|
|
||||||||
Guest Access | Sign In via User Name/Password |
|||||||||
* From the Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Medicine (Drs. Jeon, Koh, H. Kim, and Kwon), Department of Radiology (Drs. T.S. Kim and Lee), and Department of Pathology (Dr. Han), Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea.
Correspondence to: Won-Jung Koh, MD, Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Medicine, Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, 50 Ilwon-dong, Kangnam-ku, Seoul 135710, South Korea; e-mail: wjkoh{at}smc.samsung.co.kr
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Patients: We retrospectively analyzed the clinical and radiologic characteristics of 36 patients (21 men and 15 women; median age 48 years; range, 19 to 75) with pulmonary paragonimiasis whose conditions were diagnosed between October 1994 and September 2004.
Results: Thirty-four patients (94%) presented with respiratory symptoms, including hemoptysis (n = 20, 56%) and cough (n = 17, 47%). However, chest pain (n = 5, 14%) and fever (n = 5, 14%) were less frequently reported. Chest radiography revealed intrapulmonary parenchymal lesions (n = 26, 72%), such as nodules (n = 14, 39%), linear opacity (n = 6, 17%), and airspace consolidations (n = 4, 11%), which occurred more commonly than did pleural lesions (n = 10, 28%). Most cases were initially suspected to be lung cancer or tuberculosis. In 13 patients with intrapulmonary parenchymal lesions who underwent bronchoscopy, bronchial luminal narrowing, coupled with congested or edematous mucosal changes, was seen in 7 patients (54%). Bronchial mucosal biopsy specimens exhibited chronic inflammation with eosinophilic infiltrations in three of these seven patients (43%).
Conclusions: Our findings indicate that patients with pulmonary paragonimiasis presented with a variety of clinical and radiologic findings that were different from the classic presentations reported earlier, frequently mimicking those of lung cancer or tuberculosis.
Key Words: diagnosis differential diagnosis Korea paragonimiasis
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The classic symptoms of pulmonary paragonimiasis include a chronic cough with rusty-brown sputum, hemoptysis, pleurisy, and fever with radiographic findings of patchy density, linear infiltration, nodules, pleural effusion, and pulmonary cavities.145212223 As these clinical manifestations are so similar to those of tuberculosis, many paragonimiasis patients are initially treated for tuberculosis.4151624 Reports from Japan,625262728 as distinct from those in the past, asserted that paragonimiasis has become more prevalent among middle-aged patients, and frequently refer to observed nodular lesions on chest radiography. These patients are often suspected by clinicians to have lung cancer.625262728 In such cases, when paragonimiasis is misdiagnosed as tuberculosis or lung cancer, patients suffer from the considerable burden associated with long-term hospitalization, as well as unnecessary diagnostic procedures and treatments.
In South Korea, known to be an area where P westermani is endemic, the incidence of the disease has recently decreased, due to improvements in public health and changes in dietary habits. Survey data taken in the 1990s indicated that the prevalence of paragonimiasis has decreased to approximately 1% of that seen in the early 1970s.29 However, at least 10% of freshwater crabs sold in local markets are infected with the metacercariae of P westermani.29 We have continuously observed clinical cases of pulmonary paragonimiasis due to the persisting tradition in a small sector of the population of eating freshwater crustaceans. Many of the patients in such cases were initially suspected to have pulmonary tuberculosis or lung cancer. We retrospectively analyzed the cases of patients with pulmonary paragonimiasis diagnosed during the most recent 10 years in order to determine whether the clinical and radiologic features of these recent cases had changed from the classic presentations reported in previous studies.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) test, an immunoserologic test for Paragonimus-specific IgG antibody, was performed on samples from 29 patients (81%).30 Sputum cytology examinations for the detection of eggs were performed in 26 patients (72%). Bronchoscopies were performed in 13 patients (36%). Lung biopsies were performed in 10 patients (28%). Transbronchial lung biopsies were performed in five patients, fluoroscopy-guided percutaneous transthoracic lung biopsies in three patients, and surgical lung biopsies in two patients.
The medical records were reviewed for information related to the clinical data of the patients, including symptoms, history of eating raw or undercooked freshwater crab or crayfishes, laboratory tests, and other diagnostic procedures. The chest radiographs of all patients were reviewed. Abnormal findings in the chest radiographs were classified into two types45: intrapulmonary parenchymal lesions, such as airspace consolidation, nodular, linear, and cystic opacity; and pleural lesions, including pleural effusion, pneumothorax, and hydropneumothorax.
All patients were treated with high doses of praziquantel, 75 mg/kg/d for 2 days. Praziquantel treatment resulted in the resolution of respiratory symptoms and abnormal chest radiography findings in all patients except three, all of whom were transferred to other institutions, usually their referring institutions, after paragonimiasis was diagnosed.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Radiologic Features
The patients presented with a variety of radiologic findings (Table 2
). Thirty-three of 36 patients (92%) displayed abnormal chest radiographic findings. The remaining three patients (8%) were found to have no radiographic abnormalities.
|
|
Confirmative Diagnosis of Paragonimiasis
The confirmative diagnosis of paragonimiasis was based on the positive result of an ELISA test (n = 28, 78%), or by the identification of characteristic Paragonimus eggs in sputum samples, bronchial washing fluid, or lung biopsy specimens (n = 14, 39%). Six patients (17%) had positive results on both an ELISA test and the examination for Paragonimus eggs in cytologic or pathologic specimens.
Paragonimus eggs were detected in the sputum of 12 patients (46%) of the 26 patients in whom sputum examinations were conducted. Lung biopsies were performed in the 10 patients initially suspected of having lung cancer based on clinical and radiologic findings (nodular opacity in 9 patients, mass-like consolidation in 1 patient). Histopathologic diagnoses of paragonimiasis were confirmed by identification of Paragonimus eggs in four patients via percutaneous transthoracic lung biopsy (n = 2) or surgical lung biopsy (n = 2) [Fig 2 ]. In the remaining six patients, parasite eggs could not be identified in the lung tissues.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Typical pulmonary paragonimiasis patients exhibit fever, chest pain, and respiratory symptoms, including a chronic cough with hemoptysis.21 The main determinants of clinical manifestation are number of infecting parasites, their location, and the stage of the infection.423 The spectrum of pulmonary paragonimiasis ranges from asymptomatic, to overt and serious disease in cases of heavy infection. Fever has been noted in 10 to 20% of patients during the lung phase, and two thirds of patients may experience occasional febrile episodes over the entire course of the disease.424 Chest pain, considered to be due to pleurisy, was generally reported in approximately 40 to 60% of cases in the previous studies.4524 However, the disease runs a chronic course, persisting from a few weeks to several years.4 According to Japanese studies,625 fever and chest pain are less frequently observed than other respiratory symptoms, which is consistent with our observation. This is probably the result of low-density infections. Due to its nonspecific manifestations, its chronic and mild course, and the low recall rate of freshwater crustacean ingestion, a correct initial diagnosis was made in only 8% of our patients.
The most common symptom was hemoptysis (56%) in the present study. The etiology for hemoptysis varies among different series according to time of publication, the geographic location, and the diagnostic tests employed. Bronchitis, bronchogenic carcinoma, and bronchiectasis are the most common causes of hemoptysis depending on the patient population studied in recently published literatures, although tuberculosis was reported as a most important cause of hemoptysis in older articles and even more recent reports from some developing countries.31323334 Based on our study results, pulmonary paragonimiasis should be considered as a possibility in the differential diagnosis when hemoptysis has developed in a patient who has lived or has traveled to paragonimiasis endemic areas.
Peripheral blood examinations allow the detection of leukocytosis and eosinophilia in many patients with pulmonary paragonimiasis.4723 In our study, 28% of patients exhibited leukocytosis, and 69% exhibited eosinophilia. Previous studies461524 reported that peripheral blood eosinophilia was observed in > 80% of paragonimiasis patients. Eosinophilia is observed only when the worms are alive and migrating.4 It disappears when the disease moves into its chronic phase.4 The degree of eosinophilia also varies from patient to patient. Japanese investigators25 reported that the degree of peripheral blood eosinophilia was significantly higher in patients with pleurisy than in patients with parenchymal lesions, indicating that eosinophilia was an acute-phase response of the host. In other words, at least some patients, especially those exhibiting parenchymal lesions, have normal eosinophilia counts in their peripheral blood. Thus, although eosinophilia is an important parameter in the suspicion of paragonimiasis at the early stages of infection, a lack of eosinophilia does not necessarily rule out the possibility of paragonimiasis.7
Pleural fluid eosinophilia, whose causes are malignancy or tuberculosis as well as pneumothorax or hemothorax,35 is reported with a high incidence in patients with paragonimiasis.15363738 Although a small number of patients had pleural effusion in this series, pleural fluid eosinophilia, as well as a low pH, was detected in 60% of patients with pleural effusion. In addition, all patients had pleural fluid with a low glucose level and a high lactate dehydrogenase level. Based on our experience and the previous reports, characteristic pleural fluid findings can be a very helpful clue in the diagnosis of pulmonary paragonimiasis.
Radiographically, pulmonary paragonimiasis can manifest in a host of ways, ranging from an absolutely normal chest radiograph to diffuse infiltrates with bilateral hydropneumothorax.4723 This is, presumably, dependent on which stage in the development of the disease has been currently reached.4723 In the previous reports, the most common manifestation observed was pleural lesions. These ranged from simple pleural thickening, to bilateral hydropneumothorax. For example, Johnson et al15 reported that five of nine paragonimiasis patients among immigrants in the United States exhibited pleural effusion. Subsequently, the researchers16 evaluated more cases, and reported that 48% of those cases involved pleural effusion. In addition, according to a host of reports62539 from Japan and Korea, nearly 70% of paragonimiasis patients exhibit pleural lesions. In our series, however, pleural lesions were relatively rare (28%). Also, the frequency of intrapulmonary parenchymal lesions was high (72%) compared to the reports of previous studies. In particular, a nodular opacity of variable diameter (median, 2.7 cm; range, 1.5 to 4.0 cm) was the most common (54%) parenchymal lesion in our study, reported by previous studies451624 to be observed in 8 to 25% of cases. The radiographic findings vary with the stage of the disease.539 Early findings include pneumothorax or hydropneumothorax, focal airspace consolidation, and linear opacities.539 Later findings include thin-walled cysts, dense mass-like consolidation, nodules, or bronchiectasis.539 This suggests that the patients in our study may have been in a later stage of paragonimiasis.
Until recently, distinguishing between paragonimiasis and tuberculosis has frequently proven to be quite difficult, and constitutes a diagnostic dilemma in areas in which tuberculosis and paragonimiasis coexist.540 For example, Singh and colleagues24 reported that 59% of their patients initially received a diagnosis of tuberculosis. Johnson and associates15 reported that 68% were receiving antituberculosis therapy. Shim and coworkers4 also reported that tuberculosis was diagnosed in 46% before the final diagnosis of pulmonary paragonimiasis was made. Our results were similar to those of others. Thirty percent of our patients had received a tentative diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis on their initial visit. Nowadays, however, differentiation between paragonimiasis and lung cancer represents a diagnostic dilemma, even in areas where paragonimiasis is enemic.6262728 Twenty-eight percent of our pulmonary paragonimiasis patients were presumed to have had lung cancer on their initial visit. These results emphasized the necessity of generating awareness among clinicians about the inclusion of paragonimiasis in the differential diagnosis of lung cancer, as well as tuberculosis.
Only a few reports have addressed the issue of endobronchial lesions in pulmonary paragonimiasis patients. Mukae et al6 reported bronchial stenosis in seven of nine patients (78%) who had undergone bronchoscopy. Our results indicated bronchial luminal narrowing, with congested or edematous mucosal changes, in 7 of 13 patients (54%), and these results were consistent with those of the previous study.6 In addition, bronchial mucosal biopsy specimens exhibited chronic inflammation with eosinophilic infiltrations in three of these seven patients (43%) in our study. To our best knowledge, no previous studies have demonstrated chronic eosinophilic inflammation in bronchial mucosal biopsy specimens, although no parasite eggs could be found in the specimens obtained from these lesions in our study. Im et al39 reported a variety of radiographic findings in 78 patients with pulmonary paragonimiasis, and bronchiectasis was observed on the chest CT scans of 6 of 17 patients. They also reported that the juvenile worms tent and settle adjacent to the small airways, forming worm cysts. Furthermore, connection of these worm cysts with the airways occurred uniformly in 21 cats with experimentally induced pulmonary paragonimiasis.39 Im et al39 suggested that prolonged bronchial inflammation, and mechanical injury of the bronchi by intrabronchial worms, may contribute to the development of bronchiectasis. Our results, combined with those of previous studies,639 indicate that P westermani infection results in an inflammation of the bronchi, culminating in bronchial stenosis or focal bronchiectasis.
Our study was done at a tertiary care center. Therefore, our study population was not representative of the general population of pulmonary paragonimiasis sufferers. Most of our patients were referred for differentiation of other pulmonary disease, usually lung cancer or tuberculosis. Therefore, it may be that the classic presentations of pulmonary paragonimiasis had simply been more easily diagnosed at outside hospitals, and the patients were never referred to the tertiary care center. Nevertheless, our findings were not dissimilar from a Japanese report6 that was conducted at a referral center for parasite disease.
In conclusion, our pulmonary paragonimiasis patients presented with a variety of clinical and radiologic findings, which in some cases mimicked those of lung cancer or tuberculosis, in a manner dissimilar to the classic presentations reported earlier. Paragonimiasis requires specific chemotherapy, resulting in immediate improvement. Correct differential diagnosis is, therefore, quite important. When a pulmonary nodular or mass lesion is detected in a patient who has lived in or traveled to paragonimiasis-endemic areas, paragonimiasis should always be included in the differential diagnosis of lung diseases. Pulmonary paragonimiasis will inevitably be encountered more frequently by physicians in various parts of the world, due to increasing numbers of immigrants and overseas travelers, and changes in global dietary patterns.
| Footnotes |
|---|
This work was supported by grant R112002-103 from the Korea Science and Engineering Foundation.
Received for publication December 2, 2004. Accepted for publication January 24, 2005.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |