|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From IDF Medical Corps (Drs. Adir, Shupak, Gil, Peled, Keynan, and Domachevsky), Israel Naval Medical Institute; and the Division of Respiratory Physiology and Chest Disease (Dr. Weiler-Ravell), Carmel Medical Center, Haifa, Israel.
Correspondence to: Yochai Adir, MD, Israel Naval Medical Institute, PO Box 8040, 31 080 Haifa, Israel; e-mail: adir-sh{at}zahav.net.il
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: SIPE was diagnosed when severe shortness of breath and cough were reported during or after swimming, and were associated with evidence of pulmonary edema. During the years from 1998 to 2001, 70 cases of SIPE were documented in young healthy male subjects participating in a fitness-training program. Physical examination and pulse oximetry were performed immediately. Chest radiographs were obtained in all cases 12 to 18 h following onset of symptoms. In 37 swimmers, spirometry was performed at the time of chest radiography and again after 7 days.
Results: All subjects complained of severe shortness of breath. Sixty-seven of the 70 subjects (95.7%) had a prominent cough; in 63 subjects (90%), there was significant sputum production. Hemoptysis was observed in 39 subjects (55.7%). Mean arterial oxygen saturation after swimming was 88.4 ± 6.6% breathing air, compared with 98 ± 1.7% breathing air at rest before the start of the swimming trial (mean ± SD) [p < 0.001]. Chest radiographs obtained 12 to 18 h after swimming were normal in all cases. Sixteen trainees (22.9%) had a recurrence of SIPE. Spirometry demonstrated restrictive lung function, which persisted for a week.
Conclusions: In our trainee population, SIPE is a not uncommon, often recurrent phenomenon that significantly influences performance. It is not clear what predisposes to its occurrence or recurrence and what, if any, are its long-term effects.
Key Words: diving exercise pulmonary edema swimming
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The prevalence of exercise-induced pulmonary edema in humans is unknown and is probably underreported. Hopkins et al11 demonstrated in elite human athletes that brief intense exercise results in alteration of the BGB, with increased RBC and protein concentrations in BAL fluid.
There are a number of reports1213141516 describing the occurrence of acute pulmonary edema and hemoptysis in swimmers and divers. We previously reported a series of eight swimmers with pulmonary edema and hemoptysis during a single swimming time trial.12 In that particular event, overhydration was thought to be an important contributing factor. However, recurrent episodes in two of the swimmers and other new cases associated with strenuous swimming occurred without antecedent fluid loading. During the years from 1998 to 2001, we diagnosed a further 70 cases of swimming-induced pulmonary edema (SIPE) in young, healthy male subjects participating in a fitness-training program. We now report on the clinical presentation, incidence of recurrence, findings on physical examination, chest radiography, and oxygen saturation in those cases. We also report the results of serial lung function (forced spirometry) in a subgroup of 37 of the 70 subjects.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
SIPE was diagnosed when (1) severe shortness of breath and coughing were reported during or after swimming in the absence of seawater aspiration, and (2) evidence of pulmonary edema was found on physical examination (bilateral inspiratory crackles that did not clear with deep inspiration). Immediately on diagnosis, a complete physical examination was conducted with special emphasis on the respiratory system, and arterial oxygen saturation was measured again. A chest radiograph was obtained 12 to 18 h after the onset of symptoms. A comprehensive interview of each subject by the examining physician included a direct question as to whether there was subjective evidence of seawater aspiration.
In a subgroup of 37 trainees, spirometry (ST-250; Fukuda Sangyo; Chiba, Japan) was performed 12 to 18 h after SIPE was diagnosed, and again 7 days later. Before testing, the spirometer was calibrated according to the recommendations of the American Thoracic Society.17 FVC and FEV1 were measured, and the FEV1/FVC ratio was calculated. The best result of at least three tests was recorded. Forced spirometry data obtained for all subjects in a similar fashion 12 months previously, at the time of selection for the program, were available for comparison. Arterial oxygen saturation was measured at rest before the swim and immediately after diagnosis. Comparison among groups was done by analysis of variance using SAS 6.03 (SAS Institute; Cary, NC).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In contrast with the findings in animal studies, such events are very rarely reported in athletes during or after intense exercise. Previous reports1920 described acute pulmonary edema or recurrent hemoptysis in a rugby player and two marathon runners following extreme physical exertion. Another study11 has shown increased concentrations of RBCs and protein in BAL fluid obtained 1 h after a simulated cycling race, suggesting that intense exercise reduces alveolar barrier function. No activation of proinflammatory pathways was found in the airspaces, supporting the hypothesis that capillary stress failure is responsible for these changes. In a follow-up study from this same group, it was demonstrated that short-term maximal physiologic stress is needed to alter the integrity of the BGB, because sustained submaximal exercise did not result in stress failure of the pulmonary capillaries.21
Caillaud et al22 demonstrated exercise-induced hypoxemia, widening of the alveolar-arterial oxygen pressure difference, and reduced diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide in highly trained athletes after a triathlon. Increases in lung density and in the number of opacities, suggesting an increase in pulmonary extravascular fluid, were diagnosed by CT of the chest in these athletes.
The relatively frequent occurrence of swimming-induced or immersion-related pulmonary congestion in healthy individuals, in comparison with the apparent rarity of the phenomenon following nonimmersion exercise, is intriguing. There are several important physiologic effects of immersion, which might explain this difference. Immersion increases cardiac preload and pulmonary arterial pressure due to central blood pooling. It has been shown that during immersion in 33 to 35°C water, central blood volume increases by approximately 700 mL and pulmonary arterial transmural pressure by 13 to 21 mm Hg.2324 Furthermore, immersion in moderately cold water (17 to 18°C) is associated with a decrease in body core temperature resulting in redistribution of blood from peripheral to thoracic vessels. Hypothermia-induced arterial and venous constriction leads to an increase in both cardiac preload and afterload.252627 Previous reports1328293031 have noted pulmonary edema in cold water divers. The subjects examined in these studies had abnormal cold pressor tests, a finding which was not corroborated by other investigators. In our subjects, the average water temperature was 19.6 ± 3.2°C, which can cause peripheral vasoconstriction, a rise in central blood volume, and increased cardiac preload and afterload.
A reduction in functional residual capacity due to blood displacement into the lungs, combined with an immersion-induced increment in the closing volume, results in ventilation-perfusion inequality, hypoxemia, and pulmonary vasoconstriction.32 Under these conditions, because pulmonary vasoconstriction is not uniform throughout the vascular bed, those capillaries not protected by arterial constriction are exposed to the high pulmonary pressures that develop during strenuous swimming. This, according to the model of West and Mathieu-Costello,33 facilitates pulmonary capillary stress failure.
Apart from the circumferential tension caused by the capillary transmural pressure, other forces also act on the BGB, such as the longitudinal tension in the alveolar wall elements associated with lung inflation. Immersion increases the pulmonary closing volume and reduces lung compliance, thus leading to air trapping.3435
During head-out immersion, negative pressure respiration due to the hydrostatic pressure differences between the upper and lower airways produces transmural pulmonary hydrostatic forces that favor a fluid shift from the pulmonary vasculature to the alveoli.36 The more the chest sinks under water and the steeper its vertical tilt, the greater the effect. High lung volumes and peak airway pressures, both present during extreme effort, were found to cause an increase in capillary permeability and the development of microvascular injury.3738 This effect is definitely present when swimming in the semi-reclining or half-sitting position, as practiced by the study participants. Excessive negative intrathoracic pressure generated by arduous exertion, causing increased tension on the alveolar walls, is another contributing factor to mechanical failure of the BGB.
We postulate that in our subjects, who were engaged in strenuous swimming, all of these physiologic changes combined to produce damage to the alveolar-capillary membrane, resulting in clinically significant pulmonary edema. Cough with prominent sputum production was noted in most of our subjects, and hemoptysis was present in approximately half of them. These clinical manifestations, in parallel with a significant reduction in oxygen saturation and physical findings on lung auscultation, support the diagnosis of pulmonary edema. Clinical recovery was rapid, with an excellent response to diuretics and oxygen. The chest radiograph reverted to normal as soon as 12 h after the incident.
The clinical manifestations we describe may be found in seawater aspiration, apart from hemoptysis, which is usually seen in fresh water drowning. The presence of hemoptysis supports our preference for stress failure of the pulmonary capillaries as the etiology of the syndrome we describe. Furthermore, we found no reference in the English-language literature to clinically significant aspiration of seawater in professional swimmers in a nondrowning situation. The possibility of our swimmers inadvertently aspirating seawater, an event which induces immediate and violent coughing, without being aware of this, is highly unlikely, whereas the respiratory distress they experienced, cough, shortness of breath, and effort intolerance, developed gradually during the swim.
The rapid clinical improvement with resolution of the pulmonary edema is consistent with experimental animal studies,8 which demonstrate that the disruptions of the BGB are rapidly reversible with reduction of the capillary pressures. These findings are borne out by human case studies.3940 A recent study41 in elite athletes investigated the effect of maximal exercise on the integrity of the alveolar epithelial membrane, using the clearance rate of aerosolized 99mTc diethylenetriamine penta-acetic acid as an index for the permeability of the lung BGB. The authors demonstrated an acute increase in pulmonary clearance after maximal exercise, which returned to resting levels within 2 h.
The fact that SIPE is not seen or has not been reported in Olympic or other competitive swimmers requires an explanation. It is possible to discern a number of differences between competitive swimming and the exercise performed by our trainees. Swimming with fins exercises the legs only, compared with other competitive swimming styles, in which cardiac output supports both arm and leg movement. Venous return must be greatly augmented by finning compared with other swimming styles, and by the effects of immersion in the supine, semi-reclining position, as described in detail above. The temperature of the water in which these trainees swam was also significantly lower than the thermoregulated conditions in competitive swimming, inducing vasoconstriction and an increase in pulmonary vascular pressures. This combination of swimming style and a distinctive posture in cold water to produce an increase in venous return and pulmonary artery pressure could provide a partial explanation for the frequency with which we observed SIPE.
As noted above, the high incidence of hemoptysis in our trainees, which is not a characteristic clinical sign of seawater aspiration, supports our notion that mechanical failure of the BGB was the main contributing factor to the occurrence of pulmonary edema. Moreover, a recent report39 described unilateral right-sided pulmonary edema in three combat divers who swam right-side down. The increase in pulmonary capillary pressures due both to increased regional pulmonary blood flow with high exertion, exacerbated by the gravitational effect, and the hydrostatic pressure differences between the upper airways and the submerged right lung, led to capillary stress failure and unilateral pulmonary edema.
High-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) is another form of noncardiogenic pulmonary edema, which shares a certain similarity with SIPE. In both cases, there is increased pulmonary artery pressure and increased permeability of the BGB.1642 As is the case with SIPE, severe HAPE is infrequent. People with higher pulmonary artery pressure, smaller lungs, and higher pulmonary artery wedge pressure during exercise at sea level are prone to acquire HAPE.42 Unfortunately, we were unable to elicit any physical findings or behavioral characteristics that might help us predict which of our trainees are at risk of acquiring SIPE.
Lung function tests during immersion reveal a reduction in vital capacity, functional residual capacity and lung compliance, and an increase in the closing volume. Studies43 on the effects of acute pulmonary edema on lung function tests describe restrictive and obstructive dysfunction, with a decrease in FVC and FEV1, and a low FEV1 to FVC ratio.
In our subgroup of 37 trainees, who performed pulmonary function tests, significant restrictive changes were found 6 to 12 h after the acute event, with a persistent reduction in FEV1 and a normal FEV1/FVC ratio 1 week later. These restrictive changes support the clinical diagnosis of pulmonary edema. Their persistence for at least a week, despite complete clinical recovery and normal chest radiographic findings within 24 h, suggests that notwithstanding the experimental data indicating rapid repair of the breaks in the BGB, there is still some degree of pulmonary congestion and perhaps also a loss of capillary integrity. In 20 subjects, no cardiac abnormality was found on echocardiography, supporting the concept that the pulmonary edema results from capillary stress failure and is not cardiogenic in origin.
In summary, shortness of breath, coughing, and hemoptysis during strenuous swimming are related to hypoxemia and pulmonary edema, most probably due to mechanical failure of the BGB as a result of high transmural capillary pressure. We speculate that the physiologic effects of immersion, swimming in the semi-supine position with the head and shoulders above water, thus increasing the pressure difference between the lower extremities and the thorax, and the relatively cold water temperature, all serve to increase the risk of exercise-induced pulmonary edema. In our trainee population, SIPE is a not uncommon, often recurrent phenomenon that significantly influences performance. It is not clear what predisposes to its occurrence or recurrence and what, if any, are its long-term effects.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received for publication July 15, 2003. Accepted for publication February 5, 2004.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. Wenger and E. W. Russi Aqua jogging-induced pulmonary oedema Eur. Respir. J., December 1, 2007; 30(6): 1231 - 1232. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |