|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Department of Pediatrics (Ms. Sahlberg and Dr. Strandvik), Institute for the Health of Women and Children, the Department of Orthopedic Surgery (Dr. Svantesson and Ms. Magnusson Thomas), Institute of Occupational Therapy and Physiotherapy, Göteborg University, Göteborg, Sweden.
Correspondence to: Margareta E. Sahlberg, BSc, West Swedish CF Center, The Queen Silvia Childrens Hospital, SE-416 85 Göteborg, Sweden; e-mail: margareta.sahlberg{at}vgregion.se
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: To compare muscular strength and function in patients with CF with those aspects in a healthy control group (CG).
Design: Thirty-three patients with CF (16 women) aged 16 to 35 years and 20 healthy individuals matched for age and gender were included in the study. All participants had undertaken regular physical training two to three times per week. The following tests were performed: vertical jumping ability; hand-grip strength; abdominal strength; arm/shoulder strength; quadriceps muscle strength; and a functional test of leg muscle endurance.
Results: Patients with CF showed decreased muscle strength and function compared to control subjects (women: maximal hand-grip strength in the right [p = 0.02] and the left hand [p = 0.001]; sustained hand-grip strength in the left hand [p = 0.002]; and in leg muscle endurance [p = 0.02]; men: the number of sit-ups performed within 30 s [p = 0.03]; and left leg isokinetic quadriceps strength at 180° per second [p = 0.02]). The differences were not related to pancreatic or pulmonary function. There was no significant difference between the CF group and the CG in any other test results.
Conclusions: Our study showed few differences in muscular performance between patients with CF and healthy control subjects. Both groups had regular moderate-to-high activity levels. Further studies are needed to evaluate whether the small but significant differences might be related to metabolic abnormalities in skeletal muscles in CF patients.
Key Words: gender hand-grip strength lung function muscle tests physical activity
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The ideal type, intensity, frequency, and duration of physical activity for patients with CF is unknown.13 Hitherto, instructions have been given14 that are similar to those given to healthy individuals, as follows: do any kind of physical training three times per week and for at least 30 min in each session. Some patients prefer muscle-resistance training, while others prefer endurance training, and many want to participate in different sports. Endurance training affects the cardiorespiratory systems, increasing heart and respiration rates.15 Adolescent CF patients often decrease their training over time. Whether this reduction is linked to psychological factors or to true physical impairment in endurance has not yet been studied.
It is well-known that there are differences in muscular strength and function between healthy men and women.15161718 The aims of this study were to measure muscular strength and function in our young adult CF population and to make comparisons with a healthy control group (CG) with regard to gender.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Thirty-three patients with CF (16 women) were included in the study, and the clinical data are presented in Table 1
. Fifteen patients were homozygous, and 12 patients were compound heterozygous for
F508. In the latter group, a severe second mutation was identified in seven patients. Two further patients had other severe mutations.19 A total of 24 patients had severe mutations and were PI (11 women). Nine patients had mild genotypes and were pancreas sufficient (PS) [five women]. Twenty-two patients were chronic Pseudomonas aeruginosa colonization. Six patients had CF-related diabetes mellitus, six patients had mild liver involvement verified by liver biopsy, and one patient had liver cirrhosis. These seven patients had been treated with ursodeoxycholic acid for years. One patient received oral corticosteroids periodically. None of the patients received inhaled corticosteroids.
|
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee at Göteborg University, and informed consent was obtained from all patients and subjects, and from the parents of the children. The experiments complied with the Helsinki Declaration and Swedish law.
Test Procedure
All subjects were tested at a research laboratory by a physical therapist who was accustomed to the testing procedure (E.M.T.) but was unaware of whether subjects were patients or control subjects. None of the patients or control subjects had been tested before. The procedure was equal for all participants. The standard instructions were given, and the subjects were allowed to familiarize themselves with each specific test. The tests were always performed in the same order as presented here. No recovery time was given except for time to move between the tests and the time for instructions. Verbal encouragement was not used during the specific tests, but instructions to undertake all of the tests with a maximum of effort were given in advance. All subjects wore a t-shirt, shorts, and fitness shoes. The subjects warmed up on a cycle ergometer for 5 min at 100 W of resistance and did 20 submaximal push-ups against a wall. The total time for the tests was 1 h and 15 min for all subjects. The following test protocol was used for all subjects.
Vertical jump (ie, counter movement jump)23 was performed on a jumping mat connected to an electronic timer (Time-it; Eleiko Sport; Halmstad, Sweden). The subject started in the upright position, and the jump was performed with both legs. Free arm swings were allowed. The movement started with bending the knees and was directly followed by an upward movement, ending with a maximal vertical jump and landing on both feet. Submaximal trials were allowed before the test started. The highest height (in centimeters) of three maximal tests was registered.
Hand-grip strength was measured with a portable instrument with a grip device and arm support (Grippit; AB Detector; Göteborg, Sweden) that enabled standardized arm and grip positioning.16 The grip device was connected to an electronic unit with an adapter for connection to a power supply. The grip device allowed the fingers and palm to be completely clasped around it. The force exerted against the transducer located in the grip device was displayed and recorded. Grip force (measured in newtons) registered the maximal voluntary contraction (MVC), and the mean value during 10 s registered the sustained MVC (SMVC). Both the right and left hands were tested, always beginning with the right hand. The test was performed three times with a 1-min rest between trials. The highest value was recorded.
Abdominal muscle strength was measured with sit-ups. The subject lay supine on a mat, hands together behind the neck, knees bent at 90°, and feet flat on the mat and 10 cm apart. The test leader held on to the feet. A sit-up was correctly performed when the subject raised and touched the knees with the elbows and then laid back, with the shoulder blades on the mat. The subject was instructed to do the sit-ups as fast as possible. If two incorrect sit-ups were performed, the test was interrupted. The test continued until the subject was exhausted. The number of sit-ups performed during 30 s and the total number of sit-ups were recorded for each individual.
Arm/shoulder muscle strength was measured with push-ups. The subject was in the prone position on a mat, the hands placed at shoulder width under the shoulder joint, fingers forward, arms straight, head and body aligned, and toes on the mat 10 cm apart. The push-up was correctly performed when the subject bent the elbows to 90°, holding the body straight, and then straightened the elbows again. The subject was instructed to perform the test as fast as possible. When exhaustion occurred or if two incorrect push-ups were performed, the test was interrupted. The total number of push-ups was recorded.
Quadriceps muscle strength was measured with a hydraulically driven and microcomputer-controlled device (Kinetic Communicator II; Chattanooga Group; Chattanooga, TN), which operates in an isokinetic or isometric mode. The subject was positioned with a hip angle of 120° in the test chair. The axis of the knee joint was approximated to the axis of rotation of the dynamometer. The subject was stabilized with a strap around the waist. The leg-stabilization restraint was placed as far distally on the tibia as possible, while allowing full dorsal flexion of the ankle. The arms were crossed in front of the chest. In order to become accustomed to the test, the subject performed three submaximal concentric muscle actions of the knee joint. Three maximal concentric muscle actions were performed with 30 s of rest between the trials, at both 60° and 180°/s. Three maximal voluntary isometric contractions in knee extension were performed at a knee joint angle of 60°. The highest value was recorded. Both legs were tested. The starting leg was randomized. The force was measured in newton meters or newtons. All measurements were performed with applied gravity compensation.
A functional knee bend test was created to measure leg muscle endurance. The subject stood on the floor with the hips bent at 90°, a straight back and neck, feet 10 cm apart, and arms hanging. In that position, the level of the distal part of the middle finger was marked on the leg. The distance between the lateral malleolus and the lateral knee joint was measured with a tape measure, and half of that distance was marked. The subject was instructed to do as many knee bends as possible, touching the two marks, while keeping the back straight. The velocity was standardized with a metronome set at 120 beats/min, corresponding to 1 Hz. The test was performed until the subject was exhausted and was interrupted if the standardized procedure could not be sustained. The total number of knee bends was recorded.
Statistical Analysis
The conventional formula was used for calculations of mean (SD). The Student t test was used for comparisons between groups. The strength of correlation between the variables was assessed by using the Spearman rank correlation test. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05 (StatView for Windows, version Xp; SAS Institute; Cary, NC).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The results of the muscular strength and function tests are depicted in Table 2 . The men with CF, but not the women with CF, performed fewer sit-ups in 30 s (p = 0.03). The number of sit-ups performed in 30 s was the only parameter that correlated with FEV1 (p < 0.05) for men with CF. No gender differences could be seen in the total number of sit-ups between CF patients and control subjects. Hand-grip strength in both the right and left hands was significantly decreased in the women with CF, compared to healthy women. The isokinetic quadriceps muscle strength (180°/s) was significantly decreased in men with CF (p = 0.02), but neither gender differed from control subjects in the same test (60°/s). The women with CF did not accomplish the same number of knee bends as control subjects (p = 0.02). One male patient with CF was not able to perform the knee-bend test, and one female control subject did not perform the isometric quadriceps muscle test on the right leg because of knee pain. Women had low arm-shoulder strength, and seven subjects with CF and two control subjects did not manage to perform any push-ups.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Although lung function was significantly decreased, compared to control subjects, it was good for this age group6811 and could not be related to muscular impairment since only sit-ups performed in 30 s in men with CF correlated with FEV1. Pancreatic status was not related to impaired muscular strength or function.
Previously, Lands et al10 demonstrated correlation between leg strength, measured with an isokinetic cycle ergometer (expressed in watts), and lean body mass in CF patients and control subjects. We found a similar correlation between isokinetic quadriceps strength, at both 60° and 180°/s (data not shown), and lean body mass in CF patients (Fig 1 ). Unfortunately, we could not perform dual x-ray absorptiometry in the control subjects. Leg muscle endurance is important in daily life. The knee-bend test is a test of muscle endurance, and was, in our opinion, more functional and in accord with activities of daily living and many sports than endurance testing on a cycle ergometer.10 Therefore, it was interesting that this test yielded lower values in women with CF, but this discrepancy cannot be explained by differing activities.
|
It is well-known that healthy women have 40 to 60% less muscular strength in the upper body and about 25% less muscular strength in the lower body compared to men.1518 This was confirmed in our study (Table 2) and also was found to be relevant for CF patients. The men with CF differed in muscle strength and function in only two tests, compared to the male control subjects, but women differed in four tests, which were not the same tests as those in which the men differed. Elkin et al8 reported that adults with CF had significantly less quadriceps and hand-grip strength than did control subjects. They did not differentiate according to gender, and it is thus not possible to compare their results with ours.
The differences between patients with CF and control subjects were probably not due to reduced muscle mass since the studied patients had normal lean body mass. The weakness could not be due to the use of corticosteroids, since they are rarely prescribed to our patients.6 Only one male patient had periodically received such therapy.
In conclusion, our study mainly showed similar muscular strength and function in young adult patients with CF when compared to age-matched healthy control subjects with similar basic physical activity. Slight muscular weakness was found in women with CF, which was indicated by lower endurance in hand and leg muscles, and, in men with CF was indicated by lower endurance in abdominal muscles and quadriceps. The results confirm the presence of impaired endurance even in well-trained patients but would hardly have been disclosed if the gender perspective had been omitted when analyzing the control subjects. The issue of whether the impairment in muscular strength and function are due to metabolic, hormonal, or neuromuscular factors requires further investigation.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
This study was supported by the Swedish Heart and Lung Foundation, the Swedish Cystic Fibrosis Association, the Center for Sports Medicine in Stockholm, the Medical Faculty at Göteborg University, and the Swedish Research Council (4995).
Received for publication June 15, 2004. Accepted for publication October 29, 2004.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |