|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Department of Internal Medicine (Drs. Thomsen and Backer), Bispebjerg Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark; the Department of Respiratory Medicine (Dr. Ulrik), and the Clinical Research Unit (Dr. Larsen), Hvidovre Hospital, Hvidovre, Denmark; The Danish Twin Registry (Dr. Kyvik), University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark; the Department of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (Dr. Skadhauge), Odense University Hospital, Odense, Denmark; and the Department of Respiratory Medicine (Dr. Steffensen), Holbæk Hospital, Holbæk Denmark.
Correspondence to: Simon F. Thomsen, MD, Department of Internal Medicine I, Bispebjerg Hospital, DK-2400 Copenhagen NV, Denmark; e-mail: sft{at}city.dk
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: From birth cohorts over the period 1953 to 1982 in The Danish Twin Registry, 19,349 subjects with no history of asthma, as determined by a questionnaire-based survey in 1994, answered a follow-up questionnaire in 2002. The subjects were regarded as incident asthma cases when answering "yes" to the question "Do you have, or have you ever had asthma?" in 2002, and "no" to the same question in 1994.
Results: A total of 838 cases (4.3%) of new asthma were identified in 2002. The incidence rates of asthma were 4.5 and 6.4 per 1,000 person-years, respectively, among male and female subjects. For all ages, the probability of adult-onset asthma was greater for female subjects (odds ratio [OR], 1.49; p < 0.001), and for both sexes there was a slow decline in probability with increasing age. There was a positive association between increasing body mass index (BMI) and risk of adult-onset asthma applying to both sexes (OR, 1.05 per unit; p < 0.001). Furthermore, positive associations were found between incident asthma and a history of hay fever (OR: male subjects, 4.2; female subjects, 3.7; p < 0.001), eczema (OR: male subjects, 3.5; female subjects, 2.0; p < 0.001), and both (OR: male subjects, 6.9; female subjects, 8.0; p < 0.001).
Conclusions: There is a continuing high incidence of asthma past childhood that is most pronounced among female subjects. Increasing levels of BMI are associated with a greater likelihood of developing asthma for both sexes. A substantial portion of cases of adult asthma is preceded by upper airway allergic symptoms and/or eczema, thus indicating a shared pathogenesis.
Key Words: asthma body mass index hay fever incidence sex
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
By means of a prospective questionnaire study, the objective of this survey was to determine the incidence of asthma and to examine the age-dependent and sex-dependent risk for adolescent-onset and adult-onset asthma from 1994 through 2002. Furthermore, we wanted to provide risk estimates for incident asthma during the intervening 8-year period given information on hay fever, eczema, body mass index (BMI), smoking, and leisure time physical activity.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A questionnaire with items aimed at identifying multiple phenotypes, including identical questions on asthma, was used to assess subjects on both occasions. Affected cases were identified on the basis of responses to the question "Do you have, or have you ever had asthma?" Individuals answering "yes" to that question were classified as having or having had asthma. This procedure has previously been shown12 to be reliable with respect to identifying subjects with asthma in population-based studies that use questionnaire responses as the sole diagnostic criterion. Similar questions were applied to detect subjects with hay fever and eczema.
Subjects were stratified into the following four separate categories on the basis of answers to questions on smoking history: (1) current daily smokers (subjects who smoked more than one cigarette, one cigar, one cheroot, and/or 1 g of pipe tobacco per day); (2) occasional smokers (subjects who smoked less than one cigarette, one cigar, one cheroot, or 1 g of pipe tobacco per day on average); (3) former smokers (subjects who have stopped smoking any time prior to the date of assessment); and (4) never smokers (subjects who have never smoked).
Subjects were divided into the following three categories owing to the quantity of weekly leisure time physical activity: (1) light physical activity (subjects who spend < 2 h per week on light exercise activities); (2) moderate physical activity (subjects who spend between 2 h per week on light exercise activities and 4 h per week on heavy exercise activities); and (3) heavy physical activity (subjects who spend > 4 h per week on heavy exercise activities).
Statistical Analysis
The data were analyzed with a statistical software package (R: A Language for Data Analysis and Graphics; R. Gentleman, GNU Project, Free Software Foundation; Boston, MA).13 Overdispersion could be expected to a certain extent due to intrapair correlation of asthma.14 The overdispersion parameter was estimated to be equal to 1.068, which means that the intrapair correlation of asthma in this cohort is very small. Furthermore, the studied cohort comprised 35% single twins, which also provides us with ample authority to consider the entire sample of twins as if it was composed of single uncorrelated individuals (ie, the confidence intervals [CIs] reported fall 2 to 3% narrow of that ideal situation).
Since we did not know the exact time of the onset of asthma in each subject, we calculated the incidence rates of asthma under the assumption that each incident case of asthma on average acquired asthma in the middle of the study period (ie, after 4 years). This approach gave us a total of 151,440 person-years under observation.
The probability of acquiring asthma depends on age and BMI in a fashion that is still poorly understood. We analyzed the age-dependent and BMI-dependent risk of new asthma by means of a generalized additive model,15 which allowed us to handle age and BMI as continuous variables when the analyses were performed separately for subjects 12 to 19 and 20 to 41 years of age.
Logistic regression modeling was applied to investigate associations among risk factors for having asthma. Separate analyses were performed for the age groups 12 to 19 years and 20 to 41 years, with incident asthma from 1994 through 2002 as response, and with sex, age, smoking, and leisure time physical activity as explanatory variables. BMI was also included in the older age group. BMI was calculated as weight in kilograms divided by the square of height in meters.
The analyses of incident asthma in relation to eczema and hay fever were done by means of two-way tables stratified on sex, for the entire cohort. Results are reported as odds ratios (ORs). A p value of < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant. The protocol was evaluated and approved by the local ethics committee.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The relationship between age and the probability of acquiring asthma for male subjects and female subjects is shown in Figure 1 . For all ages, the likelihood of new asthma is greater for female subjects than for male subjects, with a remarkably higher probability for the development of asthma among young adult female subjects.
|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the 8-year study period, 3.5% of the male subjects and 5.0% of the female subjects developed asthma. The probability was higher for younger subjects, especially for adolescent girls. This sex difference has been pointed out in several previous studies,16 among which, another Scandinavian study emphasized the high incidence among adolescent girls. We found incidence rates of relatively high magnitude compared to previously reported findings. In a retrospective study of 15,813 individuals who were 16 to 50 years of age (period under study, 1959 to 1993) by Torén and Hermansson,17 overall incidence rates of physician-diagnosed asthma of 1.1 per 1,000 person-years among male subjects and 1.3 per 1,000 person years among female subjects were noted. Another study from Sweden18 among 4,754 subjects who were 36 to 67 years of age and were studied from 1986 to 1996 showed a 10-year cumulative incidence of self-reported asthma of 3.2% in male subjects and 4.5% in female subjects. A comparable finding was reported by Eagan and colleagues19 from Norway for subjects studied from 1986 to 1997, yet with a trend toward lowest incidence among female subjects, and concluding with an 11-year cumulative incidence of 4.0% among male subjects and 3.5% among female subjects who were 15 to 70 years of age. Additionally, several other studies342021 on adult-onset asthma, mainly American, have reported incidence rates of a comparably lower scale compared to ours. Heterogeneity among the earlier reported findings could reflect differences in diagnostic tools, discrepancies between studied age groups and the time of the surveys, as well as diagnostic mix-up with COPD.
We used self-reported asthma (ie, asking the question "Do you have, or have you ever had asthma?") as the diagnostic approach, which is a method that has proven to have a high specificity for the diagnosis of asthma and, hence, is suitable for excluding false-positive cases.12 The high incidence found in our study could therefore reflect a true increase in the prevalence of asthma among Danish adults.22 Thus, despite other factors possibly influencing the outcome, such as lack of recall regarding asthma in childhood, as well as heightened awareness due to asthma being discussed extensively in public, both of which give rise to an overestimation of the actual number of incident cases, we concluded that asthma is a disease with a continuing high incidence past childhood.
It has been shown that obesity and increasing levels of BMI are associated with incident asthma, especially among adult women,6 but also among men.23 However, it has been argued2425 that the relationship between overweight and the occurrence of asthma is a spurious one, emphasizing the fact that objective signs of airflow obstruction are lacking in obese populations despite increased reporting of respiratory symptoms and increased use of bronchodilators. We found an increasing probability of incident asthma for all levels of BMI from 20 to about 30 (ie, in the normal weight to lightly overweight range of the spectrum), with a constant greater risk among female subjects. From BMI levels of about
28, however, the SDs became so large, due to the few subjects in these BMI categories, that the effect of BMI on the risk of asthma was difficult to interpret. We found no association of statistical significance between sedentary lifestyle (ie, low levels of leisure time physical activity) and asthma. In line with this, it has been shown that low energy expenditure from leisure time physical activity cannot explain the positive association between obesity and asthma.26 Still, ß2-adrenoceptor polymorphisms are found to be positively associated with adult-onset asthma in sedentary women compared to physically active women with the same genotype.27 That finding showed that risk alleles might only become observable in risk environments, thus explaining why small but causal associations can be left unnoticed when studying genetically and environmentally heterogeneous populations. We concluded that if the relationship between overweight and asthma is causal, this heightened susceptibility is most likely to be explained by inadequately understood biochemical changes associated with weight gain, or by the changes in lifestyle accompanying it. Further, a possible, but not yet documented, pleiotropic effect of genes conferring risk to the development of both phenotypes needs to be taken into account.
We found no statistically significant impact of smoking on the development of asthma. Previous findings in this area have been conflicting. Including older subjects (ie, those > 50 years of age) in surveys with self-reported asthma as a diagnostic criterion could lead to misclassification owing to confusion about COPD and asthma, thus overestimating the number of affected subjects. On the basis of our data, we are still, however, not able to find any proof of a causal relationship between smoking and the development of asthma.
Our data indicated that a substantial portion of cases of adolescent-onset and adult-onset asthma are preceded by hay fever and/or eczema. This view is supported by Burrows and colleagues,28 who have shown that most, if not all, asthma has an allergic basis. This does not neglect the fact that two different phenotypes, as judged by skin test reactivity, can be distinguished, especially in adulthood, with the nonallergic form, which is often associated with female sex and a poorer prognosis, being the more severe.29 Nevertheless, although we found a statistically significant association between atopic markers, such as hay fever and eczema, and the later development of asthma, we propose that it might be pathophysiologically redundant to state this association, since hay fever, eczema, and asthma are manifestations of the same disease entity.30 This view is supported by data from the bulk of epidemiologic studies53132 and from several studies of cellular biology3334 that outline evidence of rhinitis and asthma being a comorbid disease with systemic inflammatory cross-talk.3536 However, when subjects are asked whether they have, or have had asthma, it is likely that they will refer to a more chronic state of the disease, and it is doubtful that few periodic or infrequent attacks of wheezing occurring concomitantly with an attack of hay fever, in the subjects perception, will qualify as a diagnosis of asthma. The picture is further blurred by the fact that inflammatory changes are present in the lower airways of atopic nonasthmatic subjects even before the onset of symptoms.37 The searching for risk factors associated with asthma in this setting likely will reveal an association with a persistent wheezing state, and not with early manifestations of the disease.
We need to take into account that conclusions about incidence rates and risk factors for the development of asthma in this study were inferred on the basis of twin data. However, it seems reasonable to extend the results to the general population when there are no differences in the etiology or the prevalence of the disease between twins and singletons. Twins are on average born 3 weeks prior to term with a birth weight that on average is 1,000 g below that of singletons. One might therefore suspect that this would tend to confer an increased risk among twins for the later development of diseases such as asthma and allergy. According to the fetal origins hypothesis, it has been argued38 that a heightened risk for the occurrence of chronic diseases later in life can be partly attributed to intrauterine growth retardation and to suboptimal development during fetal life. Following this, low birth weight has been associated with the subsequent development of wheezing illness in some studies (ie, Schwartz et al39 reported that a 2-SD deficit [1,162 g] in birth weight increased the risk of childhood wheeze by a factor 1.4). It is, however, not clear whether this increased risk also applies to the type of growth retardation observed in multiple pregnancies. In the face of these results, Räsänen et al40 studied the relationship between birth weight and the risk for asthma in adolescent twins and found no increased risk among subjects with low birth weight. In fact, some studies have shown that the prevalence of atopic disease in twins is indeed somewhat lower than that found in the general population. A reduced hospital admission rate due to asthma (rate ratio, 0.47) was found among Scottish twin children,41 and, further, a reduced prevalence of asthma was found among Swedish twin army conscripts (4.9% vs 5.9% in singletons).42 But even with variation in the reported results, and acknowledging that subtle differences may exist, we are still confident in stating that the conclusions drawn from this study can apply to the general population.
In conclusion, we found a notably high incidence of asthma past childhood, which was most pronounced among female subjects. Furthermore, we observed that increasing levels of BMI, even in the normal range of the weight spectrum, are associated with a greater likelihood of developing asthma for both sexes. Finally, we found that a substantial portion of adult asthma is preceded by upper airway allergic symptoms and/or eczema, indicating a shared pathogenesis.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
This study was supported by sponsorships from The Health Insurance Foundation, The Copenhagen Hospital Corporation, and The Danish Lung Association.
Received for publication June 3, 2004. Accepted for publication December 7, 2004.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. Chinn, S. H. Downs, J. M. Anto, M. W. Gerbase, B. Leynaert, R. de Marco, C. Janson, D. Jarvis, N. Kunzli, J. Sunyer, et al. Incidence of asthma and net change in symptoms in relation to changes in obesity Eur. Respir. J., October 1, 2006; 28(4): 763 - 771. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |