|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||

* From the Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine (Drs. Cohen, Marzouk, and Scharf), The Long Island Jewish Medical Center, The Long Island Campus for The Albert Einstein College of Medicine, New Hyde Park, NY; and Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine (Drs. ODonnell and Polotsky), Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD.
Currently at the Pulmonary and Critical Care Division, University of Maryland, Baltimore, MD.
Correspondence to: Rubin Cohen, MD, FCCP, Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Long Island Jewish Medical Center, RM C-20, 270-05 76th Ave, New Hyde Park, NY, 11040; e-mail: rcohen{at}lij.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Patients: Seventy-nine patients with severe emphysema (FEV1, 29 ± 13% of predicted [mean ± SD]) evaluated for enrollment in the National Emphysema Treatment Trial and 20 age-matched healthy subjects were studied.
Setting: Pulmonary function laboratory of university-affiliated teaching hospital.
Interventions: Data collection.
Measurements and results: We measured lung function, body composition, serum leptin levels, serum tumor necrosis factor receptors (sTNF-Rs), resting oxygen consumption (R
O2) normalized to weight in kilograms (R
O2/kg), and R
O2 normalized to fat-free mass (FFM) [R
O2/FFM]. The patient group and healthy group had similar age, body mass index (BMI), and body composition. R
O2/kg, R
O2/FFM, and sTNF-R levels were higher in patients compared to healthy subjects. There were no differences in serum leptin levels between emphysematous and healthy subjects, and there was no correlation between leptin and sTNF-R and R
O2/kg. Furthermore, both groups had similar gender-related differences in FFM, percentage of body fat, and serum leptin levels. Patients with lower BMI showed the greatest differences from control subjects in R
O2/kg.
Conclusion: In weight-stable subjects with advanced emphysema, R
O2/kg and R
O2/FFM were higher compared to healthy subjects, especially in those with BMI in the lower end of the normal range. R
O2/kg and R
O2/FFM did not correlate with leptin or sTNF-R levels. These data show that a higher metabolic rate is found in patients with emphysema who are clinically and weight stable. Thus, hypermetabolism is a feature of the disease and not sufficient to lead to weight loss.
Key Words: body mass index emphysema leptin nutrition oxygen consumption tumor necrosis factor receptors
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Prior studies11 12 have also assessed body composition in patients with stable COPD; however, these studies examined all patients with a diagnosis of COPD, and often did not separate patients with clinical/radiologic evidence of emphysema as opposed to chronic bronchitis. Indeed, there are few data on the metabolic status of weight-stable patients with advanced emphysema. Thus, it remains unclear if changes in body composition, hypermetabolism, and inflammation are present only in weight-losing patients, or whether these characteristics are also found in weight-stable patients with emphysema.
We undertook this study to characterize the relationships between lung function, body composition, REE, serum leptin concentrations, and markers of inflammation in a group of weight-stable patients with clinically advanced emphysema. We hypothesized that the metabolic derangements noted in the weight-losing population would also be found in a group of weight-stable patients. We further hypothesized that increased REE would correlate with markers of systemic inflammation and serum leptin level.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Among these patients, 26 were eventually randomized into the NETT. Reasons for not randomizing patients included the following: PFT results not reaching NETT criteria, BMI too high for participation in the NETT, presence of pulmonary hypertension, homogeneously distributed emphysema judged unresectable for lung reduction, inability to complete exercise testing, exclusion by surgeon, and unwillingness by participant to undergo randomization or further participation in trial.
Twenty volunteers (10 men and 10 women) of ages similar to those of the patients comprised the healthy group. Healthy volunteers were excluded if they had history of smoking, concomitant lung disease, or other serious medical illness. This group underwent measurements of REE, body composition, and leptin and sTNF-R levels.
Weight was measured with a beam scale to the nearest 0.25 kg with the subjects barefoot and lightly clothed. Height was determined to nearest 0.5 cm, and the BMI was calculated. PFTs including spirometry, lung volumes by plethysmography, and single-breath diffusing capacity of the lung for carbon monoxide (DLCO) were performed, and results were expressed as percentage of predicted according to the equations of Crapo et al.14 Blood for measurement of arterial gas tensions and pH was obtained at rest with the subject breathing room air.
Fat-free mass (FFM) was calculated using a specific regression equation,15
16
and was expressed both in kilograms and as percentage of total body weight. Body composition was assessed by bioelectrical impedance (BIA 101 Impedance Analyzer; RJL Systems; Detroit, MI).15
16
REE was assessed as resting oxygen consumption (R
O2) in milliliters per minute, and was measured between 9 AM and 11 AM after an overnight fast under standardized conditions using indirect calorimetry (Medgraphics Cardio 2 System, Pitot tube; Medical Graphics; St. Paul, MN). R
O2 normalized to total body weight in kilograms (R
O2/kg) and R
O2 normalized to FFM (R
O2/FFM) were also measured. For measurements of R
O2, subjects were placed at rest in a 45° semirecumbent position for 5 min breathing through a mouthpiece. Following this run-in period, breath-by-breath measurements of oxygen consumption (
O2) and carbon dioxide production were made for 5 more minutes. Values of R
O2 were averaged over the entire 5-min measurement period.
We measured levels of sTNF-Rs 55 and 75 in duplicate samples, using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kit (Quantakine; R&D Systems; Minneapolis, MN). These are proteins shed into the circulation and interfere with the binding of tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-
to its cell-surface receptors.17
The increased sTNF-Rs in patients with emphysema are thought to reflect TNF-
activation and ongoing inflammation.9
17
Serum leptin concentration18
19
was assessed in duplicates with a radioimmunoassay as described by the manufacturer (Linco Research; St. Louis, MO). The Institutional Review Board of the Long Island Jewish Medical Center approved this study.
Statistical Analysis
Data were collated and expressed as mean ± SD. We used the Sigma Stat 2.03 statistical software (SPSS; Chicago, IL) to analyze data. Data were tested for normality using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (with the Lilliefor correction) using p = 0.5 threshold for rejection of normality. Since data in both groups were normally distributed, we compared the healthy group to the patient group using a two-sample t test. For the t test, equality of variance was tested by checking variability about the group means (p = 0.05 for rejection). Univariate regression analysis was performed as indicated. Multiple backward stepwise regression analyses were performed for any given independent variable using variables that were significant predictors on the univariate analysis. The least-square technique was used to obtain the line that best fit the data. Within-group analyses were also examined for gender-related differences in leptin, BMI, percentage of fat mass (FM) [calculated as FM divided by body mass x 100], and other characteristics.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
O2, R
O2/kg, and R
O2/FFM, which were significantly greater in patients than in healthy subjects.
|
O2
O2 and BMI. In the control subjects, there was a significant positive correlation (r = 0.8, p < 0.001). This was not the case in the patient group, even though mean BMI was the same for the two groups. We further explored the relationships between
O2 normalized to weight in kilograms (
O2/kg) and BMI in patients and healthy subjects (Fig 2
). In healthy subjects,
O2/kg did not change significantly with BMI. However,
O2/kg decreased significantly with increasing BMI in patients (r = 0.5, p < 0.001).
|
|
O2/kg using a backward stepwise regression model (Table 2
). We found that the strongest correlate of R
O2/kg in patients was BMI. Moreover, in this group of weight-stable patients, there was no correlation between BMI and indexes of airflow obstruction such as FEV1 and functional residual capacity (FRC). Indeed, we found no correlation between either FEV1, FRC, or total lung capacity (TLC), and R
O2/kg, R
O2/FFM, or BMI. However, DLCO was found to be a predictor of BMI. We then classified patients into quartiles based on BMI (Table 2)
. The highest quartile of BMI was > 27.7, and the lowest quartile of BMI was < 22. There were no differences between the lowest quartile and highest quartile of BMI with respect to lung function indexes (FEV1, FRC, TLC).
|
O2 adjusted to only body weight may not reflect body composition, we also investigated the relationship between R
O2 and FFM for both groups (Table 2 , Fig 3
). R
O2 increased in both groups as FFM increased (r = 0.6 and r = 0.7 for patients and healthy subjects, respectively; p < 0.001 for both), but R
O2 was greater for any level of FFM in patients compared to healthy subjects (Fig 3
, top, a). We then compared R
O2 adjusted to body composition (R
O2/FFM) between the emphysema and healthy groups (Fig 3
, bottom) and found that the same relationship held as for R
O2/kg. That is,
O2 normalized to FFM was greater in patients than normal subjects. However, as FFM increased, there was a decrease in
O2 normalized to FFM in the emphysema group (p < 0.001, r = 0.5). This relationship did not hold for the normal group. Although the slope of the regression line was also positive in normal subjects, it was not significantly different from zero.
|
O2, BMI, or steroid usage. Even when patients in the lowest quartile of BMI were compared to those in the highest quartile, no significant difference was found in the sTNF-R levels.
Leptin Levels
There were no differences in serum leptin between the two groups. Moreover, the increased R
O2 in the emphysema group was not associated with serum leptin (p = 0.9, r = 0.01). There was no correlation between sTNF-R and leptin (p = 0.5, r = 0.1 for sTNF-R 55; p = 0.7, r = 0.07 for sTNF-R 75). Additionally, we found no correlation between leptin and steroid usage (p = 0.3, r = 0.1). Using multiple backward stepwise regression, gender, FRC, PCO2, and BMI were independent correlates of leptin (Table 2)
.
Gender Differences
Gender is known to play a role in determining body composition; for example, women have higher leptin concentrations than men for any given degree of FM, and changes in anabolic and sex hormones have been documented in men with COPD and could impact on body composition.18
19
We also examined whether known gender-related differences were present in emphysema patients as well. As in normal subjects, we found that leptin levels were higher in women than men, FFM was greater in men, and percentage of body fat was higher in women (Table 3
). There were no differences between the patient and the healthy groups with respect to the magnitude of gender-related differences. Thus, the occurrence of severe emphysema did not affect gender-related differences in body composition.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
O2/kg, R
O2/FFM, and sTNF-R levels were higher in patients compared to healthy subjects. However, there were no differences in serum leptin between the two groups. Multivariate backward stepwise regression analysis revealed that BMI was the strongest predictor of R
O2/kg in patients. Ravussin and Bogardus20
argued that normalizing R
O2 to weight might be misleading, as it does not consider body composition. These authors argued that a somewhat better relationship could be obtained when R
O2 is related to FFM. We also compared R
O2/FFM between the two groups and found that the same relationship held as for R
O2/kg (Fig 3)
.
In a study of patients with stable COPD, Creutzberg et al12
showed that FFM depletion was present in one third of the COPD population studied. These authors also found that REE was higher in the COPD group compared to healthy control group after analysis of variance with covariates sex, age, FFM, and FM, prompting these authors to conclude that other factors influence REE in patients with COPD. The increased REE in that study12
was characterized by less hyperinflation as assessed by TLC, thus raising the possibility that hypermetabolism may be different for the COPD subtypes of emphysema and chronic bronchitis. However, Creutzberg et al12
did not distinguish between these two groups. Unlike Creutzberg et al,12
we found no correlation between R
O2 (as an index of REE) and TLC. In our study, we examined only patients with emphysema and did not find evidence of FFM depletion in our group of nonweight-losing patients with emphysema. This may be due to the rigid selection criteria and definition of emphysema in our study.
In another study of nonmalnourished, clinically stable patients with COPD, Nguyen et al11
concluded that increased REE was related to plasma TNF concentration. While we found that sTNF-Rs were elevated in our emphysema group, we did not find a correlation between these markers of inflammation and the increased R
O2. Such differences may also be due to rigid selection criteria of only emphysema patients who were both weight and clinically stable. Alternatively, the degree to which sTNF-Rs reflect TNF levels could the result of the interaction between receptor shedding and renal excretion, and may not be a simple reflection of the degree of inflammation.
Our results would indicate that increased R
O2 in patients with emphysema could play a role in weight regulation in thinner patients, as heavier patients did not have increased energy expenditure. This finding is in agreement with those of prior studies1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
in which weight-losing patients have increased REE, but our study extends this finding even to emphysema patients who have maintained their weight. In our patient group, as BMI increased, R
O2 remained the same; however, R
O2/kg decreased. The reasons are not clear, and this relationship does not necessarily imply cause and effect. However, this finding indicates that R
O2 is subject to other influences besides body mass in patients. Such factors may include both increased work of breathing and metabolic effects of airway inflammation that act to make R
O2 relatively insensitive to body mass. Interestingly, in our group of weight-stable patients, BMI did not correlate with measurement of airway obstruction such as FEV1 percentage of predicted and FVC percentage of predicted. However, our data indicate that BMI correlated with DLCO (Table 3) , and prior studies8
have shown that the association of malnutrition is more closely related to the presence of anatomic emphysema as judged by DLCO.
After adjustment for FM and oral corticosteroid use as possible confounders, Schols et al21 concluded that in a population of patients with emphysema, leptin was positively correlated to plasma sTNF-R 55, indicating a link between the systemic inflammatory response in emphysema and leptin. Creutzberg et al18 found that plasma leptin levels, adjusted for percentage of FM, were elevated initially in a group of hospitalized patients with COPD; however, the leptin levels decreased after 1 week, but remained higher when compared to a healthy, age-matched population. The authors attributed this to the higher steroid usage in the patient population during hospitalization. These authors also found a correlation between sTNF-R 55 and leptin, and concluded that temporary disturbances in the energy balance in patients with COPD are related to leptin and inflammation. Thus, according to these previous studies, a relationship between leptin and sTNF-R could indicate that a proinflammatory state in emphysema at least partially determines leptin levels.18 19 21 In our study, the use of steroids (> 5 mg/d of prednisone) did not relate to any body composition parameter; neither was there a relationship between steroid usage and leptin or sTNF-Rs. Similarly, another study22 did not find a relationship between steroid usage and leptin in a population of patients with lupus. Differences between our conclusions and those of prior studies may be due to the fact that our patients were clinically stable and not losing weight. Furthermore, the BMI in the study by Schols et al21 (21.6 ± 3.0) was less than the BMI in our patient population (25.7 ± 4.7). Hence, the study by Schols et al21 may have been dealing with patients actively losing weight, making comparisons difficult.
The chief function of leptin is to maintain body fat by signaling the brain that calorie intake and the amounts of energy stored as fat are sufficient. Thus, when FM is reduced, leptin serum concentrations are reduced, evoking compensatory changes in food intake that favor the return to the previous body weight. Accordingly, leptin is postulated to play a role in the remarkable recovery of weight lost after dieting.23 24 Our data in emphysematous patients are consistent with this, in that BMI and FM were the most important determinants of leptin. Unlike our study, Takabatake et al25 found that serum leptin was lower in the COPD group as compared to the healthy group. However, in that study25 the COPD group had significantly lower BMI and percentage of FM than the healthy group. Since our study demonstrates the effect of BMI on leptin, the lower leptin concentrations in the study by Takabatake et al25 appear to be an appropriate reaction to fat loss, rather than a response to emphysema per se.
Persistent airway inflammation has been long recognized in patients with COPD, and is postulated to alter the balance between mechanisms of lung repair and destruction in favor of the latter.26
Several studies have demonstrated increased markers of proinflammatory cytokines in sera of COPD patients, particularly those suffering from weight loss; it is postulated that such augmented systemic inflammation is yet another contributing factor to the hypermetabolism in weight-losing emphysema patients.9
10
21
26
Our findings would suggest that even in patients who are both clinically and weight stable, there is active and ongoing systemic inflammation. The present study does not allow us to determine the relative contributions of increased work of breathing or persistent systemic inflammation in leading to increased R
O2. However, the present study does suggest that systemic inflammation could work synergistically with lung mechanics to increase R
O2.
We conclude that in patients with weight-stable emphysema, R
O2 is increased when compared to normal control subjects. This is especially true in patients with BMI in the lower end of the studied range. Additionally, emphysema patients as a group have increased levels of sTNF-Rs, which may indicate ongoing inflammation. Leptin correlated with BMI and gender in both emphysematous and healthy subjects, but was different between the groups. Although systemic inflammation and elevated R
O2 are features of weight-stable emphysema patients, it is possible that any imbalance between R
O2 (driven by inflammation and work of breathing) and energy supply (dietary intake), could become great enough to lead to weight loss in this susceptible group.
| Footnotes |
|---|
O2 = resting oxygen consumption; R
O2/FFM = resting oxygen consumption normalized to fat-free mass; R
O2/kg = resting oxygen consumption normalized to weight in kilograms; sTNF-R = soluble tumor necrosis factor receptor; TLC = total lung capacity; TNF = tumor necrosis factor;
O2 = oxygen consumption;
O2/kg = oxygen consumption normalized to weight in kilograms This study was presented in abstract forms at the American Thoracic Society International Conference Toronto 2000 (May 510, 2000) and San Francisco 2001 (May 1823, 2001).
Supported by the Weisman Pulmonary Research Fund.
Received for publication October 3, 2002. Accepted for publication May 21, 2003.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
levels and weight loss in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1994;150,1453-1455[Abstract]
concentration in stable COPD patients. Clin Nutr 1999;18,269-274[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |