|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From Genentech (Drs. Johnson and Butler), South San Francisco, CA; the Department of Pediatrics (Dr. Konstan), Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, OH; Arizona Health Sciences Center (Dr. Morgan), Tucson, AZ; and the Department of Pediatrics (Dr. Wohl), Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Correspondence to: Charles Johnson, MB,ChB, Genentech, 1 DNA Way, Mail Stop 59, South San Francisco, CA 94080; e-mail: johnson.charles{at}gene.com
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: To determine whether differences in lung health existed between groups of patients attending different CF care sites and to determine whether these differences are associated with differences in monitoring and intervention.
Design: The analysis was conducted using data from the Epidemiologic Study of Cystic Fibrosis from 1995 through 1996.
Setting: This was an observational database collecting prospective information from a large number of CF patients undergoing routine care in North America.
Participants: Participating sites that had at least 50 CF patients who had each made at least one visit to a center during the 2-year study period were ranked on the basis of median values for FEV1 within each of three age groups (6 to 12 years, 13 to 17 years, and
18 years).
Interventions: There were no prespecified interventions in this observational study.
Main outcome measures: The frequency of patient monitoring and the use of therapeutic interventions were compared between sites in the upper and lower quartiles after stratification within the site for disease severity.
Results: Within-site rankings tended to be consistent across the three age groups. Patients who were treated at higher ranking sites had more frequent monitoring of their clinical status, measurements of lung function, and cultures for respiratory pathogens. These patients also received more interventions, particularly IV antibiotics for pulmonary exacerbations.
Conclusion: We found substantial differences in lung health across different CF care sites. We found that frequent monitoring and increased use of appropriate medications in the management of CF are associated with improved outcomes.
Key Words: cystic fibrosis epidemiology evaluation monitoring spirometry respiratory tract culture treatment
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
31 years.2
3
This remarkable advance has been achieved through the establishment of specialized care facilities, improved pancreatic enzyme preparations, and the development of effective antibiotics with which to treat pulmonary exacerbations.4
5
Guidelines developed by the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation6
have contributed to the standardization of CF management. These guidelines recommend that patients have at least four clinical visits per year, that the measurement of lung function be performed every 6 months, and that cultures of respiratory tract secretions be conducted annually. In assessing outcomes for CF patients, the ideal measure is mortality. However, relatively few patients die in the short term. Therefore, measurements of pulmonary function have become surrogate outcomes in most clinical trials,7 8 9 10 as there is a strong association between lung function and mortality rates.11 12 13
The Epidemiologic Study of Cystic Fibrosis (ESCF) is a multicenter, longitudinal, observational study that prospectively collects detailed clinical, therapeutic, microbiological, and lung function data from a large number of CF treatment sites in the United States and Canada.14 15 16 Initiated in December 1993, the study enrolled 18,411 patients by December 31, 1995.
The goal of this study was to identify whether differences in outcomes, specifically lung health as ascertained using the surrogate marker of FEV1, existed between care sites. We sought to determine whether particular practice patterns at care sites were associated with better outcomes.
In light of data linking improved survival to the frequent use of IV antibiotics,17 an additional goal of the study was to determine whether intensive treatment with IV antibiotics was associated with better outcomes.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The three age groups (6 to 12 years, 13 to 17 years, and
18 years) at each site were ranked on the basis of the last "stable" median FEV1 percent predicted value.18
The upper and lower quartiles of these groups were compared. The patients in the upper and lower quartiles of each age group were pooled (Table 1 ) and stratified by FEV1 for the comparison of practices (Table 2
), outcomes (Table 3
), and interventions (Tables 4 and 5
). The definitions of severity used the CF Foundation categories of < 40% predicted of FEV1 values for severe disease and 40 to 69% predicted for moderate disease, with a modification of 70 to 99% predicted for mild disease and
100% predicted for normal. This definition is consistent with the CF groupings, the population of which was distributed so that the severity groups had sufficient numbers for analysis. If there were < 10 patients in a specific age group at an individual site, the site was excluded from the evaluation of that age group. To be included in this analysis, each center had to have at least 50 patients who had made at least one visit during the 2-year period and had at least one spirometry test value.
|
|
|
|
|
100% of predicted). This allowed the sites in the upper and lower quartiles to be compared based on their practices within groups of patients with similar lung health.
Statistical Methods
For each possible pair of the three age groups, the consistency of site rankings between the two age groups was assessed using Spearman rank correlation coefficients. Statistical comparison of upper quartile sites with lower quartile sites were done using Mantel-Haenszel tests for dichotomous variables and Wilcoxon rank sum tests for counts of events or durations of therapy, with stratification by FEV1 (ie, < 40% of predicted, 40 to 69% of predicted, 70 to 99% of predicted, and
100% of predicted) so that practices were compared within patients of a similar severity level. Stratified descriptive statistics included either proportions for dichotomous variables, means for counts of events or medians for duration of therapy. The quartiles also were compared globally on the overall mean FEV 1 percent predicted and weight for age percentile using t tests.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
18 years of age), 103 sites with 3,030 patients (mean, 29 patients per site; SD, 24 patients per site) were eligible. The observation that a consistent trend of monitoring and intervention was observed across the four quartiles (ie, that the middle quartiles fell between the upper and lower extremes) allowed the subsequent analysis to be restricted to the upper and lower quartiles.
For sites that qualified with at least two age groups, the rankings of sites tended to be consistent across the age groups with Spearman rank correlation coefficients of 0.30 for ages 6 to 12 years and 13 to 17 years (p = 0.007; 80 patients), 0.29 for ages 6 to 12 years and
18 years (p = 0.007; 84 patients), and 0.17 for ages 13 to 17 years and
18 years (p = 0.17; 69 patients). Considering each pair of age groups, very few sites (six or fewer) were in the upper quartile in one age group and the lower quartile in the other age group.
The observed differences between upper and lower quartile sites in disease severity, as characterized by FEV1 percent predicted, were substantial, ranging from 15 to 23% of age points (Table 1) .
Comparing patients within each of the severity groups, the monitoring of events (ie, number of visits, spirometry testing, and cultures) occurred more frequently at upper quartile sites (Table 2) . These trends were highly statistically significant in each age group. The greatest differences in the number of cultures were seen in the youngest age group, which had 40 to 77% more cultures performed at upper quartile sites than at lower quartile sites.
Certain microorganisms were reported more frequently at upper quartile sites (Table 3) . Compared with the lower quartile sites, there was a higher incidence of patients with at least one culture positive for Pseudomonas aeruginosa and for at least one strain of this organism that was reported as "multiply resistant." Also, compared with the lower quartile sites, there were more patients with at least one culture positive for Burkholderia cepacia, and for Stenotrophomonas maltophilia at the upper quartile sites.
Some therapies were used more frequently at the upper quartile sites (Table 4) . Upper quartile sites administered oral corticosteroids and inhaled cromolyn or nedocromil more frequently than did lower quartile sites consistently across all age and disease-severity groups. Very large differences were seen in the use of inhaled cromolyn and nedocromil, ranging from 10 to 42% (p < 0.001). Oral nonquinolone antibiotics also were used more frequently in upper quartile sites. Prophylactic inhaled antibiotics (ie, aminoglycoside and quinolones) were used more frequently in young pediatric patients. Among other routine therapies, substantial and significant differences were observed only in adults. In this age group, upper quartile sites administered more inhaled bronchodilators, more inhaled corticosteroids, and more dornase alfa than lower quartile sites (Table 4) . No differences were seen in the use of pancreatic enzymes and airway clearance techniques, which were used by > 90% of patients in almost all age and disease-severity groups. No attempts were made to quantify airway clearance techniques.
For patients who were < 18 years of age, upper quartile sites tended to report more frequent treatments of exacerbations with IV antibiotics (Table 5) . These differences were proportionately largest in the relatively healthy patients, particularly in the age group of 13 to 17 years. Upper quartile sites also tended to treat patients for longer periods, regardless of disease severity. This trend was particularly strong in adult patients, for whom the increased duration was highly significant (p < 0.001). Upper quartile sites also reported more frequent treatments of exacerbations with inhaled antibiotics in patients < 18 years, with differences once again proportionately largest in the relatively healthy patients. In contrast, in patients < 18 years of age the reported use of oral quinolones for the treatment of exacerbations tended to be greater in lower quartile sites, except in the youngest, sickest patients (6 to 12 years of age, < 40% predicted FEV1). In adults, there was no significant difference between upper and lower quartile sites for the use of inhaled antibiotics or oral quinolones. Because of less accurate documentation of stop dates for inhaled antibiotics and oral quinolones, the duration of treatment could not be reliably assessed.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Possible explanations for the substantial differences in lung function results between the upper and lower quartile sites include differences in the patterns of practice, but they might also include genetic or other differences in the local patient populations, differences in local conditions including climate, the distance that patients live from the site, and socioeconomic status. Data from the CF Foundation Registry indicate that in 1996 only 226 of the 19,570 patients (1.4%) reported a lack of insurance coverage, so at least this aspect of socioeconomic status is not likely to be an important factor.20 Upper quartile sites were somewhat more likely to be located in the northeastern region of the United States, and, in the pediatric age groups only, there was a tendency toward larger sites in the upper quartile compared to the lower quartile. Although the results of this study suggest that the upper quartile sites were more likely to perform special assessments and prescribe some therapies, another possible explanation that always exists in observational studies is more thorough reporting of these events at upper quartile sites. To guard against this possibility, each site received patient-specific data reports and was requested to verify the accuracy of their data.
The use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs was not considered because, at the time of this study, the ESCF did not distinguish high-dose ibuprofen therapy9 from the analgesic use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications.
Oral nonquinolone antibiotics were extensively used for treatment of patients across all age and severity groups. Those antibiotics were used significantly less often in adolescent and adult patients at the lower quartile centers than in those patients at the upper quartile centers. These data are consistent with those from a study undertaken in the United Kingdom21 indicating improved outcomes for young CF patients who received long-term antistaphylococcal therapy. Regarding the use of antibiotics to treat pulmonary exacerbations, the most striking differences between upper and lower quartile sites occurred in patients < 18 years of age, particularly in the adolescent age group. Adolescents from upper quartile sites received more treatment with IV and inhaled antibiotics, and less treatment with oral quinolones. For IV and inhaled antibiotics, the differences were greater for patients with milder lung disease, suggesting that these patients were treated more aggressively. The duration of treatment with IV antibiotics was also greater in upper quartile sites in adolescents, as well as in adults. More intensive use of IV and inhaled antibiotics at upper quartile sites might account for the better lung function observed in patients at these sites.
The identification of a pulmonary exacerbation warranting antibiotic therapy, particularly IV therapy, may be related to the frequency of obtaining spirometry, since a fall in FEV1 values commonly results in treatment for a pulmonary exacerbation. Whatever leads to the decision to treat, it appears that the upper quartile sites are treating patients more often, particularly those considered to have mild lung disease. One possible conclusion from these data is that the use of antibiotics contributes to the improved outcomes seen in patients at upper quartile sites. Support for intensive antibiotic therapy comes from data reported in a Danish study,17 which have shown that a program of quarterly hospital admissions for IV antipseudomonal therapy is associated with improved survival. Further support for intensive antibiotic therapy also comes from studies of inhaled, high-dose tobramycin.10 However, other factors in Denmark, such as attention to nutritional support and access to state-supported health care facilities, also may play a role in improved outcomes.
These data suggest a greater prevalence of multiply resistant P aeruginosa, B cepacia, and S maltophilia at upper quartile sites. This could represent an important and disturbing association between increased antibiotic use and the emergence of resistant strains. It is possible that this results from an ascertainment bias due to the higher frequency of cultures in the upper quartile sites. We have shown previously20 that increased frequency of cultures and better culture techniques result in the increased identification of resistant organisms. This observation highlights the need for continued research into improved antimicrobial agents and a better understanding of the mechanisms of colonization and infection of the lung and the development of antibiotic resistance in CF.
Both inhaled cromolyn or nedocromil and oral corticosteroids were administered more often at upper quartile sites. The association between poor outcomes in CF patients and a vigorous inflammatory response was first noted by Wheeler et al22 and led to a large multicenter trial23 of oral corticosteroid use in CF patients. Although this study showed a clear benefit in terms of the maintenance of pulmonary function, a 1996 review4 stated that the adverse effects on linear growth and glucose metabolism should limit the long-term use of oral corticosteroids. This analysis demonstrates the widespread use of both oral and inhaled corticosteroids but does not distinguish between long-term and sporadic use.
A surprising result of this analysis is the finding of an increased administration of inhaled cromolyn or nedocromil at upper quartile sites. These agents are known to modulate the inflammatory response but are also reported to block non-CF transmembrane receptor chloride channels.24 25 Cromolyn-mediated or nedocromil-mediated blocking of chloride channels would appear to be counterproductive. The strength of the observed association warrants investigation into possible mechanisms that might explain this paradox.
In summary, this large observational study of CF demonstrates significant and clinically relevant differences across sites in lung health as measured by FEV1. The striking finding of this analysis is the consistency with which the sites in the upper quartile, regardless of age and disease severity, monitor and treat patients more frequently than do lower quartile centers. This association is particularly strong for younger and relatively healthy CF patients. These results suggest, but do not prove, the hypothesis that frequent monitoring and more interventions, including the more frequent use of IV antibiotics for longer duration, potentially result in better outcomes for CF patients.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Drs. Johnson and Butler are employees of Genentech. Drs. Konstan, Morgan, and Wohl are consultants for the Epidemiologic Study of Cystic Fibrosis sponsored by Genentech. All sources of support for the Epidemiologic Study of Cystic Fibrosis in the form of grants, case report forms, and data analysis were provided by Genentech.
Received for publication November 19, 2001. Accepted for publication May 22, 2002.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. A. Merlo, M. P. Boyle, M. Diener-West, B. C. Marshall, C. H. Goss, and N. Lechtzin Incidence and Risk Factors for Multiple Antibiotic-Resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa in Cystic Fibrosis Chest, August 1, 2007; 132(2): 562 - 568. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. H. McMullen, D. J. Pasta, P. D. Frederick, M. W. Konstan, W. J. Morgan, M. S. Schechter, J. S. Wagener, and for the Investigators and Coordinators of the Epid Impact of Pregnancy on Women With Cystic Fibrosis Chest, March 1, 2006; 129(3): 706 - 711. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. Nathanson, G. Ramirez-Garnica, and S. A. Wiltrout Decreased Attendance at Cystic Fibrosis Centers by Children Covered by Managed Care Insurance Am J Public Health, November 1, 2005; 95(11): 1958 - 1963. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Verma, A. Bush, and R. Buchdahl Is There Still a Gender Gap in Cystic Fibrosis? Chest, October 1, 2005; 128(4): 2824 - 2834. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. A. de Jong, Y. Nakano, W. C. Hop, F. R. Long, H. O. Coxson, P. D. Pare, and H. A. Tiddens Changes in Airway Dimensions on Computed Tomography Scans of Children with Cystic Fibrosis Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med., July 15, 2005; 172(2): 218 - 224. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N A Jarad, S Higgs, T Jeffcote, and K Giles Factors associated with reduced FEV1 in adult patients with cystic fibrosis in a relatively affluent area Chronic Respiratory Disease, July 1, 2005; 2(3): 133 - 137. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |