|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Department of Surgery Course of Interventional Medicine (E1), Osaka University Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka, Japan.
Correspondence to: Shin-ichi Takeda, MD, PhD, FCCP, Toneyama National Hospital Toneyama, 5-1-1 Toyonaka 560-8552, Japan; e-mail: stakeda{at}toneyama.hosp.go.jp
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: Retrospective study.
Objectives: University hospital unit of general thoracic surgery.
Methods: We retrospectively reviewed the records of 105 patients with cysts of the mediastinum (50 male and 55 female patients) who comprised 13.0% of mediastinal masses over the past 50 years.
Results: There were 10 pediatric patients (< 15 years old) and 95 adult patients. The prevalence of cysts in the adult populations was higher than that in children (14.1% vs 7.7%, p < 0.05). There were 47 bronchogenic cysts, 30 thymic cysts, 12 pericardial cysts, 7 pleural cysts, 4 esophageal duplications, 2 meningoceles, 1 thoracic duct cyst, and 2 others. MRI has become a useful tool for providing supplemental data in combination with CT. Overall, 38 patients (36.2%) with mediastinal cysts were symptomatic, including 39.2% with bronchogenic/esophageal cysts, 40% with thymic cysts, and 15.8% with pericardial/pleural cysts. One hundred patients had complete resection of their masses, 3 patients with pericardial diverticulum received a thoracoscopic fenestration without mortality, and 2 patients refused surgery.
Conclusion: Early recognition of these relatively rare lesions would lead to immediate and appropriate surgical intervention. Early surgical intervention is also important because definitive histologic diagnosis can only be established by means of surgical extirpation.
Key Words: bronchogenic cysts foregut cysts mediastinal cysts mesothelial cysts symptomatology, Japanese experience
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 testing was utilized for categorical values. | Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Regarding bronchogenic cysts, the classification of Maier7 was used to describe location. There were 12 right paratracheal, 4 left paratracheal, 11 right hilar, 5 left hilar, 7 subcarinal, 3 right paraesophageal, and 5 left paraesophageal bronchogenic cysts, as shown in Table 2 .
|
|
|
|
|
|
Specimens were available for pathologic examination in all patients, which revealed typical features of bronchogenic, esophageal, thymic, and thoracic duct cysts or meningoceles. Some patients with the entire cystic mass in the thymus, found to be cystic thymoma, were excluded from this study. There were no major morbidity or mortality in the surgical treatment of mediastinal cysts, and all patients had uneventful recovery.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Incidence and Embryogenesis
Foregut cysts, including bronchogenic and esophageal cysts, represented 48.6% (51 of 105 cysts) of all cysts in the mediastinum. Bronchogenic cysts were more common than esophageal cysts.10
11
The prevalence of bronchogenic cysts was reported to be 1:42,00 and 1:68,000 of admissions to two hospitals12
; however, it is difficult to appreciate the prevalence of the cysts exactly, since some aged patients have lesions that remain forever silent.12
Bronchogenic and esophageal cysts originate from the ventral primitive foregut as an anomalous budding of the laryngotracheal groove3 11 12 during embryonic development around the time when cleavage occurs between the respiratory tract and digestive tube.12 Both organs have columnar and ciliated mucosa at the time, and thereafter the squamous epithelium spreads in the esophagus. Gerle et al13 first proposed the term bronchopulmonary foregut malformation to encompass the entire spectrum of developmental anomalies of the primitive foregut. In a broad sense, congenital cystic lesions of the lung and mediastinum may result from compromised interaction between embryologic mesodermal and ectodermal lung components during development. Bronchopulmonary foregut malformations encompassed pulmonary sequestration, congenital cystic adenomatoid malformation, congenital lobar emphysema, and bronchogenic pulmonary cyst.14 During the same period of our 105 mediastinal cysts, we also observed 26 cases of congenital cystic disease of the lung including 13 bronchogenic pulmonary cysts, which were previously reported.5 The stage of embryonic development and error may determine the bronchial vs pulmonary parenchymal location of bronchogenic cysts.5 12 15 When they form early, they are located in the mediastinum by the trachea or esophagus, having ciliated epithelium derived from either the respiratory tract or alimentary tract. In contrast, when the later anomaly develops, they are located in the lung parenchyma and with lined respiratory epithelium.5 12 15 In this sense, bronchogenic cysts and esophageal cysts (duplications) share a similar developmental background, namely foregut budding errors, rather than being separate disease entities.16 17 A distinction is made between bronchogenic and esophageal cysts when cartilage is present, which suggests the cyst is bronchogenic in origin. However, Nobuhara et al11 advocated naming both types as "foregut cysts" because of their common embryological origin, anatomic proximity and histologic similarities.
Mesothelial cysts, including pericardial and pleural cysts, are estimated to occur in approximately 1 in 100,000 persons.17 Ochsner and Ochsner4 reported 33% mesothelial cysts among 42 cysts in the mediastinum. These cysts accounted for 18.1% in our series. These anomalies are formed by the parietal recess persisting during development, namely aberrant recess fusion; therefore, the pericardial diverticulum, having a communication with the pericardial cavity, is regarded as an incomplete form of pericardial cyst in terms of its embryogenesis.
Thymic cysts used to be regarded as a rare anomaly1 18 ; however, reports19 described a higher incidence of thymic cysts. In the current series, thymic cysts represented the second most common type: 28.6% of the mediastinal cysts and 3.7% of the mediastinal tumors. Thymic cysts may occur at any anatomic level, from the base of the neck to the diaphragm.19 There has been some controversy as to the causes of thymic cysts.18 19 20 Bieger and McAdams18 reported that thymic cysts derived from the thyropharengeal duct, that is, they are congenital in origin. Graeber et al20 divided cystic lesions of the thymus into three major categories: congenital, neoplastic, and degenerative. The latter two mechanisms in pathogenesis were cystic degeneration of thymomas and cystic masses after chemotherapy for Hodgkin disease.20 In any case, local disruption of thymic tissue can induce the formation or growth of cysts. In the current series, they mainly encompassed thymic cysts of congenital origin, and we excluded the cystic masses of neoplastic origin such as cystic thymomas or degeneration after surgery.20 Of note, Suster and Rosai19 reported 18 cases of multiocular thymic cysts, in addition to uniocular cysts.
We experienced two cases of meningocele in the posterior mediastinum.7 Although the etiology of intrathoracic meningocele is unknown, it is frequently associated with von Recklinghausen disease (neurofibromatosis type 1). Due to its rarity, intrathoracic meningocele is seldom considered in the differential diagnosis of a mediastinal cyst. A meningocele may be defined as a saccular protrusion of the spinal meninges through an intravertebral foramen.21 As reviewed by Erkulvrawatr et al,22 20% of the cases were associated with neurologic impairments such as weakness, sensory disorder, hyperactive reflexes, and occasional headache, probably due to low cerebrospinal fluid pressure. We also encountered an extremely rare case of a thoracic duct cyst in 1976; pathologically, the cyst was unilocular with an associated connection to the thoracic duct. As Tsuchiya et al23 later described another case, we made a preoperative diagnosis of thoracic duct cyst by lymphangiogram. They can have a distinct connection with the thoracic duct. Regarding pathogenesis, thoracic duct cysts occur secondary to a congenital weakness and degenerative wall changes, which result in aneurysm-like dilatation and subsequent cyst formation.24
Symptomatology and Diagnosis
The clinical characteristics in mediastinal cysts are outlined in Table 3
. Overall, 38 patients (36.2%) with mediastinal cysts were symptomatic. Symptomatic patients were seen in 39.2% with bronchogenic/esophageal cysts, 40% with thymic cysts, and 15.8% with pericardial/pleural cysts, respectively. Asymptomatic patients were most common in patients with mesothelial cysts compared to other type of cysts (p = 0.06).
In the current study, the prevalence of symptomatic patients with bronchogenic/esophageal foregut cysts was lower than that reported previously, ranging from 50 to 80%.6 11 12 In addition, symptoms of infection such as fevers in the current series were low (9.8%) in patients with bronchogenic or esophageal cysts in the mediastinum compared to previous reports.6 11 In our experience,5 10 of 13 patients (79%) with parenchymal bronchogenic cysts had symptoms of infection, including 1 patient with a tuberculosis infection in the cyst, and this incidence was consistent with previous reports.6 12 St-Georges and coworkers6 reported that 90% of parenchymal bronchogenic cysts had symptoms of infection compared to mediastinal bronchogenic cysts with 36.4%. In addition, two pediatric patients with parenchymal bronchogenic cysts had symptoms of respiratory distress associated with acute mediastinal shift due to a ballooning of the cyst, and emergency left lower lobectomy was performed.5 We only encountered the following acute symptoms in two patients with mediastinal bronchogenic cysts: one patient appeared with empyema due to cyst rupture, and the another patient referred to us with abrupt onset of hoarseness due to ballooning of a right paratracheal cyst (this hoarseness was reversible by surgery). According to Ribet and colleagues,12 bronchogenic cysts in the subcarinal or paratracheal locations were more apt to provoke compression symptoms. Children with narrow or soft airways are easily vulnerable to compression by expanding cysts; therefore, patients with bronchogenic cysts in the pediatric group were seen as life-threatening emergencies,14 but this was also seen in adult patients.3 St-Georges et al6 reviewed 86 bronchogenic cysts and found major complications such as fistulization with airway, and ulcerations or hemorrhage in mediastinal cysts that were observed with parenchymal cysts. In addition, other potential complications including arrhythmia or superior vena cava syndrome may occur. Another important issue is that malignancy is associated with bronchogenic cysts.25
As for esophageal cysts, by reviewing previous reports,10 11 approximately one half of the patients with esophageal cysts were asymptomatic and discovered incidentally. Three of four patients with this disease were asymptomatic at presentation in our experience. We encountered one patient with an esophageal duplication cyst who visited us complaining of fever and chest pain due to acute enlargement and rupturing into the mediastinum.9
Thymic cysts were regarded to be usually asymptomatic, located in the anterior mediastinum, and were incidentally discovered on a chest radiograph.18 Graeber et al20 reported that only 6 of 46 patients (13%) had symptoms. Unusual presentations such as respiratory distress19 and Horner syndrome26 have been reported. In our series, thymic cysts represented 28.6% of mediastinal cysts and 3.7% of total mediastinal tumors. As shown in Table 3 , 40% of patients were symptomatic, a similar prevalence to those with bronchogenic cysts in the current study. Such cases presented with relatively large masses of 7 to 13 cm in size. Notably, hoarseness was the second most common symptom in our series. However, patients with cystic masses in the thymus have been reported to be asymptomatic.19 20
In our experience, patients with pericardial/pleural cysts had lower incidences of symptoms than other mediastinal cysts; however, one patient with an expanding pleural cyst who presented with cyanosis and respiratory distress needed an emergency operation. The two patients with meningoceles appeared without respiratory symptoms. Recurrent chest pain was associated with the thoracic duct cyst similar to the previous report.24
As for the diagnostic modality, chest radiograph was once the most cost- and time-efficient method of diagnosing surgical lesions, and was the only diagnostic tool in our early series. Before the introduction of CT scan, pneumomediastinum used to be a diagnostic tool for mediastinal mass. Currently, mediastinal cysts can be accurately diagnosed with imaging modalities such as CT, MRI, and ultrasonography. The appropriate diagnostic test allows for efficient treatment, avoiding complications. The plain chest radiograph serves as the starting point for diagnostic evaluation, and MRI is an ultimately useful tool for providing supplemental data in combination with CT. In addition, asymptomatic cystic lesions were sometimes found during examination or follow-up for other diseases.
Surgery and Outcome
Short-term results after extirpation of mediastinal cysts are excellent, and operative morbidity is acceptable as well as eliminating symptoms. We concluded that the diagnosis of a symptomatic mediastinal cyst is an indication for complete extirpation in all patients. In this sense, surgical excision is definitely diagnostic and therapeutic; therefore, watchful waiting is discouraged. The options for treatment of foregut cysts or thymic cysts including mediastinoscopic aspiration in symptomatic patients have been reported,27
but these methods should be exceptionally preferred as temporary procedures in selected cases. There were some concerns about the indications of surgery for asymptomatic patients with mediastinal cysts after establishing the diagnosis due to their benign nature.25
Ribet and colleagues12
followed up two patients with bronchogenic cysts who refused surgery for 15 years and found that one patient remained free of symptoms and the other died of a malignancy of unknown origin. As for thymic and mesothelial cysts, watchful observation data were not available in our experience. An accurate imaging diagnosis may allow these lesions to leave alone. Many patients with mediastinal cysts were initially asymptomatic, later with occasional severe outcomes. In our series, 60% of patients were actually asymptomatic but they accepted an offer of surgery. We believe that preventive resection should be preferred, even in asymptomatic patients because of the unpredictability of clinical behavior. VATS may be an acceptable surgical procedure for patients with mediastinal cysts, which are rarely malignant.28
29
Ribet et al12
analyzed the operative records and found that the VATS approach was hazardous in 11 to 30% patients with bronchogenic cysts because of pericystic adhesions or communication of the cysts with tracheobronchial or esophageal structures. The need for conversions should not be delayed. These technical difficulties were less frequently encountered in other types of cysts.
In summary, we reviewed our experience with cysts of the mediastinum, emphasizing the clinical spectrum of the disease, diagnosis and treatment, and some case presentations with unusual clinical manifestations. Early recognition of these relatively rare lesions would lead to immediate and appropriate surgical intervention. Early surgical intervention is also important, because a definitive histologic diagnosis can only be established by means of surgical extirpation.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Dr. Takeda is presently at the Department of Thoracic Surgery Toneyama National Hospital, Toyonaka City, Osaka, Japan.
Dr. Miyoshi is presently at the Department of Thoracic Surgery, Dokkyo Medical College, Tochigi, Japan.
Dr. Masaoka is presently at Osaka Central Hospital, Osaka, Japan.
Presented in part at the Annual Meeting of American Thoracic Society, Atlanta, GA, May 1822, 2002.
Received for publication May 7, 2002. Accepted for publication December 19, 2002.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
G. Galluccio and G. Lucantoni Mediastinal bronchogenic cyst's recurrence treated with EBUS-FNA with a long-term follow-up. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., April 1, 2006; 29(4): 627 - 629. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Hattori High Prevalence of Estrogen and Progesterone Receptor Expression in Mediastinal Cysts Situated in the Posterior Mediastinum Chest, November 1, 2005; 128(5): 3388 - 3390. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. V. Duwe, D. H. Sterman, and A. I. Musani Tumors of the Mediastinum Chest, October 1, 2005; 128(4): 2893 - 2909. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. A. Savitt, G. Gao, A. P. Furnary, J. Swanson, H. L. Gately, and J. R. Handy Application of Robotic-Assisted Techniques to the Surgical Evaluation and Treatment of the Anterior Mediastinum Ann. Thorac. Surg., February 1, 2005; 79(2): 450 - 455. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |