|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Longitudinal Study Section (Drs. Harik-Khan and Fleg), Clinical Research Branch, National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health; and Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine (Dr. Wise), School of Medicine at the Johns Hopkins Asthma and Allergy Center, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD.
Correspondence to: Raida I. Harik-Khan, PhD, Clinical Research Branch, National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, 5600 Nathan Shock Dr, Baltimore, MD 21224; e-mail: harikkhanr{at}grc.nia.nih.gov
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study objective: To determine whether asymptomatic subjects with low initial body mass were at a greater risk of having COPD develop during subsequent follow-up.
Design and subjects: Observational retrospective study of 458 male and 192 female participants (age range, 40 to 73 years) in the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging. At baseline, the participants did not have COPD. After mean follow-up periods of 10.2 years for the men and 6.4 years for the women, 40 men and 7 women received a diagnosis of COPD.
Methods: Cox proportional-hazards regression models were used to assess the relationship between COPD diagnosis and baseline body mass index (BMI) in men.
Results: The risk of COPD developing in men varied inversely with baseline BMI, even after adjusting for other risk factors, including cigarette smoking, age, FEV1 percent predicted, abdominal obesity, and educational status. In men, the relative risk of COPD developing for the lowest BMI tertile relative to the highest tertile was 2.76 (95% confidence interval, 1.15 to 6.59). The small number of women who had COPD did not allow us to draw conclusions regarding BMI as a risk factor for COPD.
Conclusion: After controlling for confounding variables, men with low BMI are at increased risk for getting COPD.
Key Words: body mass index body weight lung diseases, obstructive
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
More recently, body weight has been shown to predict respiratory mortality in general population samples. Results from the Honolulu Heart Program5 indicated that in elderly Japanese-American men, age-adjusted mortality was highest in those with both BMI < 21 kg/m2 and FEV1 percent predicted < 70%. Furthermore, the Adventist Mortality Study of nonsmoking men and women demonstrated that low BMI was associated with an increased risk of respiratory disease mortality.6 7 In another general population study, Landbo et al8 selected subjects with COPD from the Copenhagen City Heart Study. Their results showed that low BMI predicted poor survival after adjustment for age, ventilatory function, and smoking.
The relationship between body mass and pulmonary function is complex and is influenced by several factors that include age, gender, and smoking status, among others. Recently, we have shown that abdominal obesity has a negative effect on pulmonary function that is more prominent in men than women.9 In addressing the association between body mass and lung function, Nemery et al10 raised the possibility that subjects who are susceptible to chronic obstructive lung disease may be leaner than subjects who were not susceptible. Thus, it is not clear whether low body weight is a risk factor for COPD or merely a consequence of established lung disease. Therefore, we examined this question using the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging (BLSA), a long-term aging study, which afforded us the opportunity to find out whether asymptomatic subjects with lower initial body mass were at a greater risk of COPD developing during subsequent follow-up.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Spirometry
Spirometric testing in the BLSA started in 1962 for men and in
1978 for women, and continued until 1994. Testing was performed as
previously described12
13
with a volume-displacement
water-sealed spirometer that met the accuracy criteria of the American
Thoracic Society.14
After 1987, measurements were
digitally recorded to permit automated determination of quality and
reproducibility. Spirometry tracings that were collected before 1987
were digitized to allow computerized assessment of quality and
reproducibility; only those participants who demonstrated two
acceptable quality maneuvers that were reproducible within 5% of the
largest value were included in the present study. Reproducibility
criteria were met when the second-largest FEV1
was within 5% of the largest value.12
FEV1 percent predicted was calculated by dividing
the observed FEV1 by the corresponding predicted
FEV1 values derived from the BLSA sex- and
race-specific cross-sectional FEV1 prediction
equation.12
15
Anthropometric Measurements
Anthropometric measurements were obtained at each visit.
Measurement of height was made using a clinical stadiometer in bare or
stocking feet. Body weight was measured with a calibrated precision
scale with subjects wearing a hospital gown. BMI, defined as weight
(kilograms) divided by the square of height (meters), was calculated.
Men were classified into tertiles of baseline BMI. Waist-hip
ratio (WHR) was measured in the standing position, as previously
reported,9
16
using a flexible metal tape.
Smoking and Socioeconomic Status
Smoking histories were obtained from the subjects and classified
as reported previously.12
13
Current cigarette
smokers were those who smoked cigarettes every day or who had quit
smoking < 2 years before the visit date. Never-smokers
were those who had not smoked > 5 to 10 packs of cigarettes, 50 to 75
cigars, or three to five packages of pipe tobacco during their
lifetime. Former smokers were those who had quit smoking
> 2 years before the visit. Occasional smokers were
defined as those who had smoked less than daily within the past 2 years
and who did not meet the definition of a never-smoker. Pipe and
cigar smokers were those who were currently smoking pipes or
cigars at the time of the examination. In this study, the effect of
smoking was evaluated by comparing current smokers with those who were
not currently smoking. Detailed information on pack-years of smoking
was not available. Education was used as a surrogate for socioeconomic
status. Because the participants were generally well educated, we
assessed the effect of socioeconomic status by comparing college
graduates with nongraduates.
COPD
At each visit, the BLSA medical staff performed physical
examinations on the participants and recorded clinical diagnoses.
Specific diagnosis was determined by the clinical staff based on
medical history, including the American Thoracic Society Division of
Lung Diseases pulmonary questionnaire,17
physical
examination, pulmonary function testing, and chest radiography. In this
study, COPD was considered to be present if the participants received
any of the following diagnoses during follow-up: emphysema, chronic
bronchitis, or chronic airway obstruction, and if
FEV1/FVC was < 0.7 during follow-up.
Among the five cases of emphysema in men, two cases were based on chest radiography, and one case was based on hyperinflation of the lungs and increased anterior-posterior chest diameter. The rationale for the remaining two emphysema cases was not stated specifically. Participants who received a diagnosis of asthma at any visit were excluded from the study cohort.
Statistical Analysis
We used the Cox proportional-hazards model18
to
assess the relationship between baseline BMI and the diagnosis of COPD
by computing the disease-specific risk ratios for BMI tertiles 1 and 2
relative to tertile 3 in male participants. Because of the small number
of women who had COPD, the analysis was limited to men. In
addition to tertiles of baseline BMI, candidate independent predictors
included the following baseline variables: age,
FEV1 percent predicted, current cigarette smoking
status (1 = current smoker, 0 = not currently smoking), WHR, and
education (1 = > 15-year education, 0 =
15-year education).
For participants with COPD, time was calculated as the difference
between age at entry and at diagnosis; for disease-free subjects, time
was defined as the difference between age at entry and age at last
visit. The final model was determined by backward elimination of the
nonsignificant variables. Coefficients were considered significant at
p
0.05. In addition, standard statistical
methods
including Students t test, analysis of variance, and the
Cochran-Armitage trend test were used (Tables 1
, 2
). All statistical analyses were performed using SAS software (SAS
Institute; Cary, NC).
|
|
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Table 1 shows that the mean ages, follow-up times, and educational levels of the men with COPD and men without COPD were similar. The men with COPD had lower BMIs and FEV1/FVC ratios at baseline and at their last visit. In the few COPD subjects in whom FEV1/FVC was > 0.7 at the time of diagnosis, the ratio fell to < 0.7 during follow-up. Although WHR was also lower in the group with COPD, the difference between the two groups was not significant. Table 1 also shows that, as expected, the men with COPD had a higher proportion of smokers both at baseline and at follow-up. The education level was similar in the two groups.
Effect of Baseline BMI on the Risk of Getting COPD
To explore the relationship between baseline BMI and subsequent
development of COPD, we classified the men into tertiles by BMI at
first visit (Table 2)
. Tertile 1 was defined as BMI
24.29
kg/m2, and tertile 3 was defined as BMI > 26.63
kg/m2, with tertile 2 in between the two levels.
The mean ages of the men, both at baseline and at last visit, were
similar in all three tertiles. Table 2
shows that as baseline BMI
tertile increased, the percentage of subjects with COPD progressively
decreased, while the ratio of FEV1/FVC increased.
Thus, the third tertile had the highest FEV1/FVC
and the smallest proportion of men with obstructive disease. The
inverse association of baseline BMI and subsequent COPD was significant
(p = 0.004 for trend). The lower FEV1 percent
predicted in the heaviest tertile, although of borderline significance
(0.06), is probably caused by the higher proportion of current smokers
and by the inverse relationship between abdominal obesity, as measured
by WHR and FEV1.9
It is interesting
that the proportion of current smokers was highest in the third BMI
tertile.
To determine the effect of lowering the cutoff value of the group with the lowest BMI, we performed another analysis using a cutoff point for BMI of 22 kg/m2. When this was done without changing the other cutoff points, we found that the frequency of COPD diagnosis in group 1 was 14.6% (6 of 41 patients), in group 2 was 10.2% (27 of 265 patients), and in group 3 was 4.6% (7 of 152 patients). The frequencies for groups 1 and 2 were slightly larger than those reported in Table 2 . Checking for trend effect using the Cochran-Armitage test gave a p value of 0.008, which was similar to that originally reported in Table 2 .
The Cox proportional-hazards model, as described in the "Materials and Methods," allowed us to adjust for the effect of smoking, age, and other baseline variables in determining the relationship between baseline BMI and the risk of getting COPD. Figure 1 shows that the risk of COPD decreased as baseline BMI tertile increased, and that the risk associated with the lightest tertile (tertile 1) relative to the heaviest tertile was significant (relative risk [RR], 2.76; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.15 to 6.59). As expected, current cigarette smoking conferred the highest risk (RR, 3.81; 95% CI, 1.92 to 7.54). Moreover, the RR associated with increased baseline age was 1.12/yr (95% CI, 1.07 to 1.18/yr) and 3.10/decade (1.1210). High baseline FEV1 percent predicted was protective, with RRs of 0.97 per 1% predicted (95% CI, 0.94 to 0.99) and 0.73 (0.9710) per 10% predicted. Years of education and WHR were not significantly associated with the risk of COPD diagnosis in this group of men.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
There is compelling evidence that poor nutritional status at birth or during early infancy is associated in adulthood with impaired lung function or the development of COPD. Follow-up studies revealed that in 60- to 70-year-old men born in Hertfordshire, England, low birth weight was a risk factor for impaired lung function after adjusting for smoking status and social class. The men in this study were also more likely to have died from COPD if their weight was low at the age of 1 year.21 The effect of low birth weight on respiratory disease is further underscored by the finding that despite its association with obesity,22 23 adult asthma is more likely to occur in individuals of low birth weight.23
Malnutrition is probably the main cause of poor gestational growth that was observed in the Hertfordshire study. Evidence that nutritional depletion during the fetal and neonatal periods can lead to permanent structural and functional changes in the lung is derived from studies24 25 26 27 28 29 in laboratory animals such as the rat and the guinea pig. Deprivation of calories or protein in neonatal rats caused retardation in lung growth, reduced elastin, enlargements in airspaces and alveoli, and decreases in elastic recoil, all of which are similar to findings in emphysema.24 25 27 28
Another possible explanation for the association between low baseline BMI and the increased risk of COPD in adult men is the finding that deficits in cell-mediated immunity and circulating T-lymphocyte numbers that result from protein-energy malnutrition can cause increased susceptibility to infections.30 This is of special importance for patients with COPD in whom a relatively minor respiratory infection can greatly compromise lung function.1 It is also consistent with the observation that low body mass is a risk factor for tuberculosis and other chronic lung infections.31
The effect of malnutrition on pulmonary function is mediated in part by its effect on respiratory muscles. Arora and Rochester32 showed that nutritional depletion reduced respiratory muscle strength in patients without lung diseases. This is probably caused by the positive correlation between body weight and isometric length of different muscle groups33 and by the fact that changes in body weight affect diaphragm muscle mass.34 Thurlbeck35 suggested that malnutrition, which often occurs in COPD, causes respiratory muscle wasting, as demonstrated by diaphragm weight in emphysematous patients being lower than expected for body weight. This muscle loss, coupled with the altered thoracic configuration, further compromises the action of the diaphragm in obstructive pulmonary disease.
Another possible explanation for the observed inverse association between BMI and the risk of COPD developing is that low body weight in men who are susceptible to disease may be attributable to the lower caloric intake by the cigarette smokers. If true, then a decreased body weight may be a sensitive indicator of the biological effects of cigarette smoke. However, it is unlikely that a smoking-induced low caloric intake can completely account for low BMI, because the association of leanness with a higher risk of respiratory mortality was also observed in lifetime never-smoking men and women in the Adventist Mortality Study.6 7
Energy expenditure in excess of energy intake leads to weight loss. There is evidence that resting energy expenditure and the oxygen cost of augmented ventilation are higher in patients with COPD who lose weight than in patients who have stable weight, or in healthy control subjects.36 37 38 Hugli et al39 reported that even though resting energy requirements were higher in patients with COPD, total energy expenditure was about the same as in control subjects because of the reduction of activity by the former. The relevance of these observations to the present study is not clear because our study subjects were selected to be clinically free of COPD at baseline.
A somewhat surprising result of this study is our finding that men with high baseline body mass had a lower risk of getting COPD. Although this finding is consistent with previous reports in the literature,2 8 20 which demonstrated that the obese subjects had lower COPD mortality rates, it is at variance with our previous finding9 that individuals with greater central obesity, as measured by WHR, tended to have lower lung function, and also with the finding22 23 that increased BMI is positively associated with the risk of adult-onset asthma. Perhaps the effect of central obesity is predominately restrictive, causing a reduction in both FVC and FEV1.
A major strength of the present study is that it provided prospective, comprehensive data over a long follow-up interval in a group of initially healthy, community-dwelling individuals. In contrast to previous studies, all of our study participants were deemed to be without clinical lung disease at the time of first evaluation. Moreover, the diagnosis of COPD was based on a comprehensive evaluation that included history, physical examination, pulmonary function testing, and chest radiography.
However, the study has limitations that must be acknowledged. First, even though our finding that women with COPD were heavier than those without COPD is consistent with the findings of Chen et al,40 there are an insufficient number of women with COPD in this study to enable us to draw conclusions regarding body weight as a risk factor for lung obstruction in women. Second, this study was composed largely of a higher socioeconomic, white population. Although this limits our ability to extend these findings to other racial and socioeconomic groups, it permits us to conclude that our results were not confounded by poverty, which is itself a risk factor for COPD.
In summary, we have found that low body weight as indicated by BMI is an important risk factor for subsequent development of COPD in men. This finding cannot be accounted for by smoking or other clinical and demographic measures. The source of this relationship is unclear but raises the possibility that early nutritional intervention may prevent or delay the occurrence of COPD.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received for publication March 2, 2001. Accepted for publication July 9, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. Sinvhal, L. Tosiello, G. Cable, R. I. Harik-Khan, J. L. Fleg, and R. A. Wise Confounding Issues in COPD Risk Study? Chest, January 1, 2003; 123(1): 307 - 308. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Guerra, D. L. Sherrill, A. Bobadilla, F. D. Martinez, and R. A. Barbee The Relation of Body Mass Index to Asthma, Chronic Bronchitis, and Emphysema Chest, October 1, 2002; 122(4): 1256 - 1263. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |