|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Respiratory Support and Sleep Center, Papworth Hospital, Papworth Everard, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Correspondence to: Anne-Marie Nugent, MD, Consultant Physician in Respiratory Medicine, Royal Victoria Hospital, Grosvenor Rd, Belfast BT12 6BA, Northern Ireland
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: Descriptive analysis of retrospective and prospective clinical data.
Setting: Inpatient, noninvasive respiratory-care unit in a tertiary referral center.
Patients: Sixteen patients with myotonic dystrophy, 13 of whom required ventilatory support.
Interventions and measurements: A retrospective study of all patients with myotonic dystrophy referred for assessment for assisted ventilation was performed, including results of arterial blood gas analysis, pulmonary function tests, and overnight oxygen saturation and transcutaneous carbon dioxide levels. A prospective reassessment of all patients established on domiciliary ventilation was performed, including measurements of quality of life.
Results: Results of arterial blood gas analysis showed a fall in mean PaCO2 from 64.3 to 53.8 mm Hg (p < 0.05) on discharge after starting ventilation and a rise in mean PaO2 from 53.0 to 65.3 mm Hg (p < 0.05). There were three deaths, at 5 months, 32 months, and 57 months, respectively. The survivors received assisted ventilation for a mean period of 27 months (range, 2 to 76 months). At reassessment, improvements in arterial blood gas levels were maintained, with mean PaCO2 of 52.4 mm Hg and PaO2 of 59.0 mm Hg. Mean overnight mean arterial oxygen saturation rose from 80.5 to 90.3% after the start of treatment (p < 0.001) and was maintained at 90.4% at reassessment. Mean transcutaneous PCO2 during sleep fell from 59.3 to 41.4 mm Hg (p < 0.05), and to 43.7 mm Hg at reassessment. There were no significant changes in spirometry or maximum mouth pressures. Compliance with treatment for our test group was lower than compliance in a group of age- and sex-matched postpoliomyelitis patients.
Conclusion: Use of domiciliary-assisted ventilation in patients with myotonic dystrophy is associated with prolonged survival and a sustained improvement in arterial blood gas tensions.
Key Words: mechanical ventilation myotonic dystrophy noninvasive positive-pressure ventilation respiratory failure
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Initial Assessment
Clinical history was obtained from all patients, including
presenting symptoms, details of myotonic dystrophy, smoking habits, and
medication. A full physical examination was performed. Hemoglobin
concentration was measured. Arterial blood gas analysis
(PaO2 and
PaCO2) when breathing air was
performed if possible before starting any assisted ventilation.
Pulmonary function tests were performed with measurement of
FEV1 and FVC using a dry spirometer (Vitalograph;
Bucks, UK); maximal mouth pressures during inspiration and expiration
were recorded using a pressure transducer (PK Morgan; Kent, UK) as
measure of respiratory muscle strength.
Where possible, before starting assisted ventilation, overnight levels of arterial oxygen saturation (SaO2) and transcutaneous PCO2 were recorded. SaO2 was measured using a pulse oximeter (Biox 3700; Ohmeda; Herts, UK), and transcutaneous PCO2 was measured using a heated polarographic electrode (TCM3; Radiometer; Copenhagen, Denmark). A two-channel recorder was used to produce a hard copy. From the paper tracings, the mean and minimum SaO2 levels, the desaturation index (the number of dips in SaO2 > 4%/h), and the mean transcutaneous PCO2 level were calculated and recorded. For the 13 patients requiring assisted ventilation, the indications for and type of ventilatory support were noted. The progress of the patients was recorded, including results of arterial blood gas analyses and overnight SaO2 and transcutaneous PCO2 at discharge, as well as PaO2 and PaCO2 on subsequent hospital admissions at 3- to 6-month intervals. Where relevant, details of death were obtained.
Reassessment
Ten patients were admitted to the hospital overnight for
reassessment. Clinical histories were obtained, including current
symptoms and perceived subjective benefit from ventilation. Arterial
blood gas analysis was performed with the patients at rest and
breathing room air. Venous blood was taken for measurement of
hemoglobin concentration, and a sample was also sent for genetic
analysis to quantify the number of cytosine-thymine-guanine
trinucleotide repeats on the myotonin gene, which are known to
be increased in patients with myotonic dystrophy.9
Pulmonary function tests were repeated, including spirometry and
maximal mouth pressures. Overnight recording of
SaO2 and transcutaneous
PCO2 was performed using ventilatory
support. Quality of life was assessed using three questionnaires: the
Short Form-36 health survey,10
the hospital anxiety and
depression scale (HAD),11
and the Beck depression
inventory.12
Compliance was monitored in all patients
using a clock on each ventilator that recorded the number of hours of
ventilator function. The additional hours used from the previous
assessment (within the preceding 6 months) allowed the daily hours of
ventilator use to be calculated. Comparison was made with
postpoliomyelitis patients who were provided with long-term assisted
ventilation from our center. Postpoliomyelitis patients were selected
as a control group because there were enough patients in the database
to obtain age- and sex-matched control subjects with complete records
of compliance for comparison.
Statistical Analysis
Comparison of test results before starting ventilation, after
being established on ventilatory support, and at reassessment was made
using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Between-group comparisons were
made using the Mann-Whitney U test. All p values < 0.05
were regarded as statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Commencing Assisted Ventilation
Any patient with symptoms of chronic respiratory failure and
proven hypercapnia (or acute respiratory decompensation) was considered
for ventilatory support. The indications for assisted ventilation
included chronic hypercapnic respiratory failure with
PaCO2 > 49 mm Hg (n = 11),
respiratory arrest requiring immediate intubation (n = 1), and
nocturnal hypoventilation with transcutaneous
PCO2 rising to > 56 mm Hg
(n = 1). Assisted ventilation was noninvasive in all patients, with
the exception of the patient who required immediate intubation. All but
one patient had at least one ongoing symptom in keeping with chronic
respiratory failure, including excessive daytime sleepiness, shortness
of breath, morning headache, or insomnia.
The results of baseline investigations before starting ventilatory support are shown in Table 1 . It was not possible to obtain overnight recordings of SaO2 and transcutaneous PCO2 for three patients: one patient required immediate intubation at another hospital and was transferred to our center for weaning, and two patients were commenced on noninvasive ventilation on the day of hospital admission because of severe respiratory failure with PaO2 < 49 mm Hg and PaCO2 > 68 mm Hg.
|
Long-term Response to Assisted Ventilation
During follow-up, two patients had changed interfaces with the
ventilator. One patient changed from a nasal mask to a face mask after
10 months because of mouth leaks, and one patient changed from a nasal
mask to tracheostomy after 3 years because of retained secretions.
Three patients died since starting assisted ventilation at home. One
patient died from cardiac failure after 5 years of successful pulmonary
treatment. Another patient died after 32 months with recurrent sigmoid
volvulus and bronchopneumonia. The third patient died of respiratory
failure after 5 months of treatment with which she did not comply
adequately. The remaining 10 patients received assisted ventilation for
a mean period of 27 months (range, 2 to 76 months) at reassessment, and
five patients received treatment for > 2 years. At reassessment,
eight patients experienced an overall benefit from treatment; in
particular, they experienced less daytime sleepiness and improved
nocturnal sleep. Of the two patients who experienced no improvement
from treatment, one patient was poorly compliant with use of the
ventilator, and the other patient was treated for only 2 months. The
patient with poor compliance had respiratory arrest and had no
symptomatic benefit from ventilator use.
Physiologic Responses to Assisted Ventilation
Arterial blood gas analysis before the start of ventilatory
support showed hypoxemia (mean PaO2,
53.0 mm Hg) and carbon dioxide retention (mean
PaCO2, 64.3 mm Hg). As shown in Table 1
, there was a significant improvement before discharge, with a rise in
mean PaO2 to 65.3 mm Hg and a fall in
mean PaCO2 to 53.8 mm Hg. At
reassessment in the survivors, these improvements were maintained.
Figure 1
shows the changes in arterial blood gas results with time from start of
ventilation.
|
|
Quality of Life
The results of the Short Form-36 survey that showed the greatest
differences were in physical function and role limitation caused by
physical limitations, which were both 72% lower in subjects when
compared with age- and sex-matched control subjects.13
The
smallest differences were in mental health and role limitation caused
by emotional problems, which were 8% and 18%, respectively. In the
HAD questionnaire, where a score > 10 suggests clinically relevant
anxiety or depression, no patient reached that level of anxiety;
however, two patients had raised scores for depression. In the Beck
Depression Inventory, four patients had a score > 15, suggesting
moderate-to-severe depression.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This study has shown that patients with myotonic dystrophy can be established on prolonged ventilatory support at home with immediate and sustained improvements in physiologic parameters. This has been shown in other disorders including scoliosis, thoracoplasty, postpoliomyelitis, and other neuromuscular diseases.17 18 19 Although there was no control group in this study because we believed it would be unethical not to offer ventilatory support to a patient with respiratory failure, there seems to be prolonged survival on assisted ventilation with more than one half of the patients receiving treatment for > 2 years.
The most common presenting symptom in this study was excessive daytime sleepiness. This is well recognized in patients with myotonic dystrophy and may also occur in the absence of respiratory failure.4 20 21 Explanatory factors may include sleep disruption associated with frequent apneas5 and a central neurogenic abnormality.20 Although the excessive sleepiness may not be corrected with treatment, the majority of patients in this study felt more alert after starting assisted ventilation. Other symptoms, including shortness of breath, sleep disturbance, and morning headache, also improved.
Important aspects of management in this group of patients included selection of an appropriate ventilator and interface for each patient. When selecting a ventilator, consideration was given to trigger sensitivity and the ability to deliver positive expiratory pressure, in particular if there was evidence of obstructive apneas. We noted that a considerable number of patients had mouth leaks of air when using a nasal mask, and they required a face mask. This was most likely caused by facial muscle weakness. Even with a face mask, there could be considerable air leaks, and it was important to have a range available to ensure that the mask fit well.
The patients often appeared to be poorly motivated, and repeated education with both patient and family or the caregiver regarding treatment was essential. Depressive tendencies as well as low intelligence and personality disturbances have previously been noted in patients with myotonic dystrophy, and it is unclear whether the depression is a direct result of brain dysfunction or a secondary reaction to the physical disability.16 22 Given the neuropsychological problems in this group of patients, we were concerned about compliance with treatment. The overall number of hours of ventilation used was lower for patients with myotonic dystrophy compared with a group of age- and sex-matched post-poliomyelitis patients. Compliance appeared to be a particular problem in one third of the patients who used the ventilator for < 5 h/d. The poorly compliant patients rarely admitted to not using the ventilator and were often adamant that they were complying. It is important to note that compliance with treatment may be a problem with these patients; ventilator hours of use should be monitored regularly, and the benefits of treatment to patient and caregiver need to be reinforced.
An attempt was made to evaluate quality of life while receiving treatment. Unfortunately, patients did not complete questionnaires before starting treatment, so the information obtained is limited. From the Short Form-36 questionnaire, the most marked difference from healthy control subjects was a reduction in physical function, which is to be expected given the muscle weakness associated with myotonic dystrophy. However, there were no significant differences in mental health and role limitation caused by emotional factors. The HAD and Beck Depression Inventory suggested the presence of depression in a small proportion of the patients, although the proportion did not differ significantly from a survey from UK general practice.23 Cost of treatment was not addressed directly in this study; however, long-term domiciliary ventilation is cheaper than monitoring patients in hospital. The capital cost of the equipment is relatively small at approximately $5,000 per ventilator.
In conclusion, this study has shown that use of domiciliary-assisted ventilation in patients with myotonic dystrophy is associated with prolonged survival and an improvement in arterial blood gas tensions that is maintained. Quality-of-life assessment shows a similar emotional status compared with control subjects, despite a marked reduction in physical function. Domiciliary-assisted ventilation should be considered in patients with myotonic dystrophy in whom respiratory failure develops. This treatment can be successfully implemented despite the physical and psychological disabilities in patients with myotonic dystrophy.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Dr. Nugent was supported by funding from the Northern Ireland Postgraduate Council for Medical and Dental Education and the Doctor Samuel Ireland Turkington Research Scholarship, The Queens University of Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Received for publication May 23, 2000. Accepted for publication August 14, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. S Howard and C. Davidson Long term ventilation in neurogenic respiratory failure J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry, September 1, 2003; 74(90003): iii24 - 30. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. Laghi and M. J. Tobin Disorders of the Respiratory Muscles Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., July 1, 2003; 168(1): 10 - 48. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |