|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Departments of Medicine (Drs. Flume and Strange) and Biometry and Epidemiology (Dr. Ye and Ms. Clark) and Pediatrics (Ms. Ebeling and Dr. Hulsey), Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC.
Correspondence to: Patrick A. Flume, MD, FCCP, Medical University of South Carolina, 96 Jonathan Lucas St, 812-CSB, Charleston, SC 29425; e-mail: flumepa{at}musc.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: To identify risk factors associated with pneumothorax and to determine the prognosis of CF patients following an episode of pneumothorax.
Design: A retrospective observational cohort study of the National Cystic Fibrosis Patient Registry between the years 1990 and 1999.
Patients: The registry contained data on 28,858 patients with CF who had been followed up over those10 years at CF centers across the United States.
Results: Pneumothorax occurred with an average annual incidence of 0.64% and in 3.4% of patients overall. There was no increased occurrence by sex, but CF was more prevalent in older patients (mean [± SD] age, 21.9 ± 9.1 years) with more severe pulmonary impairment (nearly 75% of patients with FEV1 of < 40% predicted). The principal risks associated with an increased occurrence of pneumothorax included the presence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa (odds ratio [OR], 2.3), Burkholderia cepacia (OR, 1.8), or Aspergillus (OR, 1.3) in sputum cultures, FEV1 < 30% predicted (OR, 1.5), enteral feeding (OR, 1.7), Medicaid insurance (OR, 1.1), pancreatic insufficiency (OR, 1.4), allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis (OR, 1.5), and massive hemoptysis (OR, 1.4). There is an increased morbidity (eg, increased number of hospitalizations and number of days spent in the hospital) and an increased 2-year mortality rate following pneumothorax.
Conclusion: Pneumothorax is a serious complication in CF patients, occurring more commonly in older patients with more advanced lung disease. Nearly 1 in 167 patients will experience this complication each year. There is an attributable mortality to the complication and considerable morbidity, resulting in increased health-care utilization and a measurable decline in lung function.
Key Words: cystic fibrosis lung disease pneumothorax
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Using data from CF patients in the national Cystic Fibrosis Foundation (CFF) Patient Registry,5 multiple clinical features were analyzed to try to determine the risk factors that may be associated with pneumothorax as well as to determine the prognosis of patients following an episode of pneumothorax.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The CFF Patient Registry database was analyzed for the years from 1990 to 1999. For this period, the database contained 28,858 unique patients with a total of 197,156 separate entries (average number of entries per patient, 6.8). There were missing dates for 16,614 entries. This left a working database of 28,191 unique patients with 180,542 entries (average number of entries per patient, 6.4). This means that not all patients were seen and had reported data for all 10 years of the analysis. The CFF Patient Registry records only one entry per patient per year and so is a collection of year-end summary data. Complications are reported only if they are present during a specific year and may not reflect repeat occurrences. Therefore, the data are presented assuming no more than one episode of pneumothorax for each patient in a given year, although there could have been more. Patients who experienced a complication away from the CF center may not have had this included in the registry data.
Clinical variables that may influence pneumothorax were retrieved and analyzed. These included the following: (1) demographic data (eg, date of birth, sex, race, and insurance status); (2) complications related to CF (eg, pancreatic insufficiency, cirrhosis, diabetes, allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis [ABPA], and lung transplantation); (3) severity of disease (eg, FEV1 percent predicted, FVC percent predicted, percentage of ideal body weight, body mass index, supplemental [tub] feeding, and supplemental oxygen); (4) organisms present in cultures of the airways (eg, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Burkholderia cepacia, Staphylococcus aureus, methicillin-resistant S aureus, Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, Aspergillus, and atypical mycobacteria); (5) CF-related therapies (eg, dornase alfa, inhaled tobramycin, high-dose ibuprofen, and corticosteroids); and (6) outcomes (eg, mortality, clinic visits, hospitalizations, hospital days, and IV antibiotic days).
Statistical analysis consisted of the
2 test for categoric comparisons, the Student t test for the comparison of normally distributed means, and logistic regression for the simultaneous control of multiple potential confounders. Logistic regression was used to obtain the independent effect of multiple risk factors for pneumothorax. The database did not collect all variables for all 10 years. For example, therapy with inhaled tobramycin, dornase alfa, and ibuprofen have been included in the database only since 1997. Thus, multiple models were constructed to include variables that were collected for specific time periods.
The change in lung function over time (eg, FEV1) was also assessed using a mixed-model analysis of repeated measures, which utilized restricted maximum likelihood methods for estimation.7 Corey et al8 demonstrated several advantages of mixed-model analysis in assessing pulmonary function decline in CF patients, including the ability to account for both between-subject and within-subject variability within the same model. The selection of a satisfactory covariance structure is important to make appropriate inferences from repeated-measures data.7 Two models were fit with different covariance structures; an unstructured model and a first-order autoregressive model. The first-order autoregressive covariance model describes the correlation between observations in which adjacent observations are more highly correlated than observations that are further apart in time and was selected as the most appropriate for the data on the basis of information criteria assessing the fit of the model. A statistical software package used for these analyses (SAS Proc Mixed, SAS for Windows 9.0; SAS Institute; Cary, NC). The values reported are the mean ± SD, unless stated otherwise. A p value of < 0.05 was considered to be significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
Pneumothorax occurred in patients with a wide range of pulmonary function (including normal function) but occurred more frequently in patients with severe impairment of function(Table 2 ). Approximately 75% of patients had an FEV1 of < 40% predicted. The association with the severity of pulmonary disease can be seen in Figure 3 , in which there is a steep increase in numbers once FEV1 falls below 50% predicted.
|
|
|
Patients with pneumothorax who died in the same year as the pneumothorax had worse pulmonary function than did those who survived at least 1 more year. The patients with pneumothorax who survived had a greater mean FVC (52.3 ± 19.9% vs 42.9 ± 17.3% predicted, respectively; p < 0.0001) and FEV1 (37.7 ± 18.5% vs 28.0 ± 16.3% predicted, respectively; p < 0.0001) than did those who died in the same year. A Kaplan-Meier survival curve from the first pneumothorax episode is shown in Figure 4 , demonstrating 50% mortality at about 4 years.
|
|
Utilization of Resources
The utilization of services by patients with pneumothorax was analyzed, including outpatient visits, hospitalizations, and IV antibiotics, comparing the year before, during, and following the occurrence of the pneumothorax (Table 4
). There was an increase in the median number of hospitalizations and hospital days in the year of and the year following the pneumothorax. The average number of office visits did not change, although the number of hospitalizations per patient increased in the year of the pneumothorax compared to the previous year, and there were greater overall numbers of each compared to the previous year. There was greater overall utilization of services in the year of pneumothorax, resulting in 2,275 more office visits, 1,573 more hospitalizations, and 23,748 more hospital days compared to the previous year.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The principle risk factors for pneumothorax are age and severity of airways obstruction. Prior reports of pneumothorax in CF patients from single centers have suggested that the mean age of occurrence was in the mid-teen years.1 These reports were between the years 1968 and 1990. This analysis of patients in the 1990s demonstrates that pneumothorax generally occurs later in life with the mean age of occurrence in the early 20s. The median age of survival of CF patients has been increasing over time,9 presumably due to more aggressive therapies. It is likely that these therapies have delayed the progression of pulmonary impairment, resulting in the older age of initial pneumothorax.
FEV1 declines as CF patients get older, which is a consequence of chronic airways infection and inflammation, yet impairment of the FEV1 remains an important risk factor for pneumothorax, even when controlling for age. This is similar to what has been reported as risk factors for spontaneous pneumothorax in patients with other diseases, in whom the most common associations are subpleural airspace enlargement, air-trapping, and smoking.210 The use of high-resolution CT scanning of the chest at end-expiration has shown a lower lung density value in non-CF patients with spontaneous pneumothorax than in control subjects, which is consistent with the notion that air-trapping is part of the pathogenesis of this complication.2 In addition, emphysema-like changes are commonly seen in non-CF patients with spontaneous pneumothorax either by CT scan or during video-assisted thoracoscopy.11 There have been prior reports of air-trapping in CF patients with pneumothorax demonstrating a residual volume/total lung capacity ratio of 0.5612 and an average residual volume of 345% predicted.13
There is a known association between smoking and spontaneous pneumothorax.1014 Tobacco use is not reported in the registry database, so it is not possible to determine an association between smoking and pneumothorax in this population. However, studies151617 of smoking in CF patients have reported a prevalence of 8 to 21% of active CF smokers, so there is a potential for such an association.
Additional risk factors include the presence of P aeruginosa, B cepacia, and Aspergillus in the airways. The presence of specific pathogens may result in increased inflammation and airway secretions leading to obstruction of the distal airways with air-trapping. Aspergillus is commonly cultured from the sputum of CF patients, and is often thought to be a colonizer and not necessarily a pathogen.18 The presence of Aspergillus in sputum cultures may indicate ABPA, an asthma-like complication that occurs commonly in patients with CF,19 and this analysis found an increased association of ABPA with pneumothorax. The airways obstruction seen in ABPA may lead to air-trapping as a plausible pathogenesis for pneumothorax. However, most CF patients with Aspergillus present in their sputum cultures do not have ABPA. The association of Aspergillus with pneumothorax raises the possibility that the organism is a pathogen inducing airways inflammation leading to air trapping. Antibodies specific to Aspergillus fumigatus have been demonstrated in patients with CF, even in the absence of ABPA, and the authors suggested that Aspergillus may promote subclinical airways inflammation.20 There are no data to suggest that the treatment of Aspergillus colonization in patients without ABPA reduces airways obstruction or the risk of pneumothorax.
Other risk factors that are associated with pneumothorax include Medicaid insurance, pancreatic insufficiency, massive hemoptysis, and the use of the inhaled medications dornase alfa and tobramycin. There is an inverse relationship between household income and outcomes in CF patients. Lower household income has been associated with an increased risk of death.21 Medically indigent CF patients, as indicated by Medicaid insurance, have worse outcomes overall than do other CF patients.22 This association has been attributed to multiple features of the medically indigent such as nutritional deficiencies, increased tobacco use, and a lower rate of adherence to therapies.22 Trying to explain the association of pneumothorax and the other factors is challenging. Patients with pancreatic insufficiency generally have worse lung function, as do patients with massive hemoptysis.
Inhaled medications such as tobramycin and dornase alfa are used in patients with more severe lung disease.23 Although they reduce lung infection24 and promote clearance of airways secretions,25 there is also the possibility that these inhaled medications may exacerbate airways disease. Some patients experience an acute drop in FEV1 after inhaling nebulized tobramycin.2627 Such an effect could explain the association between inhaled medications and pneumothorax, although there have been no reported cases of pneumothorax in CF patients following nebulized therapy.
Pneumothorax is associated with a high rate of mortality and is a bad prognostic indicator for patients with CF. Thirty years ago, a scoring system developed as a prognostic tool for CF included pneumothorax because of a perceived association with severe disease and mortality.28 A recent or recurrent pneumothorax warranted a score of 5 (ie, 5% of the maximum score) and a history of pneumothorax at any time received a score of 3. Some analyses of large databases,293031 including the CFF Patient Registry, have tried to identify clinical parameters that predict 2-year and 5-year survival rates, but none included pneumothorax as an important criterion. This may be because it was not found to be an independent predictor or because it was excluded from analysis as < 5% of patients were affected.30 One model was found to be no better at predicting death within 2 years than was using an FEV1 of < 30% predicted as the sole predictor.31 It is evident by this analysis that a pneumothorax increases considerably the probability of dying within 2 years, especially for those with an FEV1 of > 30% predicted.
Aside from mortality, there is considerable morbidity associated with pneumothorax. The treatment of a pneumothorax typically involves the placement of a thoracostomy tube that can cause considerable pain. Some patients will need more definitive therapy, such as pleurodesis. These therapies require hospitalization, and this analysis has demonstrated a considerable increase in the number of hospitalization days in the index year, which carries substantial morbidity and cost. The increase in outpatient visits, hospitalizations, and hospital days may be the direct result of the pneumothorax or an indirect result due to the worsening impairment of pulmonary function and infection. Indeed, there is a significant decrease in lung function measured in the year following the pneumothorax, more than would have been predicted based on the previous rate of decline.
There are some important limitations to this analysis. The most important limitation is that pneumothorax incidence is likely to be underestimated in this analysis. Other diseases that cause secondary spontaneous pneumothorax, such as COPD, have had an average incidence of recurrence of 35% reported,32 with the majority of pneumothoraces occurring within the first few months after the first presentation. Although we would not be able to detect recurrent pneumothorax occurring in the same year, we might expect a higher rate of subsequent pneumothorax than we have reported here (approximately 20%). Also, patients could have experienced a pneumothorax prior to 1990 or entry into the database. There is no information in this database about the treatment of pneumothorax.
This study has several implications for therapy. First, CF patients with pneumothorax should be assessed for ABPA since specific therapy is available for this disorder. Second, it may be prudent to evaluate the effects of inhaled medications on airway reactivity in patients with more severe lung impairment. Finally, although pneumothorax increases the probability of death within 2 years, it may not play a role in the decision to refer for transplant those patients with an FEV1 of > 30% predicted.
In conclusion, spontaneous pneumothorax is a common complication of patients with CF. It occurs in about 1 in 167 patients each year, and nearly 3.5% of all CF patients will experience a pneumothorax. It typically occurs in patients who are older and who have severe obstructive airways disease. Subsequent pneumothoraces are also common, and prior studies have reported treatment failures.1 A specific study of early definitive therapy with recurrence prevention needs to be conducted in patients with this disease. There are multiple clinical factors associated with pneumothorax, including certain pathogens (especially P aeruginosa, B cepacia, and Aspergillus), pancreatic insufficiency, ABPA, and certain CF-specific inhaled therapies. Pneumothorax is a serious complication of CF, occurring in patients with advanced disease and resulting in a substantial increase in morbidity and mortality.
| Acknowledgements |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
This study was supported in part by a grant from the CFF.
Received for publication July 28, 2004. Accepted for publication January 24, 2005.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
G M Hafen, O C Ukoumunne, and P J Robinson Pneumothorax in cystic fibrosis: a retrospective case series Arch. Dis. Child., November 1, 2006; 91(11): 924 - 925. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Kappler and M. Griese Nutritional supplements in cystic fibrosis. BMJ, March 18, 2006; 332(7542): 618 - 619. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |