|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Divisions of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Departments of Internal Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN (Drs. Gajic, Limper and Aksamit); and Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL (Dr. Festic).
Correspondence to: Emir Festic, MD, Mayo Clinic, 4500 San Pablo Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32224; e-mail: festic.emir{at}mayo.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: A retrospective review of medical records and an APACHE (acute physiology and chronic health evaluation) III database.
Setting: Academic tertiary medical center.
Results: We identified 30 patients with nonHIV-related PCP and ARF. In-hospital, 6-month, and 1-year mortality rates were 67%, 77%, and 80%, respectively. Median age was 63.5 years. Median APACHE III score on day 1 was 65.5. Median ICU and hospital lengths of stay were 13 days and 21 days, respectively. All seven patients having a pneumothorax died. All but one patient had an elevated lactate dehydrogenase level (median, 563 U/L). The diagnosis was made using BAL in 28 patients and by transbronchial biopsy in the remaining 2 patients. All patients were immunosuppressed (eight were receiving corticosteroids, seven were receiving chemotherapy, and the remainder received both). Median immunosuppressive prednisone-equivalent dose was 40 mg (median length of treatment, 4.5 months). Not a single patient received PCP prophylaxis. All but one patient required intubation and invasive positive pressure ventilation (PPV). Hospital mortality was associated with high APACHE III scores on day 1 (p = 0.05), intubation delay (p = 0.03), length of PPV (p = 0.003), and development of pneumothorax (p = 0.033). Logistic regression analysis demonstrated that association of intubation delay with hospital mortality persisted after adjusting for severity of illness (p = 0.03).
Conclusions: Among patients with ARF secondary to nonHIV-related PCP, poor prognostic factors include high APACHE III scores, intubation delay, longer duration of PPV, and development of pneumothorax. None of the patients in this series received PCP prophylaxis prior to the development of pneumonia.
Key Words: acute respiratory failure ICU Pneumocystis pneumonia
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It is well established that the clinical course of PCP differs in patients with or without HIV infection.189 NonHIV-related PCP presents as an acute fulminant pneumonia with abrupt onset of respiratory failure, while HIV patients experience a more insidious course. Furthermore, the organism burden and inflammatory response in lungs are markedly different between these two groups, and this contributes to the observed difference in outcomes.8910 However, despite these differences, the previous literature511121314 on both HIV- and nonHIV-related PCP prior to 1995 indicate that the mortality of patients with acute respiratory failure (ARF) requiring mechanical ventilation (MV) does not differ widely, and ranges between 40% and 60%. In a retrospective analysis15 of 116 nonHIV-related PCP cases at our institution between 1985 and 1991, the in-hospital mortality of patients who had ARF (n = 50) was 66%.
In order to examine the outcome and associated factors of ARF due to nonHIV-related PCP at our institution in more recent years, we retrospectively collected data for a consecutive series of nonHIV-related PCP patients requiring positive pressure ventilation (PPV) and admission to the ICU between 1995 and 2002. Clinical, laboratory, and radiologic features were examined, as were markers of disease severity, mechanical ventilation parameters, and patient outcomes.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All patients had a PCP diagnosis established by identification of organisms on BAL or transbronchial biopsy (TBBX). The doses of corticosteroids used for immunosuppression and as adjunctive therapy for PCP were converted to a prednisone-equivalent dose (PED) based on the standardized relative potency criteria.16 Laboratory data collected in addition to the APACHE data included lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and CD4 counts. The microbiology data reflected positive Gram stain or culture specimens during or shortly (1 week) after ICU stay. MV data included invasive vs noninvasive PPV, time of intubation relative to the time of ICU admission (on or off noninvasive PPV) and MV settings: positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP), and tidal volumes (VTs) reported as actual volumes and in milligrams per kilogram of predicted body weight (PBW).
Statistical analysis was done using statistical software (JMP, Version 5.1; SAS Institute; Cary, NC). For continuous variables, median values and ranges were reported. Association of independent variables with hospital mortality was assessed by using nonparametric Wilcoxon test and
2 test. Logistic regression analysis was performed in order to assess whether delayed intubation was associated with hospital mortality when adjusted for severity of illness (APACHE III score); p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Laboratory and Radiologic Features
The diagnosis of Pneumocystis jiroveci infection was established by calcofluor white staining of BAL material in 28 of these patients. Four of these patients had additional confirmation of the Pneumocystis organisms, two by TBBX and two on postmortem examination. The diagnosis for the remaining two patients was established by TBBX alone. In addition to Pneumocystis, other microorganisms were further detected either by Gram stains or culture specimens in 15 patients over the course of ICU stay or within 1 week thereafter (Table 2
). The presence of microorganisms on Gram stains or cultures did not show evidence of association with increased mortality (p = 0.16). Positive respiratory specimen results were deemed to be secondary to microorganism colonization or latent infection rather than active disease.
|
As expected, chest radiographic examinations generally revealed diffuse interstitial and alveolar infiltrates on hospital admission. Subsequent chest radiographs in all patients identified seven patients with pneumothorax over the course of their ICU stay. None of these patients survived the hospitalization.
Treatment and Ventilatory Support
Twenty-nine of the 30 patients were treated with TMP/SMZ; of these, one patient individual also received primaquine and clindamycin for 2 days. The remaining patient was allergic to TMP/SMZ, and therefore received pentamidine. All patients were additionally treated with adjunctive corticosteroids. The median PED of corticosteroids used in treatment for ARF related to PCP in these patients without AIDS was 65 mg (range, 10 to 100 mg).
Seventeen patients were placed on noninvasive positive pressure ventilation (NIPPV) upon ICU admission, 13 in the form of continuous positive airway pressure, and 4 in the form of bilevel positive airway pressure (BiPAP; Respironics; Murrysville, PA). Complete data on NIPPV was available for 16 of these 17 patients. The median duration of NIPPV prior to intubation was 35 h (range, 7 to 132 h). Four of the 16 patients who received NIPPV survived until hospital discharge (median duration of NIPPV, 10.5 h). The median duration of NIPPV was 49 h in 12 of the 16 patients who died (Table 3 ).
|
Patient Outcomes
Twenty patients did not survive to discharge from the hospital, yielding a mortality of 66.6%. Of the 10 patients who were discharged from the hospital, 3 died within 6 months and another died within a year. Accordingly, the 6-month and 1-year mortality rates were 77% and 80%, respectively. Of the 10 patients who survived until hospital discharge, 6 were discharged to home, 2 were discharged to short-term rehabilitation facilities, and 2 were discharged to nursing homes. Of the six patients who were discharged home, five were alive after 1 year. Of the two patients who were discharged to rehabilitation facilities, one died within 6 months and the other was alive at 1 year. Both patients who were discharged to nursing home died within 6 months.
Statistical analyses were performed to identify clinical features associated with mortality. Using univariate analyses, clinical features associated with mortality are presented in Table 3. Clinical features significantly associated with death from PCP include elevated APACHE III score on day 1 (p = 0.05), delay in intubation (p = 0.033), duration of PPV (p = 0.003), and the subsequent development of pneumothorax (p = 0.033). Logistic regression analysis confirmed that the delay in intubation was associated with higher hospital mortality after adjusting for severity of illness (p = 0.03; odds ratio, 1.04 for each hour of delay; 95% confidence interval, 1.01 to 1.09).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Similarly, Forrest et al1314 showed, in a retrospective review, that APACHE II and modified multisystem organ failure scores were both significant predictors of outcome in patients with AIDS-related PCP and respiratory failure. Our study further documents that APACHE III scores are predictive of mortality among non-HIV patients with PCP. The APACHE III model has previously been demonstrated to consistently predict overall morality across diagnoses in two large, prospective, multicenter North American series (37,668 patients and 116,340 patients).1718 An Australian study19 on 3,398 patients further demonstrated that the APACHE III could perform well as an independent assessment of probable mortality.
Delay in intubation, longer duration of PPV, and development of pneumothorax were also associated with mortality in our cohort. Bedos et al20 prospectively evaluated a similar cohort of patients with HIV-related PCP and respiratory failure. Their study revealed that delay of MV beyond 3 days, duration of MV for > 5 days, and development of pneumothorax were predictive of patients death within 3 months of ICU admission.20 Among patients with HIV-associated PCP and both delayed MV and pneumothorax, the predicted probability of 3-month death was close to 100% in that study. In another review21 of patients with AIDS with respiratory failure due to PCP requiring MV, those with a pneumothorax also had a mortality of 100%. In our series of ARF in patients with PCP in settings other than HIV, pneumothorax developed in seven patients, and none of them survived. It remains uncertain whether pneumothorax simply represents a marker of severe disease and poor prognosis or whether it independently worsens disease severity and mortality, as previously suggested.22 Because all patients with pneumothorax in our study died, logistic regression analysis was not feasible to verify if pneumothorax was associated with hospital mortality after adjusting for severity of illness.
Similar to patients with HIV infection and ARF due to PCP,20 delayed institution of MV in our patients was associated with increased mortality. For those who survived to hospital discharge, the median time from ICU admission to intubation was 4 h, compared to 48 h in those patients who died. In addition, for patients initially managed with NIPPV, the length of time from onset of NIPPV until intubation and institution of PPV was also significantly associated with outcome. Thus, prudent and earlier intubation and PPV may also be of benefit in the management of patients with ARF associated with PCP in patients without HIV.
Our current study clearly indicates that similar prognostic factors may be applied to both HIV- and nonHIV-related PCP patients with ARF. The clinical differences observed in milder cases of HIV- and nonHIV-related PCP appear to become much less significant once the disease has progressed to ARF. In this setting, both prognostic factors and mortality are very similar regardless of HIV status.
The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network study23 demonstrated decreased mortality in patients receiving MV with reduced VT (6 mL/kg PBW), as compared to traditional MV strategies. Although this study was published in May of 2000, protective lung ventilation strategies were not immediately applied nationwide. As a result, we are unable to determine whether these patients might have benefited from such a ventilatory strategy. The observation that all our patients except one had a ratio of PaO2 to fraction of inspired oxygen < 200 and received MV with a median VT of 10.5 mL/kg, with relatively low PEEP, suggests that these individuals may have been candidates for lower-VT protective lung ventilation. Furthermore, these patients also were predisposed to ventilator-associated lung injury. The combination of PCP-related lung injury and ventilator-associated lung injury might in part explain the high mortality observed in this cohort. As a strict protocol for ventilator management in patients with acute lung injury or ARDS was initiated at our institution in early 2003, the future evaluation of a similar cohort may help determine beneficial role for reduced VT ventilation in nonHIV-associated PCP.
Although CD4 counts have not been routinely measured in patients with PCP without HIV infection, among these patients, six had CD4 counts measured with a median of 70 cells/µL. In another study by Mansharamani et al,24 the median CD4 count was 61 cells/µL, and > 90% of patients had CD4 counts < 300 cells/µL at the time of nonHIV-related PCP diagnosis. Moreover, approximately 40% of the patients receiving long-term corticosteroid therapy deemed "at risk" for PCP had CD4 counts < 300 cells/µL, while the CD4 levels in patients not considered at risk for PCP were similar to those in healthy subjects.24 Thus, in immunosuppressed non-HIV patients, CD4 counts < 200 cells/µL might also help identify individuals at particularly high risk for PCP, which in turn should help guide prophylaxis. However, it should be noted with a word of caution that occasional patients with hematologic malignancies and other nonHIV-related immune suppressed conditions have been observed to acquire PCP with entirely normal or even elevated CD4 levels.
In our study cohort, no patient received PCP prophylaxis, in spite of receiving a median PED of 40 mg for a median duration of 4.5 months. One fourth of our patients received
30 mg of the PED for
2 months. In the previous study by Yale and Limper15 at our institution 10 years earlier, the median PED daily dose was 30 mg for a median duration of 12 weeks. One fourth of patients received as little as 16 mg or less of prednisone for 8 weeks. Even though our current study did not address the true incidence of PCP among immunosuppressed patients, it showed that 20 patients died in period of 6 years from a disease that was potentially preventable. With this in mind and the concerns that resistance to TMP/SMZ may emerge with increased reservoir for infection, it is prudent that the primary PCP prophylaxis is strongly considered for all immunosuppressed non-HIV patients, particularly those receiving > 16 mg/d prednisone for > 2 months, those individuals receiving cytotoxic chemotherapy, and those treated with other immunosuppressive regimens.1525
Comparing the immunosuppressive conditions associated with non-HIV PCP in the current series to the earlier study reported from our institution reveals that there has been a remarkable drop in the incidence of PCP among transplant recipients. The previous study by Yale and Limper15 reported that PCP developed in 25% of that series in the setting of solid-organ or bone marrow transplantation, which represented the second most common condition associated with PCP in settings other than AIDS. Interestingly, however, only 3% of the current series of individuals with PCP and ARF occurred in patients with organ transplantation (one patient). The incidence of PCP among all other predisposing conditions remained proportionally unchanged over the intervals of these two studies. The decrease in the incidence of PCP with ARF was attributed to a routine PCP prophylaxis among organ transplant recipients in more recent years.7
After learning the results of this study, performance-improvement protocol was implemented at our institution with a target of 100% PCP prophylaxis among all immunosuppressed non-HIV patients receiving prolonged systemic corticosteroid therapy, and/or cytotoxic chemotherapy. Moreover, early intubation and institution of mechanical ventilation on admission to the ICU is now recommended for patients with ARF due to nonHIV-related PCP.
Potential confounding features of this study should also be noted. The majority of these are inherent within the retrospective design employed in this study. Although virtually all of the reported data were charted prospectively as part of the documentation requirements for clinical care and our quality assurance programs (APACHE III database), it remains possible that some important variables may not have been recorded. However, we believe this to be unlikely, since the data set analyzed for each significant prognostic factors was entirely complete (100% data availability for APACHE III scores, duration of PPV and pneumothorax) or nearly complete (97% of data regarding the timing of intubation was available). Thus, only the secondary analyses might have been affected by missing data, but we also believe this to be not likely. In addition, with only 30 patients in this cohort, sufficient power might not have been present to demonstrate other potential relationships in clinical features and mortality.
In conclusion, our data suggest that ARF due to nonHIV-related PCP remains a serious illness with high mortality. Among our patients, poor prognostic features include elevated APACHE III scores, intubation delay, and longer duration of PPV, as well as the development of pneumothorax. The delay in intubation on admission to the ICU is associated with higher hospital mortality rate even after adjusting for severity of illness. These findings in nonHIV-related PCP patients are consistent with similar findings in HIV/AIDS-associated PCP documented in the literature. All patients in our cohort failed to receive PCP prophylaxis, which should be strongly considered for all non-HIV immunosuppressed patients receiving prolonged systemic corticosteroid therapy, and/or cytotoxic chemotherapy.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Financial support was provided by Mayo Clinic and Mayo Foundation.
Received for publication October 11, 2004. Accepted for publication January 18, 2005.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |