|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Departments of Community Health Sciences (Ms. Dik, and Drs. Tate and Manfreda) and Internal Medicine (Dr. Anthonisen), University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, Canada.
Correspondence to: Nicholas Anthonisen, MD, University of Manitoba, Department of Medicine, 810 Sherbrook St, Winnipeg, MB, Canada R3A 1R8; e-mail: nanthonisen{at}exchange.hsc.mb.ca
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: We identified all children born between 1980 and 1990 in the Province of Manitoba, Canada. We used records of physician contacts (inpatient and outpatient) and services of the universal provincial health insurance plan to follow up 170,960 children from birth to the age of 6 years to identify the first diagnosis of asthma. Information on mothers and siblings was also obtained to determine family history of disease and exposure to infections.
Results: During the study period, a diagnosis of asthma was made in 14.1% of children by the age of 6 years. The incidence was higher in boys than in girls, in those with family history of allergic diseases. It was higher in urban than in rural areas, and lowest in those born in winter. Asthma was more likely in those with low birth weight and premature birth. Certain congenital abnormalities and complications of pregnancy and labor also increased the risk of asthma. The risk of asthma increased with maternal age. Both upper and lower respiratory infections increased the risk of subsequent asthma, and this effect was more important than exposure to familial respiratory infections, which also tended to increase asthma risk. The risk of asthma decreased with the number of siblings when siblings had a history of allergic disorders.
Conclusions: In addition to genetic influences, intrauterine and labor conditions are determinants of asthma. Exposure to both upper and lower respiratory tract infections increases the risk; these infections do not explain the protective effect associated with the increasing number of siblings.
Key Words: asthma risk intrauterine labor complications maternal age siblings effect upper and lower respiratory tract infections
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Population
We used the MPHRR to identify study subjects and to track their use of health-care services during the first 6 years of life. We selected all children born in Manitoba between January 1, 1980, and December 31, 1990, who were residents from their birth date and had a hospital delivery record (n = 185,988). Children who were institutionalized or had < 1 year of insurance coverage (n = 8,973), as well as children with missing information (mothers record, birth weight, gestational age, area of residence) were excluded (n = 6,055). After exclusions, there were 170,960 children available for the analysis. The size of annual cohorts was similar, increasing from 14,483 in 1980 to 16,303 in 1990.
Outcome
The onset of asthma was defined as follows: (1) the first claim submitted by a physician with a diagnosis of asthma (ICD 493), (2) the second claim (defining asthmatics as those having at least two physician claims), and (3) the first hospital discharge with asthma as the primary diagnosis. Because there were only minor differences in results, we used the first definition in this article.
Risk Factors
The MPHRR provided for each child the birth date, gender, and the postal code of the parental residence. Residences were classified as urban (metropolitan Winnipeg, approximately 650,000 or 54% of the total provincial population) or rural (outside Winnipeg, the largest town having 30,000 people). The Winnipeg postal codes were matched with contemporary Canadian census data to obtain the mean household income in that area, an indicator of socioeconomic status. Postal code areas were ranked and divided into quintiles.
For each child, we determined the primary caregiver on the basis of physician office visits made Monday through Friday during the first year of life. The primary caregiver was classified as a general or family medicine practitioner; or pediatrician, if there were more visits to a pediatrician than to a general practitioner; or mixed, if there were more than two visits to both general practitioners and pediatricians. Few children (3,745 or 2.2%) did not visit a physicians office Monday through Friday in the first year of life.
Children were classified into five groups according to gestational age and four groups according to birth weight, forming approximate quintiles, or quartiles. For each child, we identified selected congenital anomalies (ICD 277, 740759) and perinatal conditions (ICD 769770). In addition, we identified all physician visits (including the date) for asthma, acute bronchitis and bronchiolitis (ICD 466), bronchitis not otherwise specified (ICD 490), upper respiratory tract infection (URI) [ICD 460465] and lower respiratory tract infection (LRI) [ICD 480487], and selected allergic and related conditions: nasal polyps (ICD 471), allergic rhinitis (ICD 477), atopic dermatitis (ICD 691), contact dermatitis and other eczema (ICD 692), dermatitis due to substances taken internally (ICD 693), and urticaria (ICD 708). Visits for noninfectious gastroenteritis and colitis (ICD 558) were also identified.
Using the population registry of the MPHRR, we identified each childs mother, her age at birth of the child, and siblings with their ages. For the mother and siblings, we abstracted the dates of all physician visits for asthma, the other respiratory and allergic disorders noted above, as well as URI and LRI and noninfectious gastroenteritis. For mothers, we also identified selected complications of pregnancy (ICD 640645) and childbirth (ICD 650652, 660665, 669). Using data from the mother and siblings, we determined if the child was exposed to URI or LRI in the family during the first and/or the second year of life.
Analysis
We used the Cox proportional hazard model14 to identify characteristics of the child and of his/her mother and siblings that were significantly associated with the first diagnosis of asthma. Variables associated with pregnancy and birth, as well as characteristics of mothers and siblings, were modeled as time-fixed variables. Variables that changed during the course of the study (onset of respiratory and allergic conditions in infants) were modeled as time-dependent variables. Hazard ratios (HRs) with 95% confidence interval (CI) indicate relative risks of asthma. Statistical significance was defined as p < 0.05 or 95% CI not overlapping the value of 1.0.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Tables 1234 show variables with significant HRs for the incidence of asthma. These HRs were derived from the model that included all significant time-fixed and time-dependent variables. Table 1 shows that male gender, pediatricians as primary care providers, and urban residence increased the likelihood of asthma. In Winnipeg, the risk did not vary significantly among neighborhoods with different mean income.
|
|
|
|
Table 3 shows that a maternal history of asthma was a strong predictor of asthma, while a maternal history of allergic rhinitis was less so. The risk of asthma increased with the mothers age. However, this was the case only when time-dependent variables (Table 4) were added to the model; without them, the risk of asthma in infants was inversely related to maternal age.
Table 3 also shows that having a sibling was protective. However, having a sibling with a history of allergic conditions increased the risk of asthma. Asthma risk was more strongly associated with asthma in siblings than with maternal asthma. The association with maternal or sibling allergic rhinitis was weaker than that with asthma. A siblings history of noninfectious gastroenteritis and of contact dermatitis was protective.
Table 4 shows significant time-dependent variables. A physicians diagnosis of several atopic conditions and noninfectious gastroenteritis increased the likelihood of a subsequent diagnosis of asthma. In addition, both LRI and URI increased the risk of asthma.
Exposure of an infant during the first or second year of life to URI or LRI in the mother or siblings did not affect the risk of asthma when time-dependent variables were in the model (Table 3). Without time-dependent variables in the model, however, the significantly increased risk of asthma was associated with mothers and siblings URI and LRI in both the first and the second year of life.
Having a sibling was protective (Table 3). We explored this by substituting the number of siblings for the categorical sibling variable. When there were no time-dependent variables in the model, only children with four or more siblings had a significantly lower risk of asthma than those without siblings. When time-dependent variables (Table 4) were in the model, those with one sibling were protected (HR, 0.94; 95% CI, 0.91 to 0.97), and protection increased almost linearly so that the HR for those with five and more siblings was 0.74 (95% CI, 0.67 to 0.82). We classified children into those with at least one sibling with asthma, or allergic rhinitis, or atopic dermatitis, and those without (Fig 1 ). In the latter, having a single sibling was protective, and the effect did not increase with the number of siblings. Those with siblings with allergic disorders had a higher risk than those without siblings, but the effect decreased progressively with the number of siblings.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
There are several advantages of using the MPHRR for asthma research. It includes the whole population with universal coverage and access to health care, and has substantial statistical power to detect associations. There is no reporting or recall bias in regard to either asthma or the risk factors examined. We were able to identify objectively the primary caregiver in the first year, and families (mother and siblings), and assess the relationship of their diseases to the onset of asthma in the children studied.
The overall cumulative asthma incidence by age 6 years was 14.1%, similar to 18.2% for the British 1958 birth cohort at age 7 years.16 Incidence increased 2.3 times between 1980 and 1990, and we controlled for the cohort effect in our analyses. The same risk factors were identified when individual cohorts were examined.
Our finding that asthma was more likely to be diagnosed in boys is consistent with most studies.3161718 Primary care pediatricians were more likely to diagnose asthma than family physicians. The increased sensitivity on the part of pediatricians may reflect greater access to guidelines and other educational efforts concerning asthma.
We found that childhood asthma was less common in rural areas than in the urban area, as have others in Canada.19 This cannot be ascribed to pediatrician supply since we controlled for this effect. There was no association between asthma and urban neighborhood mean household income. This is consistent with our previous studies20 in contrast to the United States, where asthma in urban children was more common in lower socioeconomic groups than in higher socioeconomic groups.21
As others,17 we found a strong effect of a family history of asthma and allergic disorders on asthma risk. In the present study, childhood asthma was more strongly associated with asthma in siblings than in mothers, presumably because siblings could have inherited an asthmatic predisposition from the father as well as the mother. Our database did not identify the biological father. Independent of familial history, the occurrence of an allergic disorder (for example allergic rhinitis) in a child further increased likelihood of a subsequent diagnosis of asthma (Table 4).
In the New Zealand cohort, low birth weight was not associated with an increased prevalence of asthma.2223 However, our results are consistent with studies showing the association of low birth weight with an increased risk of asthma.1721
In our study, low gestational age was an additional risk factor for asthma, independent of birth weight. This is in agreement with some other studies,1824 but not all.21 Since maternal smoking is associated with an increased risk of both low birth weight and premature birth,252627 maternal smoking may underlie the association we found between these factors and asthma.
We found that some congenital anomalies of the respiratory and circulatory system apparently increased the risk of asthma. This was true for both cystic fibrosis and perinatal respiratory distress. This likely represents a labeling problem since these conditions are associated with bronchial hyperresponsiveness and wheezing.2829
Certain conditions during pregnancy and labor further increased the risk of asthma in our study. This is consistent with literature30313233 indicating a wide variety of abnormalities of pregnancy and birth can be associated with subsequent asthma in the child. Though maternal asthma increases the risk of complications during pregnancy,3435 we controlled for this influence.
Others2136 have found maternal age inversely related to wheezing lower respiratory illness. This may reflect a greater vulnerability of young mothers and higher exposures to risk factors such as smoking. In our study, asthma risk increased with maternal age after we considered time-dependent variables that reflected the childs own respiratory infections and allergic disorders. Children of younger mothers may be more likely to have URI and LRI, accounting for previous findings.
Our finding that the risk of asthma was lower for infants born in winter months is consistent with findings on the Isle of Wight,17 but not with those in Germany37 or in New Zealand,23 where only skin sensitivity to allergens was associated with season. Businco et al38 found that children with skin reactivity to pollen were significantly more likely to be born during pollen season.
Our study strongly suggests that infections during the first years of life increase the risk of asthma. This might have been expected in the case of LRI, which present major labeling problems. However, we found little difference between the effects of LRI and URI. Our findings are consistent with those of McKeever et al,39 but others40 have reported that URI had a protective effect in terms of subsequent asthma diagnoses.
Respiratory infections in mothers and siblings in the first 2 years significantly increased the likelihood of asthma in study subjects when time-dependent variables were not in the model, but not when time-dependent variables, representing infections in children themselves, were added (Table 3). This suggests that the effects of exposure to respiratory infections were largely mediated by the acquisition of these infections by the children themselves.
We found that previous URI predisposed to asthma, in contrast to the hygiene hypothesis,41 which argues that exposure to URI drives the immune system in the T-helper type 1 direction thought to be protective against asthma.40 However, children with siblings having noninfectious gastroenteritis and contact dermatitis were protected. These disorders are poorly defined and very common, and may be proxies for unknown exposures in early life. However, gastroenteritis and contact dermatitis increased asthma risk in the children themselves. The protective effect of siblings has been cited as a proxy for exposure to infections favoring the hygiene hypothesis. The fact that we found that siblings had a protective effect after considering previous URI, gastroenteritis, and contact dermatitis suggest that the effect was not due to exposure to infections.
Finally, the progressive protective effect of sibling number seemed to be restricted to children in atopic families in our study. Celedón et al42 reported that maternal history of asthma modified the relationship between day care exposure and asthma. However, contrary to their observation that the protective effect of day care exposures was greater in those without maternal asthma, in our study the siblings protective effect was greater in those with family history of asthma.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Support was provided by the Medical Research Council Canada.
Received for publication December 9, 2003. Accepted for publication May 19, 2004.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
T. To, A. Gershon, C. Wang, S. Dell, and L. Cicutto Persistence and Remission in Childhood Asthma: A Population-Based Asthma Birth Cohort Study Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, December 1, 2007; 161(12): 1197 - 1204. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Goldberg, E. Israeli, S. Schwartz, T. Shochat, G. Izbicki, O. Toker-Maimon, E. Klement, and E. Picard Asthma Prevalence, Family Size, and Birth Order Chest, June 1, 2007; 131(6): 1747 - 1752. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |