. Khalil, and J. Remy Multi-Detector Row CT of Hemoptysis RadioGraphics, January 1, 2006; 26(1): 3 - 22. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. C. Yoon, K. S. Lee, Y. J. Jeong, S. W. Shin, M. J. Chung, and O J. Kwon Hemoptysis: Bronchial and Nonbronchial Systemic Arteries at 16-Detector Row CT Radiology, January 1, 2005; 234(1): 292 - 298. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Remy-Jardin, N. Bouaziz, P. Dumont, P.-Y. Brillet, J. Bruzzi, and J. Remy Bronchial and Nonbronchial Systemic Arteries at Multi-Detector Row CT Angiography: Comparison with Conventional Angiography Radiology, December 1, 2004; 233(3): 741 - 749. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. Yoon, Y. H. Kim, J. K. Kim, Y. C. Kim, J. G. Park, and H. K. Kang Massive Hemoptysis: Prediction of Nonbronchial Systemic Arterial Supply with Chest CT Radiology, April 1, 2003; 227(1): 232 - 238. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. Yoon, J. K. Kim, Y. H. Kim, T. W. Chung, and H. K. Kang Bronchial and Nonbronchial Systemic Artery Embolization for Life-threatening Hemoptysis: A Comprehensive Review RadioGraphics, November 1, 2002; 22(6): 1395 - 1409. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |